Shaan has a right to be upset

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

dhumdi_dhana

@dhumdi_dhana

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#101

I agree whole heartedly that M Singh is the most irritating, know it allfool. Can't people of India request for a referendum as far as M Singh is concerned "to be or not to be" a judge/leader on the next Reality TV Show????😕

I'm sure he'll be ousted in no time. Too much arrogance And v. little sense!! He has the audacity to claim that he's the first one to start the idea of a medley?? 😲

Has M Singh heard of Lataji??? Doesn't seem so!!! He should go ask for the DVDs of Lataji Live Stage performances and he'll see her effortless rendition of a medley.

I trust the organisers take more care to see that people don't gang up against one person like they did against Shaan.

GOD BLESS & GOOD LUCK SHAAN

Quote

I don't know! U tell me! :D ;)

@-Sanjana-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 15 years ago

#102

Yes. I totally agree with u. Firstly, this is MUSIC ka maha muqabla NOT PERFORMANCE ka maha muqabla. At least if the show were based on performance u could say that they somehow managed. But this is about MUSIC. U need to learn and know the song properly before singing. And if they do make a mistake, I definately don't think that the TEAM CAPTAIN+ judges should defend it. If it's a mistake, the least Shankar ji could have done would be to ACCEPT it. Plus, the job of a team captain is to LEAD the team. And Shankar ji was becoming the entire team. It's quite obvious that he will get 10 each time! And if the show was about only captains singing, this show may as well have been called, 'captains is maha muqabla' instead. I think that it was totally cheap on his part to go up there and sing TWICE. This is for new singers to become India's new sensation. But if the captain himself doesn't allow his singers to sing, then there is really no point in having a team for him. He may as well have gone up there and sung all the times! After all, getting a score of 10 is guarenteed! And as far as Shaan is concerned, I think he was absolutely RIGHT in getting angry! Anyone would feel this way! I think that team captains should not be allowed to sing at all. Only then, will the game become fair. Because as of now, Music is maha muqabla is very unfair and biased.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

dhumdi_dhana

@dhumdi_dhana

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#103

Originally posted by: swati_mjht

shankar would never have to be threatened by shaan..shankarji has evrything going right for him in the music industry..why would he feel threatened by shaan.
I really think shreya's medley was better...I think they did not show the crowd so how can you say they did not enjoy shreya's medley....She tried something really innovative yesterday..
it is your POV if you have lost respect for a gr8 composer on such an issue.. but I don't think he was fooling the audience in anyway yesterday

[/QUOTE

As said over & over again, Shankar did cheat, if he is so------ good & confident why is he doing the same thing over & over again?? Has he no consideration for his team ?? Does he not have the maturity to show some faith in them?? Does he not need to lead them to an honest way?? Lead them to the platform where they can get some acnoledgement???
No matter what hieghts he has reached, he is a v. petty minded person. He says this is a game & have to win! But there are some unwritten moral codes for any game!!! Shankar has turned this into a war where all is fair - just win each battle( partcipation) - by fowl means.

Quote

dhumdi_dhana

@dhumdi_dhana

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#104

Originally posted by: tina59
well I didn't have any problem with Shankar coming on twice as he as a captain made a strategic decision to make his team win which is fine as it was as per the rules.

What I disagree abt was the points given by the judges given to rahul and nikita in the duet round. It was unfair as nikitha didnt sing and hence points should have been cut for it.

for eg: lets take a scenario where in the duet round, nikitha didnt forget the lyrics and sang, now suppose rahul sand out of the world and nikitha sand badly and besura, how much points would the judges have given, def not a 9, they would have given lesser considering that it was a duet, its the same thing they should have applied when giving points here excet this time Nikitha forgot and didnt even sing.

So in the duet round, they didnt deserve a 9.So shaan's anger is justified.

PS: I just dislike rahul my god, he is so full of sttitude and his trying to get footage every single time wow....
the way he said that the audience won and he lost showed it all, dude it wasnt abt u at all so his statement made no point.
Even when shankar sings, he comes on and stands before the camera.......

Whatever any one may say but the fact is that it was an unfair move by Shankar.

I agree with you where Rahul is concerned, but the most do😊
He is an arrogant, mediocre singer, calls himself an "artist" who is not getting the proper treatment & this is making him feel v. bad. That HR supports him " I know, I understand beta!" GOD HR & others; Mika especially are so------- stupid & biased!!😳

Quote

Sid

@Sid4TeamCanada

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#105

shaan's anger, towards the judge's attitudes towards rahul neeti performance - it was 100 % valid!

its MUSIC ka MAHA muqabbala- u have the singers of HIGHEST quality coming here to compete, such a tough competition, where even the tiniest flaw can cause ur team to lose.. at this stage, if one of the singers FORGETS the lyrics.. that is a BIG reason to deduct marks.. YES rahul showed quick thinking, and YES he made it into an entertaining performance, BUT the fact is that the girl FORGOT whtever 3-4 lines she had.. and nowhere did it sound like a duet.. i wud've called the song a SOLO the way it was sang... if JUST rahul was singing, and he had forgotten the lyrics - then wht? wud he hav gotten 9? NO! he wud've got like 6-7 depending on how much he sang.. in a solo performance, all marks are made by the single singer.. but in a duet, each of the two shud be judged, and their marks shud be tallied.. and neeti shud hav gotten a 1 or 2 for HER part... so rahul gets 5.. + 1 or 2.. thats 6 or 7.. they cud've given rahul singer of the day award at the end of the show... but to actully make his marks cover neeti's.. that means it was a SOLO round not a DUET! shaan's anger was absolutely justified - PERFORMANCE GOOD OR NOT, the point is that its a duet, its such a HIGH stage, & a mistake like forgetting the lyrics - NEEEDS TO BE TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT!

the second point: about shankar coming to stage to sing so many times.. thats UNFAIR.. ok if the captain wants to come, but the fact is that the captain shud let the other captain know abt this...so that the other captain can prepare accordingly... i mean come on ofcourse if the captain comes, audience won't give ANYTHING less than 9.5! thats a GIVEN! and thats UNFAIR.. the fact that shaan kept giving HIS TEAM the chance to get their win, whereas shankar just kept trying to win it HIMSELF... i think tht first, captains shud be restricted to just 1 extra round (other than medley), and BOTH the captains shud come then, in one of the rounds... so that its fair to both sides.. the onyl reason shaan lost in the shaan vs shankar match WAS BECUZ SHANKAR SUNG MOST OF THE SONGS, whereas shaan sent his students!! if like shankar, shaan had stepped in for the 2-3 rounds... then it wud hav been a TIGHT match, almost a tie!

Quote

1 ... 7 8 9 10 11

Shaan

Shaan has a right to be upset - Page 11

Related Topics

Explore Topics