Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 24
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 06 Aug 2025 EDT
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 07 Aug 2025 EDT
SHIFTING BACK 6.8
GRUHA🏠PRAVESH 7.8
Dharma..what a downfall!!
Janaabe Aali - War 2 - Hrithik Jr NTR Dance Face Off
Anupamaa 06 Aug 2025 Written Update & Daily Discussions Thread
What if (Fun Post)
She Ijj Bekkkkk?
War 2 shows in New Zealand removed due to ZERO bookings on 1st Day
Dil Se or Kuch Kuch Hota Hai?
Which mihir you prefer
Legacy and Longing: Inspiring Leaders/Heroes You Want to See Back!
This is when I haven't even watched the entire episode. You're strong that you left it . I am way too attached to this show but CVs have destroyed it mercilessly.
Originally posted by: JAfanCharu
Hi guys ,
Hi charu,
Hope you had a wonderful diwali and may this diwali bring you all happiness,health and prosperity...I finally caught up watching four episodes back to back , that I had missed due to a busy week of Diwali preparations. I was appalled at what I saw . Disappointed and angry are mild words to describe my reactions to the story line .
True.. At least we took it in stages .. Couldn't imagine how you would have felt watching it all in a go..The circumstances leading to the Chittor war and the depiction of the war itself was distorted , misleading and disgusting . EK actually got away with this horrible depiction . Where are all the groups who were protesting against the show earlier ? Their presence is desperately needed now .I was horrified that Jodha actually apologized to Jalal for spending intimate moments with him . 😡 😡 😡 😡 . Just as I had anticipated , Jalal cried his eyes out , Jodha hugged him and all the unjust accusations heaped on her were instantly nullified .I never knew that feeding the hungry , watering plants out of clay matkas , wearing plain clothes , no chappals and living in a hut , could absolve a man of killing thousands of innocent people 😡 😡. My reaction to that scene was one of complete disbelief 😲 😲 😲 😲 .
Whatever you had said completely echos what many of us have felt.. This is the main reason i don't watch mega serials..Except a few which are refreshingly different.. most of them follow this same formula.. this is their way of sanctifying their heros and heroines and they expect us to admire this ,but in real we are left appalled..My mistake was to believe that this a historical fiction and they wouldn't do it here as there are many facts out in open and they have to respect it .. but sadly it seems they decided to not even consider that this is based on legends...What was Rukaiya doing today , dumping a bowl full of sand on her head ? 😲 😲 😡 😡 . How I wish that sand has some cleansing powers to it , she will benefit from it . What exactly is her problem ? Is this behavior befitting a queens' ? I wish her character had really gone six feet under and left all of us in peace . I cannot begin to imagine all her atrocities , now that Jodha has repeated the blunder of bestowing the title of 'badi ammijaan' on her . When will Jodha and Jalal learn ? When will EK stop portraying Jodha and Jalal as clueless , brainless idiots ? She is insulting and disrespecting the two beautiful historical characters in every way possible . Is putting Rukaiya on a pedestal Ekta's idea of respecting 'naari shakti ' ? It definitely seems like it . She is respecting the wrong naari's 😡 negative shakti .
True..I'm happy i didn't watch it.. it could have been so unbearable...After finally receiving his waaris in Salim, after undergoing so many hardships , I expected Jalal to have a small ceremony for Jodha to be bestowed with the title of MUZ . Instead I had to be content with a portrait session of Jodha / Salim, with Jodha wearing an oversized crown that indicated her having received the title . Maybe EK did not want to upset Rukaiya with an elaborate MUZ title ceremony 😡 for Jodha .
During HH's birth they don't show any festivity and i was thinking they are reserving it all for salim's birth. I THought they would show the whole of agra lightened and rejoicing at an emperors birth .. and grand celebrations in amer too.. and a jashn for jo... but they are in such a fast track they don't want to show anything good dedicating all time for ruqs plan and pain which left me wondering why don't they change the title...I am cursing ( Maham's influence 😉 ) myself for catching up with those missed episodes . I have wound myself up all over again . I can confidently say that today's episode was my last one for JA . There is no way I can sit for half an hour everyday and watch Rukaiya putting her wicked plans to action and gloat over Jodha's misery, by manipulating an innocent and unsuspecting little Salim .Sorry for venting my frustration, shock and disgust over the deceptive and disgraceful depiction of history and historical characters . All my forum friends, please forgive my verbal tirade .
There is nothing to be sorry about charu .. we all are in the same boat disgusted with this ,..Charu .
True.. The cvs have destroyed it mercilessly and like donjas said its so painful to see something you loved so much die before you .,reading wu's doesn't bring that kind of agitation you get when watching it on onscreen and i was in dire need of creating a detachment as it has started affecting me personally too. after seeing an episode i'm being agitated for hours ...
Originally posted by: history_geek
Hi all,
Will be Busy till Monday morning.
But just to say one thing as a common reply to MANY PMs ..
Salim referred his mother as "Hazrat" ..This reference was not used for Ruqs or even Salima Begum..!!!!!! << This reference is normally attributed to Sufi Saints and HIGHLY respected people..
Even Akbar bestowed the title of "Wali Ni'maat" on MUZ, which again points towards the Sufi leanings of MUZ..Note that Sufi's were people known for religious tolerance...
Not only Salim, Khusrau was also close to her , and called her with same reference as Salim.
The NONSENSE of Ekta Kapoor is NOW getting on my nerves...!!. First Chittor and NOW glorification of vamps..!!.
There is no doubt that Ruqs was a master conspirator, but Salim was very much close to his OWN mother.!!.
It is true that Salim respected all 3 > MUZ, Ruqayya and Salima...But it was NOT that he was NOT close to his OWN mother...It is Absolute rubbish if Ekta shows Jodha crying buckets now.!!.🤢.
You can see this link..>>
1. Here is an OLD Link about Jahangir's relation with his mother..
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/105448260
2. Also, see this post, note the last point..
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/104559472
3. I won't be able to explain again about the name of mother of Daniyal..I have already told so in my Kids Post, and i stand by that. Don't tell me that it is Anarkali..!!.😉
I will update my Blog on this issue later in Details.!!!!.These days very busy...
I dont know why Jalal and Jodha are reduced to dumb onlookers and Ruqs is given so much importance..
Originally posted by: SindhuMenon
@bold: exactly Priya..
Originally posted by: history_geek
Hi all,
Will be Busy till Monday morning.
But just to say one thing as a common reply to MANY PMs ..
Salim referred his mother as "Hazrat" ..This reference was not used for Ruqs or even Salima Begum..!!!!!! << This reference is normally attributed to Sufi Saints and HIGHLY respected people..
Even Akbar bestowed the title of "Wali Ni'maat" on MUZ, which again points towards the Sufi leanings of MUZ..Note that Sufi's were people known for religious tolerance...
Not only Salim, Khusrau was also close to her , and called her with same reference as Salim.
The NONSENSE of Ekta Kapoor is NOW getting on my nerves...!!. First Chittor and NOW glorification of vamps..!!.
There is no doubt that Ruqs was a master conspirator, but Salim was very much close to his OWN mother.!!.
It is true that Salim respected all 3 > MUZ, Ruqayya and Salima...But it was NOT that he was NOT close to his OWN mother...It is Absolute rubbish if Ekta shows Jodha crying buckets now.!!.🤢.
You can see this link..>>
1. Here is an OLD Link about Jahangir's relation with his mother..
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/105448260
2. Also, see this post, note the last point..
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/104559472
3. I won't be able to explain again about the name of mother of Daniyal..I have already told so in my Kids Post, and i stand by that. Don't tell me that it is Anarkali..!!.😉
I will update my Blog on this issue later in Details.!!!!.These days very busy...
I dont know why Jalal and Jodha are reduced to dumb onlookers and Ruqs is given so much importance..
Hi Abhay,
You have said it. I have read the same things regarding Salim's relationship with HK. Daniyal's mother wasn't Anarkali... There was no Anarkali yaar.. I don't understand why Ekta loves her so? is she planning to take up this role herself?
Jodha's dialogues made me want to throw something at my tv and I almost threw my phone at it. I cannot tell you how disgusted i am.This is annoying me no end.
I hope ekta doesn't make Salim call Jodha MUZ. why is she hell bent on distorting every minute detail?
Kuch to rehne do.. This is utter CRAP!!!!