Shaan has a right to be upset - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

104

Views

11.7k

Users

40

Likes

102

Frequent Posters

PIPC thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: Vijay Vyas


<font color="#660000">Fans ko apne favourite ka har action acha lagta hai iska
matlab yeh nahi ki sabko woh acha lage. Yeh to Shaan ne Mika ko sirf Dhaka diya
to news channel walo ne halla macha diya kaan ke niche bajane se Bhagwan jaane
aur kya kya bolte.</font>


<font color="#660000">Aap khud hi dekh lo starnews walon ne kya bola:</font>


[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5eWVuayhgiA[/YOUTUBE]



I am so disgusted to see the role that the media is playing now-a-days. India has innumerable burning issues that the public should know....Innumerable incidents are happening everyday in India which demand the attention of the media. Instead of making the public aware of what is the socio-economic and political scenario of India, these lazy reporters are doing postmortem of somebody's emotional outburst in a reality show. How very inefficient of them 😕 !!!!

When I watch and listen to some news bulletin, I do so to learn something that is happening in and around my country, and the whole world. What positive things does these trashy news footage bring to the viewers? How does it add to the learning curve of the viewers?

Any foolish and emotional sangeet ka deewana/ki deewani viewer like me who watches this mockery of music conducted in the garb of 'musical reality show' knows what happened there on the MKMM stage.
This news footage didn't even show any 'behind the stage' version of this incident also. It simply showed what was shown there in the telecast of that MKMM episode.

These lazy reporters just squeezed in some comments that seriously sounded like comments that a bunch of idle girls exchange while gossiping....The first question 'dekha aapne Shaan ne kya kiya?' just made me feel so 🤢........They simply based the entire piece of footage on a sensational outburst with the repetition of the same scene over and over again with some sensation stirring dialogues squeezed in between...

Come on star news reporters or any reporters who present this kind of footage to public in the name of news for that matter, it is about time you become aware of your responsibilities and stop acting like a bunch of college girls whose discussion start with the sentence, "suna usne kya kiya/dekha usne kya kiya?😆...

I really detest the way the Indian viewers are taken for granted. If they took the viewers seriously, they would have certainly thought twice before presenting such crappy and trashy news items...I rest my case....


bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#92

Originally posted by: PIPC



I am so disgusted to see the role that the media is playing now-a-days. India has innumerable burning issues that the public should know....Innumerable incidents are happening everyday in India which demand the attention of the media. Instead of making the public aware of what is the socio-economic and political scenario of India, these lazy reporters are doing postmortem of somebody's emotional outburst in a reality show. How very inefficient of them 😕 !!!!

When I watch and listen to some news bulletin, I do so to learn something that is happening in and around my country, and the whole world. What positive things does these trashy news footage bring to the viewers? How does it add to the learning curve of the viewers?

Any foolish and emotional sangeet ka deewana/ki deewani viewer like me who watches this mockery of music conducted in the garb of 'musical reality show' knows what happened there on the MKMM stage.
This news footage didn't even show any 'behind the stage' version of this incident also. It simply showed what was shown there in the telecast of that MKMM episode.

These lazy reporters just squeezed in some comments that seriously sounded like comments that a bunch of idle girls exchange while gossiping....The first question 'dekha aapne Shaan ne kya kiya?' just made me feel so 🤢........They simply based the entire piece of footage on a sensational outburst with the repetition of the same scene over and over again with some sensation stirring dialogues squeezed in between...

Come on star news reporters or any reporters who present this kind of footage to public in the name of news for that matter, it is about time you become aware of your responsibilities and stop acting like a bunch of college girls whose discussion start with the sentence, "suna usne kya kiya/dekha usne kya kiya?😆...

I really detest the way the Indian viewers are taken for granted. If they took the viewers seriously, they would have certainly thought twice before presenting such crappy and trashy news items...I rest my case....


Pinki, as always I can't but help applauding your brilliant posts!👏👏👏👏👏
greygoose thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: shyamidutt

Yes Very well said....... is this show for judges or new singers? they should have limit may be like one song allowed by judge so FatSo like shankar who may be great composer but very bad human for putting new talkented singers like Anwesha not to even see what oither judges gave he by singing himself. Very sad on shankar's part

Rahul is not singer and i dont know what he thinks of himself? i may be biased but i think singers who come out of Saregamapa are better and down to earth with exceptions like Sharib who always disrespected judges
Gajji is mastermind but even he must have forgotten that this show is abt new upcoming singers and not Judges.. Let them fight it out for thier players by aruing or fghting but not by sining themselves

hikamosa thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#94

Originally posted by: greygoose

Yes Very well said....... is this show for judges or new singers? they should have limit may be like one song allowed by judge so FatSo like shankar who may be great composer but very bad human for putting new talkented singers like Anwesha not to even see what oither judges gave he by singing himself. Very sad on shankar's part
Rahul is not singer and i dont know what he thinks of himself? i may be biased but i think singers who come out of Saregamapa are better and down to earth with exceptions like Sharib who always disrespected judges
Gajji is mastermind but even he must have forgotten that this show is abt new upcoming singers and not Judges.. Let them fight it out for thier players by aruing or fghting but not by sining themselves

On the contrary I think Anwesha is honored that Shanker himself came down to challenge her. Shanker also praised so much for her performance. Having said that though its within the rule but ethicaly wrong that to perform twice in one show. But for that only I dont think you should use the derogatory word for one of the most respected talented singer composer.
Regarding Rahul , yes his antics and attitude are absolutely unbearable but you cant deny the fact that he is damn good singer. I dont like him at all but I have to admit that he is a good singer. He does give GOOSE bump at time , so what its not GREY.
Edited by hikamosa - 15 years ago
Shreyacool thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#95

Originally posted by: sashb

Exactly!!! What Shankar did yesterday was very cheap..it was not right..firstly it has been noticed that even if the captains don't sing that well, they always end up getting 10 points...so I guess we should also restrict the number of songs a particular person can perform in an episode...

Also, what Shan said abt the duet song was correct..we could surely make out that Nidhi had forgotten her lines and there was a very very long pause where she appeared totally lost..and if it is a completetion where u ctach if anybody slips on the sur and tal then u need to also catch when anybody forgets the lyrics..
lyrics are equally imp for a song..also she sang only 10% of the total song..so it could not even be called a proper duet...

I agree with your one point bout Shanker coming and performing against the newcomers! He should stop doing so. What shanker did was cheap but the way shaan behaved was also very cheap! He should have made his point in a proper manner, rather than pouncing on the audience, throwing his jacket & shouting at the judges.
A duet need not be 50-50%. As long as both male & female singer make their presence felt. There are soooo many duets, in which the female has only 2 lines for example shukhranalla, kaise mujhe, bakhuda, etc etc....... So shaan shouldnt have made a big fuss for this!!!!
I think Rahul deserved to be the singer of the day for his singing, i m not hes fan atall, but the song sung was beautiful, soft & soothing, mite b bcoz their song selection was good & also the mistake wasnt awkward!
Edited by Shreyacool - 15 years ago
nithyak thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#96
I agree with your points shreyacool, especially about shankar .
bebe nanno thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#97
sheryacool,
I also agree that duet can have only 2 lines etc but unlike Shaan, my point would have been that those two lines should be sung correctly and with lyrics of course.
In fact, abhi na jao has a full female part, and as I said earlier, even the in beginning female part, the male singer had to sing along with her as she obviously did not know the song at all.
nithyak thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#98
Probably, she was busy with some shows and came straight for the shoot. We never know what happens behind the scenes. Let us give everyone benefit of doubt. 😳
greygoose thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#99

Originally posted by: hikamosa

On the contrary I think Anwesha is honored that Shanker himself came down to challenge her. Shanker also praised so much for her performance. Having said that though its within the rule but ethicaly wrong that to perform twice in one show. But for that only I dont think you should use the derogatory word for one of the most respected talented singer composer.
Regarding Rahul , yes his antics and attitude are absolutely unbearable but you cant deny the fact that he is damn good singer. I dont like him at all but I have to admit that he is a good singer. He does give GOOSE bump at time , so what its not GREY.

You right and i am sorry for bad use of wods for Shankar. I really like him as singer and composer but when i see thigs like this i dont like it. WE can disagree on Rahul's singing but then this forum is for that
More i think more i realise that nonplaying judges are more to be blame than Shankar him self for giving Rahul's due more marks
well Shit happens in this type of shows but i still like MKMM
Supremo thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
I think shankar really showed his class and mastery by singing twice.I think it was unbelievable singing.Shaan didn;\'t come in because he was scared that he would be found wanting against such a powerful singer.😉
I don't know what kind of people are supporting shaan- approving of shaan's rowdy behaviour but abusing Mika for the similar behaviour!!!!!! This is hypocrisy at its worst....😕

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".