Mahabharat Episode Discussion Thread # 14 - Page 16

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

104.9k

Users

75

Likes

4.4k

Frequent Posters

Vr15h thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: thearcher

One more. Bheeshma and Karna were downed by Arjun which was necessary for Pandavas. But the 100 sons including Dury were done in by Bheem. Why is this character being treated as so much chump change?

Pandavon ka bal Arjun hai? 😕 How about Arjun AND Bheem?


Bhima did much more than just the 100 Kauravas. Included in his list was Bahlika, the brother of Santanu, some princes of Kalinga on day 3, and a whole bunch of others.

In fact, if one analyzes the war, almost all the killings of the Pandava warriors were done by either Drona or Ashwatthama. There were a few odd exceptions, where Bhurishrava, Karna, Bheeshma, Shalya, Duryodhan got to kill some warriors, but not many.

On the Pandava side, it was Bhima & Arjun, followed by Satyaki and then Abhimanyu & Ghatotkacha. Nakul killed 3 of Karna's sons, while Yudhistir & Sahadev killed Shalya & Shakuni

So yeah, Bhima was the bal of the Pandavas, not just Arjun. And Arjun had a rudransh - Hanuman - and a Narayana avatar - Krishna - on his chariot. Bhima had none of that, but did just as much damage.
Vr15h thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Sadhana_pr

True! I have wondered about this too. A blog post was shared on the forum which had a hilarious take on this. It said "can you imagine Thakur saying mujhe Gabbar nahin, unke checkpost-wala guard chahiye?"😆



Sadhana and Archer

We had discussed this a bit several months ago in this thread


You might find the discussions pretty interesting.

With Jayadrath, Arjun's motivaiton was seeing him dead b4 sunset due to his role in causing Abhimanyu's death. With Karna, Arjun had forgotten about that, but when Krishna reminded him of that by taunting Karna about what he had done w/ Abhimanyu, Arjun was as angry as he was w/ Jayadrath and went ahead and slew him
Vr15h thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Rehanism

In any case did Arjun expect Jayadrath to cordially greet them with a bouquet and give a free pass without a fight? Obviously he would resist them. He's ENEMY. That's his job. I guess it was all to avenge their hurt ego of being defeated by a mediocre Jayadrath, whom they had previously captured and enslaved. I don't see any reason why Jayadrath would be marked for Abhimanyu's death. Of all he was least responsible for Abhimanyu's death.



Not just that, like I pointed out in the cited thread Who killed Abhimanyu? Jayadrath was one of the 11 senapatis of the Kaurava akshaunis, and one of his jobs was to prevent Drona's chakravyuha from being broken. Or if it was, to fix it again. Just b'cos Abhimanyu had gone thru didn't mean that he had a moral obligation to let the rest of the Pandava army follow him. His job was to keep the chakravyuha intact, so that it could advance & capture Yudisthir.

Actually, I blame Arjun himself for being so quick tempered & touchy and carrying so much of baggage regarding his vows. Okay, so the Shamshaptakas challenged him, so what? His first duty there was to prevent Yudisthir from being captured, like he did on day 12. He was in the army as a major combatant for the Pandavas: it wasn't his job to go about personally responding to anybody and everybody who insulted him. Sooner or later, everyone in that side was gonna get killed - whether it was by himself, or by Bhima or Satyaki, what difference would it make? He should have remained w/ the main army and penetrated the chakravyuha. That would have saved his dear Abhimanyu, and also made that day too a Pandava victory.

The significance of Abhimanyu's death is that it aroused a casual Arjun, who up to then was not taking the war seriously, despite the Gita, despite Krishna getting off his chariot twice... Once Abhimanyu was killed, Arjun adapted the same attitude that Bhima did - that the enemy was the enemy. Up to that day - days 1-13, it's not known how many akshaunis of the Kauravas were destroyed. But on day 14, Arjun, along w/ Satyaki & Bhimasena, destroyed EIGHT of the 11 akshaunis of the Kauravas. Only 1 or 2 may have remained.
runi17 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: TheWatcher

^

Drona did not order Karna to break Abhimanyu's bow from behind and Karna did not break it from behind.

I think Jaydrath was one of the easiest target and hence Arjuna chose him, he had already vow'd for killing Karna, why not kill him before the next sunset or immolate himself, he was not able to kill Jaydrath without help - let alone killing Karna before the sunset.

However, there can be another reason for Arjuna vowing to kill Jaydrath - Rage - He just lost his son, he was blinded by rage and he chose the first person in line viz, Jaydrath.



Hey,i am a new user here...don't feel offended pls but actually according to the sanskrit slokas drona did advice karna to cut the bow of abhimanyu 4m behind d back position & he did it apparently...don't know y KMG missed it or whatever...here is d link...http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/mbs/mbs07047.htm...check d sloka no.29 & 31...clearly states drona advised him.."paschat praharanam kuru" i.e. hit him 4m behind & in 31,karna cut d bow standing behind...not trying 2 demean any1..jst stating what i read
srishtisingh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
abt arjun vowing to kill jaydrath I read somewhere an analysis I found interesting! it was being an strategic move to force kaurava forces in a defensive mode, and gave pandavas a better opportunity to b in offensive mode! since whole k army was concentrated only on protecting jaydrath
Vr15h thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
Inline comments:

Originally posted by: shyam09

Here are the top moments / epiphanies I saw / had:
1) There can't be a child more worse than StarAshwatthama ... this goes beyond the boundaries of peer pressure and beyond the realm of stupidity ... the kid is blackmailing his dad to his death.

Why doesn't Drona remind him that he's a brahmin, and if he's that scared of dying, he should withdraw from the war?
2) StarBhim clearly doesn't understand what happens when Indra's Shakti collides with Brahmastra ... not that I know either, but I figure using one Brahmastra is bad enough on it's image, but using it to counter Indra's shakti isn't going to be result in the showering of flower petals

Even the real Bhima was defiant towards weapons - when Ashwi released the Narayanastra at the Pandavas after Drona's death, everybody surrendered to it @ Krishna's orders - everybody except Mr Vrikodar. As a result, that weapon stopped focussing on anybody else and zeroed in on him. A braveheart's braveheart!!! 👏

3) StarDrona, despite saying that he has no greed for being the commander, still sort of accepts it. It's shown as being a last resort to protect his son, but still there wasn't a need for him to make that vow. He clearly could have turned the tables to his favor saying - you want me, but I don't want you ... so let's cut a deal. I will capture StarYuddhi, end the war, and voila!

See above - he could have played the caste card, which he was playing w/ ⭐️Karna

4) StarAswatthama has proved that he is StarDuryodhan's misteress (get it "mister"ess ... ahaha punny ... ok bad joke)

Already we had KaJu, where both were in bi- relationships, and where KaJu broke up after Ka insulted Ju's other 1/2, or 1/3, or 1/4, or 1/5, or 1/10 (depending on whether one counts Ka himself, or Subhadra, or Krishna, or the remaining 4 Pandavas) In this one, the 2 were genetically related, but only 1 knew it at this time.

Now, in your new scenario, you have an inter-caste dostana relationship b/w Brahmin Ashwi & Kshatriya Duri. I wonder what the shastras say about such relationships - are they pratiloma or upaloma? 😈🤣

5) StarBhim already takes down Vikarna ... aww ... but looks like StarYuyutsu will be saved (he isn't part of Dury's 99 brothers, he is Dury's step brother).

Why, did ⭐️Bhima say anything specific about Vikarna?
6) Was there any closure on StarShikandi yesterday?

What exactly is supposed to happen to ⭐️Shikhandi? Is she supposed to turn back into a princess, or is the yaksha supposed to get cursed? Also, if Shikhandi becomes Shikhandini again, does Ashwi kill her in the night attack? Or would ⭐️Shakuni finish the job by stabbing her again, and this time, since she's no longer needed to down Mahamahim Bheeeshm, she can be allowed to peacefully become virgati prapt?

7) That dialogue where Arjun tells Madhav that it's time to go say Pranipath to Angraj was perhaps the best moment. KAJU ZINDABAD!
8) Why can't StarPandavas implement Operation Capture the Dury ... I mean the only difference this time is that there isn't Bhishma to do any protecting. Arjun keeps Karna busy, Drona is kept busy by BFF and BFF's son, and Bhim is free to take on Dury. Or was that operation taken because Bhim wasn't allowed to kill Dury's bro's because Bhishma was commander?

Due to the shakti, Arjun shouldn't fight Karna. So let Abhi fight Karna, Arjun Drona or Ashwi, Drupada or Dhrishtadyumna the other of those 2, Bhima go after Dury, Virata after Shakuni, Shikhandi after Dushashan (who she did defeat during the gurudakshina war, remember?) and Prativindya after Susharma. Yudhi can invade Hastinapur again 😈 forcing Drona to leave, and leaving the Kauravas again @ Bhima's mercy. Think we have everyone covered, right? Since this war has no Kripacharya, no Satyaki, no Bhurishravas, no Bhagadatta, nobody... Yeah, they should resume that operation to capture Dury.

9) I like StarKarna's challenge talks more than any other character (I mean just whatever he says and whatever actions he does. It's fresh, it's awesome, it's not that boring ... for example, during the KaJu moment, whenever Ka spoke, I was attentive but the moment Ju started to speak my mind slightly got distracted.)
10) I hope StarKarna wins. The way he got off the chariot to wipe the dirt / dust of the Kurukshetra on his forehead -- no other person has done this during the war. Money is on you StarKarna. Don't fail me! Take down those StarPandavas and then those StarKauravas so you can become the StarKing of StarHastinapur!!

Karna reminds me of Maharana Veer Hammir, the founder of the Sisodia dynasty of Mewar. That ruler was the first to do something like that, and looks like authors got so impressed that they had prior heros doing them. Ramanand Sagar had Rama doing that after his return to Ayodhya, and now we have Swastik having Vasusena doing that.

AnuMP thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Thanks for the link Vrish. The thread discusses the same things
I understand the immediate rage and going after Jayadrath

One thing I cannot agree on is Yudhi being at fault. I am NOT AT ALL a fan of Yudhishtir. But he is the king and as such has to be prepared to send people to certain death.

I would blame Drona most of all. That is why I cannot wrap my head around Arjun's anger at Dhrisht for killing the nishastra guru Dron.

Karna too, to a lesser extent.

Dusshy's son, the actual murderer, was killed by Half-Bratha Shruthakirti
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
But Dushy'son is killed by abhi right?.. Or does he kills dury's son...?? As he vowed too na
Vr15h thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
Archer

I too don't blame Yudhi here - it was their bad luck that their plan failed. Like I mentioned, I blame none other than Arjun himself - like responding to enemies who insulted him was more important than keeping his king from being captured by the enemy. Nice sense of priorities.

About Arjun's anger @ Dhrishtadyumna, it's a BRC invention. I think we're deviating from discussing the ⭐️wars here, so I've posted about it in the Kurukshetra thread. Feel free to discuss.
Edited by .Vrish. - 11 years ago
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Surya_krsnbhakt

Wow Kaju Ke Beech Hasya-Baan?

"Lagta hain aapko mere us roop ka vismaran nahi hua hain"🤣


I cannot get over the shock of hearing such a taunt and Madhav-Parth snicker over that -- OMG what?🤣

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".