God - Adi and Sugni Jodi????? - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

71

Views

5.6k

Users

28

Likes

337

Frequent Posters

Hillylove thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: Istila

Julie,

Telling a lie deliberately and hiding the truth to prevent ruining lives are not the same things. While I agree that Vikram should have done the honourable thing and told Sughni the truth, Vikram was not given enough time. He was totally overwhelmed and confused.

He was still adjusting to the initial shock of seeing Reva suddenly come back to life and dealing with her mental health & physical abuse. Vikram himself was not in his normal state of mind. He was going through the initial stages of shock, trauma and was in denial.

Sughni first pursued him to marry her before he had the chance to think about proposing to her officially. Deeply in love with Sughni, with his emotions running everywhere, he was rushed in the decision of marrying her, even though his intention was first to divorce Reva after her recovery and getting the whole family agreeing for them to wed. Gulabiya accelerated this issue being blinded with her cloud of suspicions.

Vikram tried to tell Sughni the whole truth, but she was not ready to listen. Both women, Reva & Sughni threatened to kill themselves. Vikram was caught between a rock and a hard place.

This follows a similar theme from the classic novel, Jane Eyre, when she gets to know the truth she feels hurt and leaves Rochester but returns to marry him when she finds out he becomes blind and injured (thanks to his mad wife who sets him and the whole house on fire).

Here's the video clip showing Vikram's own feelings when he was accused of lying from 3.08.2012 @ 3.00:

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=luOEITNNFhg[/YOUTUBE]

Istila you are very correct, that is exactly what happened. I clearly remember the scene with Vikram and Dhanuma, he was going to tell Sugni the truth and he was planning to divorce Reva first.
Hillylove thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: merrydock

i think this is what they mean when they say God workes in mysterious ways. what is ordained happens, if sugni thinks she is in love with vickram may she is not really in love with him, but a shadow of Aditya that she was first in vickram.

i know i may not make sense but life does not make sense sometimes and you let things happen because they do, the end result will always be what it is ment to be.
if Aditya and Sugni were not ment to be then Aditya would not have fallen in love with her knowing that she loves his uncle. now isnt that ironic.
may be this is what makes Sugni and Aditya the same, why they both walk the same parth. both in a relationship with another as in Vikram and Amrith. but both thrown together due to sacrafice they both feel they are making.
and then comes the even biger sacrafice that is being made again by Aditya who is now in love with sugni but is sacraficing her becaues he thinks she will be happy with vikram whome she thinks she loves.
isnt that kind of twisted. Sugni loves Vikram, but is willing to sacrafice her love for him for his marriage. Aditya who thinks is in love with Amrith and sacrafices her to save his the uncles marriage by marrying the girl his uncle loves, but in turn actually finds out that he is truly in love with the same girl but now is willing to sacrafice that love because the girl concerned is in love with his uncle. and the uncle who is married wants to break of a realtionship with his wife. becauese he loves sugni, who he lies to, sets her against her mother. will do anything as well as killl his nephue to have her but who is really a selfish person concerned with only himself, his love, his pain, his need.
so it think Aditya and sugni are more alike. and are really ment to be as they mirror each other. and vickram is only a shadow that does not always stay true to form not like a image in the mirror that is exactly what it reflects.

Thanks for Responding to my Post😃 I like the long post, it means you have put thought into your answer and you like debates.😃

Well, in response to your post, I would say that you are right life may seem to not make sense a lot of times, but it really is for a good reason at the end of the day. However, that holds true for two aspects of life, the good and the evil side. The good can be nothing but that, and my stance is that if it is Ordained by God, then how does it entail two wrongs making a right? Vikram lied to Sugni whether intentionally or not is by perspective and now Sugni marries his nephew to save Vikram's marriage and marries in his home, sharing a room with his nephew. Is it really something that you believe is ordained by God? Why would such a union be pure if done in such a vulgar way. Sugni was willing to give herself to Adi, Vikram's nephew after her Sardhakai. Not every relationship even if it seems to last and the two persons seem to be in love is ordained by God, or we would not have so many broken hearts, promises and relationships. I don't think any God would support this sort of setting to make a Union that is spiritually palatable and I think it would be a bit naive of us to believe that, not to mention having a distorted view of God.
The situations you deemed as sacrifice such as Sugni marrying Adi to save VIkram's marriage is illogical if you seriously look into it. Who does that? I don't need to marry any ex fiancee of mine nephew to tell him to get the hell out of my life and leave me alone and stay with his wife. Besides being gross and immoral, it is the most ridiculous thing I could ever imagine, to get rid of a man.
My POV, the cvs have no sense of creativity so they will come up with the most ridiculous ways to provide entertainment, but my main contention is the immoral implications of it.
Why not make Sugni marry some random guy, I am sure Vikram would have gotten the point just the same. Sugni is the one who drew attention to herself with the Sardhakai knowing full well VIkram will not have that and then accepting Adi to do the deed. Otherwise if she had left town and found someone to marry her, I really think VIkram would have eventually gotten the point. The only reasons was forcing himself on her, is because he never got that chance to explain himself, he never got that closure he wanted, and most of all he thought his motivation would be worth it because in his mind Sugni loved him.

For the record I really have to disagree with your POV on Adi, I would have been able to swallow you saying Vikram and Adi mirror each other😆 Please tell me when you have seen Adi true to his form, unless you are speaking from the perspective that from day one he was never a good character and has been consistent with that. Adi from day one was abusive to Sugni. The abusive behaviour never changed because he did the same to Amrita. As a matter of fact staying with a woman knowing full well you never really truly wanted to marry her, is emotional abuse. I am sure we can agree on that towards Amrita. Also, what about his physical abuse to Amrita, who did not deserve it, since she was not the one who went off and did some guys Sardhakai 😆(just kidding but you know what I mean) he slapped her. Remember he pushed Sugni and tried to drag her out of the house. don't forget that not because he is supposedly in love now.
He slapped his own Uncle, and it was not as if Vikram had laid a hand on Sugni to hurt her and he felt he needed to defend her. Adi lied to VIkram about his intentions towards doing Sugni's Sardhakai, and since VIkram can't lie for a good cause, why should Adi be excused?Lying is lying, didn't we all agree that Lying for good is still not Right, when we all agreed Vikram was wrong for lying?😊
To speak further on changing form, didn't Adi change his form, when he backed out of marrying Sugni in spite of his Promise? Why were Sugni and Gulabiya so disappointed if he never gave them the false impression that his choice for Sugni's well being, or is it that Sugni has illusions of Grandeur that Adi would marry her in spite of the marriage not being necessary any more in light of Reva's acceptance? Wherever would Sugni get the idea that Adi was doing this for her and Reva and not Reva only?

I have been watching this show from day one, and I have been waiting and watching till now I don't watch but I read, and I am still waiting for Adi's character to be Big in my eyes. It has always been my perspective that Adi deserves No one, as he is not true to himself nor anyone in his life.

Do you really in the bottom of your heart believe Adi is a good guy? If there is any shadow in this show, I would have to say it is Adi.


Edited by hillydee - 12 years ago
Hillylove thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: orianthi


Even with divorce, Sugni would be responsible for breaking a marriage. Regardless of how much he hates Reva, the fact of the matter is, He would be divorcing her to get with Sugni, therefore she would be the reason for the divorce and the catalyst for his decision. Sugni would not want to break someone's marriage.

😆 I agree with the muslim thing.
In addition I like Adini. They are so much alike and they both understand each other as a result of their sacrifices. I think they are nice couple. And the new Adi really is different from the old one. This Adi is more gentle and kind to sugni and he is giving her respect which is most important. I am not saying that TVS isn't but i mean Adini aren't bad or anything that they can't be a couple. If TVS can get with Sugni despite having a wife, why can't Adi get with Sugni despite being his uncle's young ex gf?

Your point on Sugni being reason for divorce is not exactly true. Remember Vikram thought Reva was dead, that is an important part of the show to understand the motivation behind Vikram moving on, that is why he allowed himself to give into his feelings for Sugni. As far as Vikram was concerned he was a free man. Just as how you feel Adi and Sugni were faced with unique circumstances to fall in love, why can't Vikram and Sugni's union deemed to be the same? If you feel your spouse is dead and you have fallen in love what are you going to do? Make yourself fall out of love with the new love and fall back in love with the old?
What if Sugni and Vikram had gotten married before Reva returned? Would you want Vikram to divorce Sugni and remarry Reva, because he was originally married to her?
Just as how Adi is allowed to leave Amrita because he does not love her and marry Sugni, why can't Vikram do the same wilful act, when the only difference is the signing of a piece of paper?
The only thing I can agree on is that Vikram should have found a way to tell Sugni the truth even if she killed herself after, who cares if she committed suicide, I mean as long as he told the truth right? Then my dearest Vikram would not be so hated right? Or then would he be hated for making Sugni commit suicide?

I am pleading to our dearest Adini Fans once again, we Sugvi Fans Don't subscribe to Adultery or Bigamy. We do not agree with Vikram being with Sugni while being married, nor do we agree with him marrying her while married.

Thanks

Hillylove thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: avyarima



Yes! you have said it all👏. TVS is married!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. you have a great logic here why Sugni and TVS jodi is not acceptable by me. Isn't that enough????????????????

see, i dont mean he must stay married, all am saying is He is married!!!!!!!!!!!!!. he should be good enough to deal with his wife case (even divorce her, i dont care), before going for Sugni because, like it or not TVS made her his mistress without her knowledge( i dont care why).
even if he is married to a witch, A MARRIED MAN IS OUT OF BOUND FOR ME, BUT I DONT HAVE PROBLEM WITH A DIVORCEE.

@ TOPIC STARTER ----I agree that Amurita's character in the show, and the lies( to the family) makes it difficult for people to accept Adi-Sugni's jodi and i totally agree with every one on this only because Amurita was a very good friend of Sugni , so friend's lovers are out of bounds too for me. (And i am not a big fan of Adi- sugni jodi) .but i accept the relation,because they maybe wrong in their actions, but they intentions are good and pure( that is why i accept it). more over Jodi's are made from heaven. many a times we think love somebody and will want to marry them. but God chooses who he knows is best for us. (that doesnt count for people who are still married!!!)

(the problem i see here is people dont understand the ritual, magnitude, and the weight of marriage . they see no difference between a married and unmarried couple.)

secoundly, God never intended any body to be a prostitute, some are in it for money, some because of critical situation and others because of their barbaric culture. so do you mean sugni does not deserve to be a wife because traditions doesnt allow that?...because if i know a little about God i would tell you God is in total agreement with a (good person) prostitute getting marry. Yes, she is legally (by their traditions) his mistress. but here is the twist...he is not married!. so what makes it so wrong and confusing if he makes her his wife.
infact, thats the second reason...why this jodi makes sense to me.

You totally misconstrued what Anastasia said. Her use of "married," is sarcasm to the Adini fans constant claims that we wanted Vikram to marry Sugni while he was still married. We have exhausted so many times, that this is not true, but you all fail to believe and it seems intentional. Quite frankly I find it very offensive to my values, even though I have repeatedly dismissed the accusations.

Also, it would have been really nice and more friendly if you had addressed me as Hillydee and not TOPIC STARTER, it makes this discussion feel hostile and that you don't really care to share only dictate to me.

Well, I still thank you for your post.
Edited by hillydee - 12 years ago
Hillylove thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: avyarima



Yes! you have said it all👏. TVS is married!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. you have a great logic here why Sugni and TVS jodi is not acceptable by me. Isn't that enough????????????????

see, i dont mean he must stay married, all am saying is He is married!!!!!!!!!!!!!. he should be good enough to deal with his wife case (even divorce her, i dont care), before going for Sugni because, like it or not TVS made her his mistress without her knowledge( i dont care why).
even if he is married to a witch, A MARRIED MAN IS OUT OF BOUND FOR ME, BUT I DONT HAVE PROBLEM WITH A DIVORCEE.

@ TOPIC STARTER ----I agree that Amurita's character in the show, and the lies( to the family) makes it difficult for people to accept Adi-Sugni's jodi and i totally agree with every one on this only because Amurita was a very good friend of Sugni , so friend's lovers are out of bounds too for me. (And i am not a big fan of Adi- sugni jodi) .but i accept the relation,because they maybe wrong in their actions, but they intentions are good and pure( that is why i accept it). more over Jodi's are made from heaven. many a times we think love somebody and will want to marry them. but God chooses who he knows is best for us. (that doesnt count for people who are still married!!!)

(the problem i see here is people dont understand the ritual, magnitude, and the weight of marriage . they see no difference between a married and unmarried couple.)

secoundly, God never intended any body to be a prostitute, some are in it for money, some because of critical situation and others because of their barbaric culture. so do you mean sugni does not deserve to be a wife because traditions doesnt allow that?...because if i know a little about God i would tell you God is in total agreement with a (good person) prostitute getting marry. Yes, she is legally (by their traditions) his mistress. but here is the twist...he is not married!. so what makes it so wrong and confusing if he makes her his wife.
infact, thats the second reason...why this jodi makes sense to me.

I am trying to figure out why you said the above because I never said God intended anyone to be a prostitute my very reason against Sugni living that life. Do you know anyone on this forum who believes God agrees with Prostitution? because your statement sounds like you are responding to a perception you have of my post. I totally wanted Sugni to get married, as I am also sure God would want her to do the same and change her life. I would have wanted Vikram to marry her after his divorce, Frankly I wished there was no Reva to begin with , or if Adi was not Vikram's nephew, because that makes her no better than a prostitute if she is willing to have relations with her ex fiancee's nephew, this is defeating the whole purpose of Sugni leading a life away from the fate of her culture. Remember Bednis not only sell themselves for money, they get involved with men no matter who they are as they do not respect relations or family, Sugni being with Adi in spite of his relation to Vikram is doing the same. With their so called great intentions, are still ruining the family. It is not only wives who are destroyed by Sardhakai, children and other family members, remember Adi is a product of such a destruction.

If you prostitute yourself to a single man it is one sin, but to do it to a married man is two sins, so I can't see why you should assume that anyone is agreeing to Sugni not marrying in the right way to a single or divorced man.


Hillylove thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#56
THANKS EVERYONE FOR YOUR POSTS👏

Just wanted to explain to those who felt the need to be hostile. If your point is of value to you and you hold true to it, there is no need to come across offensive or accusatory, as it may be deemed that you are uncertain of your stance and also do not know how to dialogue with all your fellow men.

Take care Everyone!!
PutijaChalhov thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 12 years ago
#57
Great arguments by all for and against the jodi what will CVs do lets W&W
princessonline thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: hillydee

Thanks for your perspective and I truly appreciated the length of it and the time you took to respond to my post in a very intelligent way.


I think everyone can admit that Sugni's hurt is very plausible. I would never take that from her. My outrage was her methods that followed and her rationalisation to right the wrong she felt was being done by Vikram, and I believe that is the main contention of the outcome of events. No one faults Sugni for her anger, even though I believe is she had not lacked Maturity, there could have been a more in depth conversation with Vikram in spite of her anger, after all she almost married the man, I think they both owed that to each other. They could have spoken about this and she could have taken any decision she wanted. Her allowing this dialogue with Vikram would have also been more in line with the very same things you speak of, her love for him, trusting completely and seeing him as God. However, her feelings becomes conflicting and her immaturity becomes apparent, when she says "She trusts him completely," but she never once tried to hear his perspective, don't you think that is strange?
Any female I know, when she finds out that her man did her wrong, her normal reaction is " How could you?" "Why did you lie to me?' and I think she would normally wait for the answer because when you are in love, especially the way Sugni claimed to be ( I never thought telling a man you see him like God was something light to say and forget in a moment😲) even when you see his betrayal, the love still makes you in disbelieve it and hope that there is some miraculously good reason for this.😆 Not throw back his ring, tell him a few choice words, and run out to round up a whole town of men and you pick the richest one to take you to a life of unlimited Prostitution.
Maybe my fault is to think that all those big claims made by Sugni had some strength in it for her to at least hear him out before making a decision and absolutely and definitely not hooking up with his nephew under the guise of saving his wife who you know nothing about. Then eventually deciding to make a real marriage out of it, especially in such a short time. She moved on quite quickly for a girl so hurt. I thought she would have left him and went somewhere else to lick her wounds not live in the same house with her culprit and taunt him with his nephew for your so called good intention. What makes Sugni feel it is her right to make a decision for a Grown man to stay with his wife with her Grand Plan. Isn't Vikram grown enough to know what he wants? If she did not want him anymore , all she had to do was walk away to another place.

For the record, Vikram did not intentionally try to kill Gulabiya with the gun, nor did he ever try to kill her at any point in time. Vikram is a Man, not a little boy, it is only natural he would stand up to Gulabiya from day one, if he wanted to be with Sugni.
The only people that came in between Sugni and Gulabiya in the beginning are themselves. If their bond was strong as they claimed it was, if Sugni was loyal to her Mother like she pretended, no man, no one could have come between them. Gulabiya forced Sugni to choose her over her ambitions. Sugni put her ambitions over her Mother. No one can make you do what you truly do not want to do, even if they put a gun to your head.

Entertainment is one thing, but entertainment showing mixed, confusing and values deemed to be immoral even if it is by one person, cannot be truly Entertainment, but then again, it is my perspective and right, to not be entertained by rubbish that is being mixed with real life issues. Is it that marriage and God are such trivial things that you don't mind the cvs distort it for the sake of your entertainment? Is it so wrong that others don't feel that way and just want to stand for something they believe is against what they believe is right?
So, if you don't see anything wrong with what the Cvs are portraying and you feel that myself and others are taking this "entertainment." so seriously, don't you think we have the same right to how we feel?
My post was merely for a perspective towards what I perceive to be wrong. So, I expect some or most to say my perspective is wrong and why and some or most to say my perspective is right and why. Or I would be willing to live with everyone saying I am wrong and why.
What I am not expecting if we are individuals and have the right to how we feel, is that I must accept this as entertainment and not take it too seriously.

Thank you for your reply and I agree with many of the things you said.

I agree with you about Sugni being wrong about many things. However, I feel she took so many wrong steps because there were others, like her mother, telling her what she should do and what not. Everyone should have left Sugni on her own for a while to let her think and rationalize what she should do. Sugni's biggest mistake was to agree to go out and sell herself. She should have thought about all the things that had happened and then cooled down and talked to Vikram and let him explain his side of the story and then let him know what it is she wants him to do. Sugni on the other hand messed things up by making decisions in the heat of the moment. I hold Sugni accountable for a lot of the mess that as been made.

Firstly, I was always a Vikram and Sugni fan. However, I like Adi-Sugni now. But that wasn't what I was going to say. What I was going to say is that I am not sure why Sugni has to be so "angelic" and help Reva to get Vikram back? I could understand that she left him because he betrayed her trust but what I think is utterly ridiculous is that she wanted to go away from Vikram because she wanted to reunite Reva and TVS. I feel that she has nothing to do with TVS and Reva's relationship. If TVS does not love Reva and wants to divorce her then that is something he wants to do. She should have no right to tell him what he should do with his relationship or not. There is no love, understanding and willingness to be with each other in that marriage and it is better that they divorce. She should not consider herself to be the second woman who destroyed the relationship because TVS and Reva had no relationship to begin with.

Secondly, Sugni pushes TVS away and then cries about how he has gone so far away from her! She really needs to make up her mind. Do you want the guy or not? She is leading two men on and that is not fair for the both of them. I do feel bad for Sugni, however, I am not going to defend her for the things that she is doing wrong.

Thirdly, it is not Sugni's headache to think about what happens to Reva and her relationship. She needs to figure out what she wants. I am not sure why Sugni has this misconception that if she were to leave TVS then his and Reva's marriage will be better. The guy doesn't love her, for god sake he wants to kill her! He will not have a perfect relationship with Reva even is Sugni were to leave them two alone.

At the end though I do like Sugni and Adi because there relationship doesn't really have a lot of baggage which could in the future cause them trouble. My theory is that if you can not forgive the person wholeheartedly for their pass mistakes then it is better to leave them out of your life instead of giving them false hope.

I am not saying the CV's have the right to undermine God, His power or the values of relationship. What I was trying to say was that no matter what we feel the CV's are not going to change their scripts for us because the majority of the people wanted TVS and Sugni together, ultimately though the CV's did what they had intended to do. I was just trying to say that don't get mad over a show and ruin your day because at the end it is created to entertain us no matter how annoying and messed it can be.


Very confusing topic. It is hard to support one side of the coin. In this story each person has made lets of irrational choices, thus make is difficult to actually full on support one person with thought supporting another.

devraniharish thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: rozetta




@ devranharish, despite all the negative comments on Adini jodi, Frankly I dnt mind so my friend plz dnt take the comments to heart, ur comments r truly valuable to me cuz i'm a adini fan like u.
I mean u said we lost but if u look on the bright side we adini fans actually WON!!!! I mean no matter what they say we still get to see adini as the main jodi, no matter how many bashing, we won cuz we get to see the adini jodi no matter what.
So to all Vikram fans, hope u enjoy
cuz i know i will


Thanks for support lots of love to you
Edited by devraniharish - 12 years ago
Istila thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: hillydee

Maybe my fault is to think that all those big claims made by Sugni had some strength in it for her to at least hear him out before making a decision and absolutely and definitely not hooking up with his nephew under the guise of saving his wife who you know nothing about.


As Vikram once told to Sugni after her dance in front of the Takurs, all of her boasting, was exaggeration, it meant nothing, and was of no avail. Plenty of times in Indian serials the continual breaking promises & hearts is shown.

Whether by intention or not, the CVs vail attempts to deeply violate our moral sensitivities, hurting us to the inner chore, is not going to improve their lot. They simply make themselves appear, lacking in any reasonable judgement, intelligence & wisdom.

What the CVs forget is that we are humans and like them, we have hearts & minds, moral values, sensitivities ...and hopefully, some wisdom.

People don't always look at age or beauty as a deciding factor for marriage. We look at things which bring deep meaning into our lives, not constantly watching lechery for entertainment. We, the audience do not like to waste our precious time on disrespectful, demoralising melodrama...the main reason why I am not watching it.


Edited by Istila - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".