Critics Review - Mod Note Pg. 67. - Page 12

Originally posted by: Kavya_KraZQueen

I agree with you about everything else except for the bold part. Firstly Dodo & Dia are N's family, not his, secondly N would not think of it as a big deal but it IS a big deal for M; N saying "what difference does it make?" from her standpoint is easy but thinking what difference it ACTUALLY makes to M by looking at it from his perspective is what really puts the same thing in a totally different & quite serious light (I am not saying N is wrong here , I know she used that line in order to defend herself but from M's POV that is a careless comment) because he is someone who would not appreciate others knowing about his personal feelings, he is not the kind of person who would want his feelings (which he values a lot ) to provide fodder for others' idle gossip (N doesn't care what the world thinks about them, neither does M but while N would not bother whether she is giving people a chance to talk about them, M WOULD) which is why he put his foot down against making their relationship public in the first place . However, N's reasoning about the same (making relationship public) & her insecurities did seem valid to him so he asked her for sometime to think this out carefully before they can tell everyone in such a way so as to avoid being everyone's topic of discussion to some extent at least & at the same time allay N's fears. It was a plan which has been interrupted in between so M did not take too kindly to it, I can understand his anger about it but my main issue is his rationality going for a toss, I could have bought this kind of reaction to N had they NOT been a couple already but we were shown MN literally sticking to each other since confession so they should have formed a basic level of understanding at least (now I guess everyone gets why some of us have been stressing on the emotional bonding of MN for AAAAGESSS). One would particularly expect M to give N a fair chance this time because this is not the first time he didn't give her a chance to explain herself, how long will we be shown M repeating the same mistake again & again? Is that ALL there is to M's character or MN's relationship? Romance- fight-patch-up routine & comedy - that is ALL that defines MN? Where is the depth? When were we shown the strength of their bond by a proper build up of a bond between them for it to be 'tested' now?

Completely agree with what you said in the blue part.

But, going back to my initial point about Dia and Uday being family, I still don't find a rational reason for Mayank to get so mad.

Granted, he's the guy who likes to keep his personal feelings to himself and wouldn't them to be a subject of gossip and speculation. That's the ONLY reason why he doesn't want everyone to know, right?

But again going back to the point that Dia and Uday are family. So why would they talk about them in a bad way anyway? It makes no sense to me.

I agree that Nupur doesn't need to tell the entire world about their relationship but I still don't get Mayank's reasoning behind not even telling her family. Because it seems like the reason he gives against telling everyone doesn't even hold ground with Nupur's family.

-Mahi

Originally posted by: trouble_maker

Why the heck do u guys not show SaNu, MaJan, SaNjie...all friends scenes now???Why is the show only and only about 2 couples now....?!?!?


I miss this ^^ SaNu!!

Exactly my point, Binu!

Initially it was so nice to see all of them bonding as a friend. It started out as Samrat's gang, GunUr, Mayank-CJ but then we got so many beautiful friendships ... SaNu, MaJan, BenJan and so on...

Why not now? So what if MayUr and SaJan are in love... doesn't mean they forget all friendships!

-Mahi

I like the suit Gunjan was wearing today! :)

I have just few simple things which i want to convey regarding the current mayur and their so called track.

Oh brother,this thread was supposed to be meant for a review of an episode.but all I see is people complaining,specially mayank-nupur fans.I mean give your opinions,suggestions,what you liked,what you didn't. And before doing so,remember that its an Indian show.I always think that some mayur fans have nothing good to say about the show,which is true.I didn't like the locket, mayapari cut outs etc but this fight was reasonable.mayank did not listen to nupur during the project time too,so why the fuss? Nupur should have explained,why didn't she?you people say the reaction was dumb,let me tell you,I know a person very closely,he always keeps his calm,but he does lose his temper,and threw things away.everyone is not perfect, mayank included.there is a logic in the track, enjoy it.you have a better suggestion for a future track, give it.

As for the creatives wasting their talent theory,come off it.tv actors rarely do well in movies,although they have talent.do you really think these actors have the opportunity to do shows like friends or house in our tv industry?this show has its lows,but it has had highs too.thank the creatives for giving us both rati and arjun. Ignore the small issues and enjoy the show while it lasts.in this sense,I like sg fans,since they appreciate what they like,disregard what they don't and give suggestions for the future.ok so the creatives won't listen sometimes,so what?will your constant nagging have any effect?instead give ideas and use your energy in better ways.I'm not saying don't critique the episode,but do it in a different manner.

Originally posted by: rose82

Oh brother,this thread was supposed to be meant for a review of an episode.but all I see is people complaining,specially mayank-nupur fans.I mean give your opinions,suggestions,what you liked,what you didn't. And before doing so,remember that its an Indian show.I always think that some mayur fans have nothing good to say about the show,which is true.I didn't like the locket, mayapari cut outs etc but this fight was reasonable.mayank did not listen to nupur during the project time too,so why the fuss? Nupur should have explained,why didn't she?you people say the reaction was dumb,let me tell you,I know a person very closely,he always keeps his calm,but he does lose his temper,and threw things away.everyone is not perfect, mayank included.there is a logic in the track, enjoy it.you have a better suggestion for a future track, give it.

As for the creatives wasting their talent theory,come off it.tv actors rarely do well in movies,although they have talent.do you really think these actors have the opportunity to do shows like friends or house in our tv industry?this show has its lows,but it has had highs too.thank the creatives for giving us both rati and arjun. Ignore the small issues and enjoy the show while it lasts.in this sense,I like sg fans,since they appreciate what they like,disregard what they don't and give suggestions for the future.ok so the creatives won't listen sometimes,so what?will your constant nagging have any effect?instead give ideas and use your energy in better ways.I'm not saying don't critique the episode,but do it in a different manner.

And here we go again....

Firstly, I'm unable to understand why the concept of an OPINION is so hard to understand in this forum....just cuz someone doesn't view a show in the way you do by blinding themselves to the nonsense being shown, you will term them as constant complainers, fussing etc. etc....Different ppl express their opinions in different ways....as far as I can see, NO bashing is going on in this thread..yet STILL ppl ALWAYS have to rake up non-existent issues to make villians out of MN fans😕😕😕

Some ppl want to give ideas and use their 'energy' in 'better ways' as you put it, they are most welcome to.....but why is sarcastic criticism not allowed when they DO show such ridiculousness in the show??? WHY are ppl not welcome to their opinions???

I guess it's pointless to even expect that in this forum.

*Edit: FYI....this is NOT the epi discussion thread....that's a different thread...this thread is solely meant for criticism.

Yo now lessonss of criticism here too..

oh well ROFL

this is a criticism thread and as far as we are within IF COC we are fine I guess...

no teaching please

@above,I never said don't criticize,I myself pointed out somethings I didn't like.what i said was small things like mayank getting too hyper is ok,not something unacceptable.neither did I say you are bashing anyone.why are you so defensive?In my opinion,a critical review is somthing you like,didn't like,what is your suggestion.its an honest opinion which is alwys welcome. my professors give a critical viewpoint,and it is not always about condemning someones work.I only have a small hesitation,since I really like to read honest opinions and not just Sarcastic criticism. If this is what this thread is meant for,I'm sorry,I didn't know it.

I don't want this thread to be closed coz of me,as I come just sometmes.so u can go ahead with your critical opinions.

Originally posted by: rose82

@above,I never said don't criticize,I myself pointed out somethings I didn't like.what i said was small things like mayank getting too hyper is ok,not something unacceptable.neither did I say you are bashing anyone.why are you so defensive?In my opinion,a critical review is somthing you like,didn't like,what is your suggestion.its an honest opinion which is alwys welcome. my professors give a critical viewpoint,and it is not always about condemning someones work.I only have a small hesitation,since I really like to read honest opinions and not just Sarcastic criticism. If this is what this thread is meant for,I'm sorry,I didn't know it.

I don't want this thread to be closed coz of me,as I come just sometmes.so u can go ahead with your critical opinions.

Thanks for your clarification. I was responding to the statements I bolded from your previous post where you generalized some MN fans as never being having anything good to say about the show and always complaining.....forgive me if I got a bit defensive over that statement, I had no other idea how to react😊

Beyond that, I don't want to get into the details of what one may consider 'condemning' of someone's work....to each their own opinion😊

From the Sept 24th epi:

I don't get what basis this characteristic of Mayank's is being shown on that he doesn't like to "show his emotions".....so when Dia, Benji etc. came over to his house and teased MN, that time toh he's acting fine...who is asking him to start doing full on PDA with Nupur in front of everyone to do a 'dikhaava'?? Then later he randomly starts spouting total nonsense to Nupur....I have no problem with MN fighting....but the REASON for this fight as many other ppl have mentioned in here as well....is really pathetic.

I am unable to understand even 1% the 'logic' behind Mayank's fear of everyone knowing about him and Nupur.....it's like he expects that if everyone knows, then him and Nupur will be expected to be the resident entertainment act of Axe-l and put up a show of PDA for everyone....like ppl have NOTHING better to do in their lives than gawk at MN all day?? What kind of logic is this?? There is no head or tail to it......just a very convenient excuse to make MN fight and gear up for the Morena track.

This was his main line from his melodramatic outburst that I found really confounding.....this whole 'main apne emotions kisi ke saamne dikhana nahin chaahta'.....Ummm, where the hell did THIS characteristic of his suddenly emerge from??? Ofcourse then it was endlessly built up from that point onwards geared towards showing M going overboard as he does in every MN fight and Nupur storming off in hurt and anger as always......

As if showing Nupur's shaadi obsession was not enough, this totally random phobia that has been shown of Mayank being scared to reveal their relationship.....whatever happened to the self-confident, self-assured guy who didn't give a damn about what ppl talked?? Didn't ppl talk about him before in the college as well?? I'm sure he was fully aware of the girls gawking at him, but he never cared....so where is this random logic coming in that NOW that he is in a relationship, ppl will talk about them?? I find this seriously stupid.