Originally posted by: pakeezah
I dont think its script sense or anything
who would think a Talaash with Aamir is wrong script?
If out n out different Barfi is hit why couldnt breezy romcom
GTPM instead of disaster
If Madhur Bhandarkars Chandni Bar and Fashion are huge
hits and critically acclaimed, wont heroine centric Heroine
sound good?
How does script sense come in? Its more to do with dynamics
of KKK being in the movie that bungled things up. Dont know
bout talaash, Im sure perfectionist Aamir tied all loose ends up
inspite of that it fizzled out, but GTPM, the director was busy
running around trying to get dates fixed for madam producer
saahabs mooh boli behna thru karan, how could he concentrate
on making a good movie? An older looking jaded heroine has
been forced on him opp a chikna hero and he has to make it work?
They look like aunty bhanja and he is supposed to create roaring
romantic chemistry? If the karma and energy is right even that works
like with chikna Shahid and Vidya in Kismat Konnection, but here,
no.
For Heroine, Im sure given freedom to work with his vision, Bhandarkar
would hv created another Fashion. But, no..he was so in awe of
getting KKK and so eager to show up madam Aishwarya, he
concentrated more on KKK than film Heroine. Result disaster.
Anyway, reason Vidya Kaajol are doing well post marriage is
they are doing age appropriate roles...not running round trees
and pouting into camera wearing 20year olds clothes.
Most of the movies being made hv heroines running around trees
trying to seduce heroes. Naturally such roles will go to younger
tribe, Deepika kat PC. They look the parts.
KKKs problem is she is paralyzed by fear of graduating to older
women roles and cannot accept she is no longer suited to running
around trees. She is hellbent on slotting herself still with Deepika,
Kat and Pee Cee and sadly, the camera does not lie.
6