Wht;s the big deal wit puja? - Page 6

Originally posted by: tpam

yess i am soo much with yu... u dnt need to praise some1 u dnt like bt be impartial.. wen some1 performs awesome then atleast giv the creadit u maynt like the person soo wat?? and hate thread is not allowed soo some1 saying puja sucks out here in open forum ..... and thats why we want this to be closed!!

and moreover i dnt like many of the contestants bt i am never bothered abt whom i dnt like .. i am there to cheer whom i like i think thats a better way !!

abt the 1st highlighted part...if wht u r saying is true and one shld onli say something if they wanna praise someone and not if they wanna critisize....theh all the critics in the world shld be banned.....and ppl shld onli say good things abt movies, dramas, art or any kind.....just like there are fans, there are critics...and one needs both so as not to get complacent....

now for the 2nd part...this is by no means a hate thread....coz i don't hate puja...she's a cute little girl..but she has submitted herself to be in the public eye..and ofcourse when one does tht u are not always gonna get flattering responses....i started this thread and have not called anybody any names..wht anybody else posts i cannot control..but for tht asking for the thread to be closed is unfair...u r being undemocratic...

Originally posted by: tpam

yess i am soo much with yu... u dnt need to praise some1 u dnt like bt be impartial.. wen some1 performs awesome then atleast giv the creadit u maynt like the person soo wat?? and hate thread is not allowed soo some1 saying puja sucks out here in open forum ..... and thats why we want this to be closed!!

and moreover i dnt like many of the contestants bt i am never bothered abt whom i dnt like .. i am there to cheer whom i like i think thats a better way !!

Criticism does not always mean that one sucks! Don't read too much into the deductions here. Its all about an attitude...you can accept any criticism as constructive or destructive. Everyone has a right to their opinion here. It would be wrong to oppress one's right to voice their opinion just because you do not agree with them.

Originally posted by: goodstuff

I TOTALLY agree..puja sucks..then again almost all the girls suck..this is depressing!! lol 😆 😉

no hate post/topics are allowed...

this topic was started to noe why puja fans liked puja...which the puja fan's answered and the topic starter understood....😊

this topic was left open becuz there was constructive criticism being discussed towards puja...which is absolutely fine....but seems the topic is turning into a puja/richa/shifa bashing topic now...which is definately not allowed...

please discuss puja's performances based on reasonable judgement...not ur personal likings or dislikings...

we will see how this topic continues from here on....den take the needed actions 😊

Originally posted by: srk_lover

no hate post/topics are allowed...

this topic was started to noe why puja fans liked puja...which the puja fan's answered and the topic starter understood....😊

this topic was left open becuz there was constructive criticism being discussed towards puja...which is absolutely fine....but seems the topic is turning into a puja/richa/shifa bashing topic now...which is definately not allowed..

megha hw can we control wht ppl post...this way anybody can post anything in any topic..so r we gonna lock all threads??????.....the thread is not started with the aim of calling any names of bashing anybody..so locking it will be unjust..and unfair..i feel...just for one or two bad ppl everyone must not suffer

thas y it isnt locked rite? 😉

but the aim of this topic was to noe why puja fans like puja...and ur question was answered...

but styl...itz left open for discussion...im not closing it 😕

i just gave a warning so it doesnt continue...we've had to do that with richa topics, suhit topics...we're not biased 😊

lol okkk so I guess I sounded more harsh than I meant to be! I was saying it in the sense that i'm not "satisfied"..lol but I still think the girls need to improve, and the judges need to do a better job of criticism..I notice that they blow a person up, and forget to tell her she still needs to work on her singing on the same note, so no one is improving as much. I still think the girls this year are not good. And I still think Puja is not that great as the judges make her out to be. Her voice is too childish and I don't get "sukoon" listening to any of the songs. I am yet waiting though!? And some people need to relax on this thread, u're getting all offended, and not noticing that my posts are not out of anger and hate, but humour..lol!

Completely agree. Charu , Deepali are way better than her. I don't find her voice that great.

Originally posted by: angierockzzz

Firstly i wanna say tht i don't wanna offend anyone wit my thread...i'm starting this topic becoz i really wanna noe something...i noe thr r lot of puja supporters here...and some are really vociferous and can't tolerate a single word against her...but still i'm someone who sticks to her own guns..so i'm daring to ask something like this...i wanna noe wht's the big deal with puja chatterjee???? y is she praised like she's the best thing since sliced bread...don't get me wrong i think she's certainly good.....defiantely better than ankita, vartika, harshida and all....but comeone yaar...am i onli one who feels tht thr is childish tinge to her voice...every song of her's seem like a child is singing them.....i mean as a singer she is good...she takes all alaps and harkats very well...but the basic voice quality is raw, not polished, immature type....and plus her pronunciation is also rather bad....so let's not ignore these fine points at such an important competiton....tht's wht i feel....i hope i'm not ripped to shreds by puja fans....try to look at it objectively ..and see if any of my points make sense or not.....😕

Firstly, I may or may not agree with you all the time, but I certainly admire your guts because you always pick up those red button topics, which people wont dare to do otherwise. So I applaud you. :)

Back to the topic, I definitely agree with you there. I've found Puja to be immensely overrated, while she has sung well and has maintained a good track record, I do not find her voice to be AS impressive as the judges do. Seriously, her nasal twang does get to me at times and she desperately needs to work on the diction, but otherwise, she is a good singer....just not all that, IMO.

Originally posted by: FrenchieRox

Firstly, I may or may not agree with you all the time, but I certainly admire your guts because you always pick up those red button topics, which people wont dare to do otherwise. So I applaud you. :)

Back to the topic, I definitely agree with you there. I've found Puja to be immensely overrated, while she has sung well and has maintained a good track record, I do not find her voice to be AS impressive as the judges do. Seriously, her nasal twang does get to me at times and she desperately needs to work on the diction, but otherwise, she is a good singer....just not all that, IMO.

hehehehehe....thnx...i guess 😕...😆...yea i do kinda have a knack to fall a*s backwards into sensitive subjects...it's becoz when i have an opinion i always speak my mind..whether ppl like it or not and whether anybody agrees wit me or not...😃