Ruqaiyyafication of Mughal Sultanat, Abhay Post Pg 1

RadhikaS0 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Hi Friends,


Apologies once more! Have been missing here (again) for the last few days. :( I was partly busy with the festivities, partly depressed by the story line and partly handicapped, as my computer was out of service. I am still depressed by the story line. But life goes on and here's my take on the trend the show is taking, or, rather, took last week.

The Repenting Emperor

Jalal seeks Salim Chisti's blessings so that he can get sukoon. (And an heir?) Chisti Sahab doesn't let him get off the hook so easily. He tells Jalal that he has to repent for every person he killed in Chittor and only his conscience can tell him when he has atoned completely. Only then can Jalal get sukoon and an heir. To quote him, Salim Chisti tells AkDha that what they lost cannot be returned to them nor can they be compensated for it. But they can get what they seek if Jalal's slate is wiped clean of the Chittor massacre.

JJ agree to live like an ordinary couple at Sikri during this period of penance. (Seemingly 3 years ?, as Javeda's and Bakshi's kids are quite grown up during this time.)

Side Note: History aficionados and those to whom Chittor holds a special place in their hearts still, please bear with me. I am only recounting verbatim what was shown to us. I felt sick too to see Ekta Kapoor turning history on its head and showing Akbar repenting for Chittor and actually going out of his way to rebuild the lives of the people there. The truth, as we all know, is that he actually celebrated his victory at Chittor and sadistically ordered the massacre of some 30,000 peasants in cold blood. Chittor was never rebuilt or repaired or resettled.
How an emperor could stay away from the affairs of the state for so long, leaving Agra in the hands of his ministers like Todarmal and his mother and begums, is beyond me. If I remember correctly, Jalal could not stay away from Agra during the separation track and had returned to Agra alone, leaving Jodha in Amer.

Why is Akbar being justified so much by Ekta? First, he was given the excuse of being emotionally distraught for waging the war. Now he is being shown to repent and take suitable remedial measures.

Jalal's repentance must have been almost over because he is blessed with the good news of Jodha's pregnancy in the Wednesday episode (Oct 22 2014). The entire pregnancy is done away with in just one episode! Why the rush, Ekta?

Jodha was treated roughly in her last pregnancy and this time too, she has not been pampered at all. We have to guess Jalal pampers her from their words to Salim Chisti. Jodha is gifted a new bandi, Shahzad Bano, to take care of her.

Akbar, as we know, didn't see Salim for one month after he was born, due to astrological reasons. Why couldn't Jalal tell the truth to Jodha? Surely, she would have understood that it was best for Akbar not to see Salim for some days? Why did Ekta have to bring in this issue of the woman who was widowed by Jalal, and show Jalal going to Chittor to personally rehabilitate her?

Salim was born in Sikri on Thursday (Diwali), in the absence of Jalal. On Friday, he was home in the palace and with Jalal, his father. So, a small leap of one month again on Friday!

I couldn't understand Jalal telling Jodha now after 3 years that he was with her at all times and she needn't apologize to anyone, after having accepted her apology for Hussein's death. Why was the twins' death raised after so long, esp on a joyous occasion? Why was Jodha made to seek Ruqaiyya's pardon too for being careless enough to kill Hussein and thus rendering Ruqaiyya childless? Why was the Jalal who had promised his support to Jodha just a few minutes back silent, as Jodha sought Ruqaiyya's pardon and Ruqaiyya shed crocodile tears, when he knew Ruqaiyya's reality?

All these leaps and Jodha being made to apologize to all and sundry for no fault of hers and being made to repent for 3 years for Jalal's crimes can be set aside when we see the worst NR till date, second only to the Chittor NR. This relates to the emergence of Ruqaiyya as the tour de force of the show. It's fine she wasn't punished or even exposed. But making her the main lead of the show, while the erstwhile leads, AkDha, danced around her to her tune, is unbelievable.


Ruqaiyya, the Most Powerful Mughal Ever?

Slowly, over the last few episodes, we were informed that Ruqaiyya had got over the tragic demise of Hussein but had 'lost her narmi' and was crueler still, if that is possible. We saw Jalal scold her for indirectly causing the deaths of the twins but he also gave her his word that he would remain her friend forever. The only saving grace was that he refused to hand over Salim to Ruqaiyya.

At that point in time, I really felt very envious of Ruqaiyya. It must mean something to be able to get away with anything, including the death of royal heirs, just because she happened to be the childhood friend of the emperor. Au contraire, Jodha, being an ordinary princess, has to apologize to everyone for not committing any mistake. Is it Jodha's sin if Ruqaiyya's mission to be the MUZ failed?

Ruqaiyya being Ruqaiyya, now thinks that if Jodha has to be the MUZ, then she should only be the MUZ and not the ammijaan too of Salim, the waris. Now she has come up with a new crooked plan according to which she will ensure that Salim regards his mother as only the MUZ but not his mother. She plans to ensure that Salim will regard only Ruqaiyya as his mother. All this to hurt Jodha because Ruqaiyya knows that, for Jodha, the MUZ title holds no relevance but being mother to Salim does.

Ruqaiyya now plans to use Salim to separate JJ, as she feels he was responsible for bringing them together. Doesn't she know that they came together first and, that is why, they were able to produce Salim?

Friday also saw the entry of Anarkali's parents and hinted at the imminent entry of Anarkali herself.

Ekta, how many more NRs are we going to be subjected to? Which research showed you that Anarkali was a historical character? Please share your research with us too.

The worst possible scene for me personally, not taking Chittor into account, was Jodha thrusting Salim into the scheming Ruqaiyya's hands and begging her to accept him and forgive her (Jodha). Why can't Jodha accept that Hussein was poisoned by Zeenat and it was not her fault? Why must Jodha force Salim into Ruqaiyya's hands and call her his true "badi ammijaan"? Why must Jodha insist on Ruqaiyya sharing the joys of motherhood with her?

I have never heard from any quarters so far that Ruqaiyya was involved in raising Salim exclusively. Or that Salim regarded Ruqaiyya as his real mother and called Jodha MUZ. Salim was close to all 3 chief queens of Akbar and quite respected his own mother. He even addressed her as Hazrat.

Just to glorify Ruqaiyya, Ekta is running down both Jalal and Jodha. Jalal looks like a spineless jellyfish in front of Ruqaiyya and Jodha is quite the baby-producing machine for Ruqaiyya to fulfill her ambitions of being the most powerful Mughal ever.

Has anyone ever read that Ruqaiyya was so powerful that she had the run of the empire, her wish was above everything, and even Akbar couldn't say no to her?

Why is Ekta deliberately running down Jodha's importance? And why is she destroying Jalal's character too, in the process?
Updates: Oct 28 29

PS: Abhay's posts: Link1 Link2
Edited by RadhikaS0 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

563

Views

35k

Users

40

Likes

1.6k

Frequent Posters

jiya.k thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Jo kabhi nazaro ki raah dil ko sukoon deta tha, Jo kabhi nazaro ki raah dil ko sukoon deta tha...aaj haal-e-dil yeh hai ki ek nazar galti se kanhi uss par na padh jaye iska dil me khuaf hai...
Edited by jiya.k - 10 years ago
Charu.S thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Awesome analysis as usual Radhika. You have said it all very aptly. I echo your thoughts in every aspect of your arguments .In order to avoid further disappointment, I'm completely avoiding the serial.I have to come to terms with the fact that in order to be happy,I have to watch JA as if it is a regular soap drama and not attach any historical value or logic to it . Now this is going to be extremely hard to do.So I'm going take a break until I can console myself to accept watching history and historical figures being insulted.
Keep writing. I enjoy reading your views and arguments.


Charu.
history_geek thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Hi Radhika,

Was quite busy for the last few days. Logged in and found so many messages / queries from friends. I can see, like you, many people are getting fed up with the scheme of this show now, but thanks to this habit of watching JA, still continued with it..!!.

Thanks for this post, i can see how the show is progressing now after reading this update...
Hats off to your patience for putting down these points..

Will post later as replies to the views here, and catch up with you all, and pending PMs "soon". ;p

Brilliant Post..!!..👏


I shared the foll. before also.Posting again.

1. Here is an OLD Link about Jahangir's relation with his mother..

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/105448260

2. Also, see this post, note the last point..
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/104559472


Salim as we know , was the ONLY Mughal
Emperor to touch the feet of his mother but Ekta Kapoor is hell bent at destroying all that.😕.




Edited by history_geek - 10 years ago
jiya.k thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
brilliant post Radhika...hats off u...
NutellaWaffle thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail 11th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Radhika wonderfully written and the title is so apt for present condition of mughal sultanat... Its all abt rukayya rukayya and rukayya and where r Jodha akbar in this show?? Ur last para says evrythng... Jalal is numb spineless person infront of ruk and jo is baby producing machine for her... Our JA is over with such tragic ending of jalal who said that he wil b with her at tough times left her and blamed her for three years and rukayya go scotfree in death of twins... Jalal dint even apologise jo aftr meeting her aftr three years and immediately their third sr was done which was horrible to watch at that situation being soulmates... This serial did injustice to Jodha jalal chadacters in name of epic love story... Out cvs r bothered abt ruk and how to give her more screenspace and how to increase negativity in serial... It's all abt ruk harem ruk games ruk plots ruk jealousy ruk smirks ruk slaps kicks ruk blunders ruk bachpan dost ruk Audha ruk MUZ obsession ruk as evil... No JJ anywer... It's tough for me to see JJ lik that and ruk winning over them all time... I shud stop watching JA which is difficult for me but I wil try...
Goras thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: jiya.k

Jo kabhi nazaro ki raah dil ko sukoon deta tha, Jo kabhi nazaro ki raah dil ko sukoon deta tha...aaj haal-e-dil yeh hai ki ek nazar galti se kanhi uss par na padh jaye iska dil me khuaf hai...



Bahut khoob likha hai👏
MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Radhika, today was first day of skipping watching RukAkbar show.

I am glad to say I did not miss it much and spared myself headache and nausea!

I have no interest in watching Ruk glorification and if that means I stop watching Paridhi & Rajat that is ok. Cos where are Jodha & Jalal I loved?

The fiery proud Jodha who broke a vase when Jalal said sorry after falsely blaming her in Ruk mc saying trust once broken cannot be mended. The clever proud fiery self respecting Jodha - is replaced by stupid foolish doormat without a shred of self respect.

Jalal who loved Jodha is also gone. In his place is callous selfish husband who hid from Jodha that Ruk wanted Salim for Hussain, who let Jodha say sorry to him and Ruk knowing it was Ruk's fault. Jalal who treats Jodha like a verbal punching bag and baby producing machine - Jalal who is a spineless coward in front of Ruk

I have given up on JA - cos it is NO LONGER JA - love story is over - Jodha Jalal I loved are gone - Ruk? watching 1 min of her face on my tv is bringing repulsiveness inside my home so no thanks.

If I get feedback about some good scene I will watch ONLY JodhaJalal online and spare myself from watching Rukayyafication and LT obsession of CVs.

So the JA sick Cvs can take a leap off a cliff could not care less

MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Akdhaparijatluv

Radhika wonderfully written and the title is so apt for present condition of mughal sultanat... Its all abt rukayya rukayya and rukayya and where r Jodha akbar in this show?? Ur last para says evrythng... Jalal is numb spineless person infront of ruk and jo is baby producing machine for her... Our JA is over with such tragic ending of jalal who said that he wil b with her at tough times left her and blamed her for three years and rukayya go scotfree in death of twins... Jalal dint even apologise jo aftr meeting her aftr three years and immediately their third sr was done which was horrible to watch at that situation being soulmates... This serial did injustice to Jodha jalal chadacters in name of epic love story... Out cvs r bothered abt ruk and how to give her more screenspace and how to increase negativity in serial... It's all abt ruk harem ruk games ruk plots ruk jealousy ruk smirks ruk slaps kicks ruk blunders ruk bachpan dost ruk Audha ruk MUZ obsession ruk as evil... No JJ anywer... It's tough for me to see JJ lik that and ruk winning over them all time... I shud stop watching JA which is difficult for me but I wil try...




Bhavana, I did not watch today and spared myself headache and nausea of having to watch Ruk face.
I hope I can stop watching JA totally

SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: JAfanCharu

Awesome analysis as usual Radhika. You have said it all very aptly. I echo your thoughts in every aspect of your arguments .In order to avoid further disappointment, I'm completely avoiding the serial.I have to come to terms with the fact that in order to be happy,I have to watch JA as if it is a regular soap drama and not attach any historical value or logic to it . Now this is going to be extremely hard to do.So I'm going take a break until I can console myself to accept watching history and historical figures being insulted.

Keep writing. I enjoy reading your views and arguments.


Charu.



Beautifully written Radhika and totally totally with you. 👏👏

I am with Charu here. I too stopped watching JA. so long bore it for Parijat. but now cant do it any more...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".