Wht;s the big deal wit puja?

angierockzzz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Firstly i wanna say tht i don't wanna offend anyone wit my thread...i'm starting this topic becoz i really wanna noe something...i noe thr r lot of puja supporters here...and some are really vociferous and can't tolerate a single word against her...but still i'm someone who sticks to her own guns..so i'm daring to ask something like this...i wanna noe wht's the big deal with puja chatterjee???? y is she praised like she's the best thing since sliced bread...don't get me wrong i think she's certainly good.....defiantely better than ankita, vartika, harshida and all....but comeone yaar...am i onli one who feels tht thr is childish tinge to her voice...every song of her's seem like a child is singing them.....i mean as a singer she is good...she takes all alaps and harkats very well...but the basic voice quality is raw, not polished, immature type....and plus her pronunciation is also rather bad....so let's not ignore these fine points at such an important competiton....tht's wht i feel....i hope i'm not ripped to shreds by puja fans....try to look at it objectively ..and see if any of my points make sense or not.....😕

Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

3.4k

Users

25

Frequent Posters

mango-frost thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
well yes she does have this childish sound to her voice...but u noe went they say "awaaz mein khanak hai"....i think that childish voice is the khanak in her voice...which makes her different from others...

richa also has the childlike voice...but hers is different...hers seems like itz not polished and itz immature...whereas puja's seems like itz polished...just sounds abit immature but has that haunting quality to it...

the rest u have mentioned...sur taal harkats etc...everything is perfect for her.. 😊
atria thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Her sur, taal, harkat is usually pretty good. She also sings the songs with the correct feel. As for the childishness in her voice, it shows only sometimes, but already her voice shows immense possibillity, it has a lot more depth as compared to Shifa then Richa. So you may not like her, your choice, but many of us feel she is really good! 👏
angierockzzz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: srk_lover

well yes she does have this childish sound to her voice...but u noe went they say "awaaz mein khanak hai"....i think that childish voice is the khanak in her voice...which makes her different from others...

richa also has the childlike voice...but hers is different...hers seems like itz not polished and itz immature...whereas puja's seems like itz polished...just sounds abit immature but has that haunting quality to it...

the rest u have mentioned...sur taal harkats etc...everything is perfect for her.. 😊

Okk...lemme give u a big thanku for not getting madddd at meee....and i can see someof ur points....but like u compared between puja and richa...i think the other way around.....tht while both sound childish..but richa's baisc voice sounds more well-trained and puja's sounds raw....but maybe i'm wrong there...😕

username88 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
lol dun b scared
ye ur ryt, she needs 2 work hard on her pronounciation n i dun think her voice is all that childish, esp compared 2 shifa n richa
shes rely talented...n wen she sings i jus love it
b4begin thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
well. i did not felt the same way as you did with puja but it is definitely the case with richa. Everything in her song is good but the childish voice kills everything.
mango-frost thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: angierockzzz

Okk...lemme give u a big thanku for not getting madddd at meee....and i can see someof ur points....but like u compared between puja and richa...i think the other way around.....tht while both sound childish..but richa's baisc voice sounds more well-trained and puja's sounds raw....but maybe i'm wrong there...😕

why wud i get mad at u? just cuz shes my fav doesnt mean she has to be urz...i respect ur thuts..

well yes richa's voice is well-trained....but her voice quality is child-like....u can tell shes a 16 year old girl singing...whereas puja's is more polished i feel...even her voice is well-trained....she wudnt be able to sing the songs with so much perfection if it was well-trained...

and wat atria said....we like puja cuz she sings each song with a correct feel/mood....she gets fully into the song and sings it with perfection....whereas her childlike voice is concerned...shes 18...it will mature...give it sumtime....otherwise she has everything....

same for richa...👏

Edited by srk_lover - 18 years ago
angierockzzz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: srk_lover

why wud i get mad at u? just cuz shes my fav doesnt mean she has to be urz...i respect ur thuts..

well yes richa's voice is well-trained....but her voice quality is child-like....u can tell shes a 16 year old girl singing...whereas puja's is more polished i feel...

and wat atria said....we like puja cuz she sings each song with a correct feel/mood....she gets fully into the song and sings it with perfection....whereas her childlike voice is concerned...shes 18...it will mature...give it sumtime....otherwise she has everything....

same for richa...👏

i agree wit u here....😃

mango-frost thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
great 😊

and u said richa's voice is well-trained....so is puja's...i editted my previous post to add that bit in
angierockzzz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: tpam

how do yu judge a singer as well trained??? doing harkateys?? i never hav seen amey date or karunya or meenal or any gr88 singer doing unnecesary harkatey???
they do whereever necessary and richa tries to do harkateys and prove she is more trained bt loses on sur !!
where as puja and deepali they r more well trained and more pakka in sur u need to sing songs the way it shud be sung !! rite?

i hope she sings a classical one and shuts up every1.. bt stil i feel even if she does that ppl here wil remain biased and never approve her talent

i ahve no comments to ur post..becoz i know u r someone who takes any criticism of ur fav's veryy personally...so no comments here frm my side

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".