Critics Review - Mod Note Pg. 67. - Page 13

Okay few stuff to say.on the current MayUr fight.

You know, I really don't mind the premise... I can see MN disagreeing over on whether to make the relationship public or not... But, THIS is what breaks MN up and forces Nupur to go back to Morena? A disagreement on whether to make their relationship public or not? Wait wait hold on a sec, even that's not the reason... its basically about the TIME when the said relationship is allowed to be made public? 😲 Honestly, I get that MN need to seperate for N to go to Morena plot to work out. But couldn't a better and more realistic reason have been formulated for their seperation?. Mayank comes off as a guy with major anger-management problems with the way he's (senselessly and inconsistently) overreacting to the situation, smashing plates and all... What happened to the COOL, calm and logical Mayank? You know the 'ICE' to Nupur's 'FIRE'... And these are words used by the show-makers themselves to describe the characters... So really what was that all about? Where is Mayank's 'coolness' when he is breaking up plates? And on to Nupur, well, Nupur is quite a tenacious and persisant character, she is NOT an escapist. She sticks on to Mumbai when she was humiliated and embarrased in college. She sticks on to Mumbai when Gunjan gets mad at her. She sticks on to Mumbai when Mayank gets, rightfully so, angry at her due to the project scam, but this time when she hasn't even made a mistake lo and behold she's suddenly feeling the need to go to Morena? 🤔 What I find even more mind-boggling is that instead of trying to convince Mayank of her innocence, or you know, just waiting till things cool down, she decides to escape to Morena?
Yes I get it that its done to start the Morena track but the problem is that such exaggerated, inconsistent responses from Mayank & Nupur really tarnishes the image of MN in the audience's eye. Because this 'smashing plates all around' Mayank and this 'so hurt to escape into home-town just due to an argument' Nupur is most definately not the same cool nerd Mayank and filmy dramatic Nupur that drew me into the show. And THAT MN is the reason we watch this show, not these cariactures.

So my request to the creatives is to kindly keep the characters in mind when formulating new tracks. Thats the least you can do, right?

Well said, Sonia!

I also find it seriously annoying how Nupur and Gunjan are behaving as if their world has ended cuz of the guy issues in their life and the need to go back to Morena to be all 'taro taaza' in the 'clean air' or whatever else they were babbling......and I was ROFL when Nupur said, 'phir jab hum waapas aayenge, humaare paas phir se himmat hogi apne sapno ko pura karne ki'...oye hello! WHAT sapna??? When was Nupur shown to have ANY sapna in this show other than finding her rajkumar and as of recent SHAADI with Mayank??? Hilarious how they randomly try to add 'poignancy' to a character when they NEVER show any basis to it otherwise.....LOLL....Sapna....ha!

I have no hope for the tracks atm, but please don't use any more cut outs. *begs* They make the cheesy scenes even cheesier, By God!

gautam, we need tujhe dekha to ye jaana sanam for SaJan....please make it happen somehow....after that DDLJ wala promo, i can so imagine Sajan on the song.....they'd be amazing

if not tujhe dekha, then suraj hua maddamm for SaJan....that is Sony 4 sure...did my HW
and u can also have Khuda Jaane for the first date, Mashallah+Jab se tere naina+zara si+o meri jaan melody for pre-confession/woo-ing stage

all sony songs...and i wish u had used woh pehli baar in MJHT...

What is up with these DDLJ promos??? Seriously, MJHT stick to the original things you showed in the beginning yaar.

and if you are gonna leash such bakwwas suprirses on us, please, don't show promos. SG promo made me laugh. I just can't stop laughing. REALLY STUPID.

@new promo

wat did i watch ?😕
happy that sajan had a hug, which is giving me a hope for confession
but wat was that style.... ditto copy frm DDLJ, n that was very artificial, there was no natural feel

plz give sajan some simple,neat n original confession
not interested in any copies esp DDLJ

@mayur promo - i think u r using only DDLJ (or some more SRK) tricks for MN, better stop doing that.... it's a request

Creatives now plzz dont use suraj hua madham on MN (earlier using that rain scene created a big hungama already)...Moreover I cant bear another MN romancing around cut-out of pyramids 😵😵..Secondly that song is all about Man-Woman romance & MN are still college students..No matter how much I love ArTi but I dont think even they could do justice to "suraj hua madham"..SRK-Kajol's chemistry in that song was seductive, dark and passionate..For me it wont work on MN 😛
& haan all these "bade bade deshon mein choti choti baat","mujhe lagta hai maine aap ko pehle kabhie dekha he" dialogues SRK k muh se hi achcha lagta hai 😆,i know majority of MN fans like Mayank sprouting these dialogues,no offence to them this is just my POV 😉