Episode 407 Discussion: 19th Oct 2013 - Page 14

Originally posted by: EvIlNeSs_RoCkZ

I dont understand what exactly did ppl find 'oh so hot' in that shotting scene?...RM have done hotter scenes than this in their bedroom and bathroom 😆😆

And for once i liked RK not reacting at MC for shouting at Madhu...we have had enough of hyper n crazy RK...lets see now what he has say abt it today coz he hasnt spoken yet 😆

Regarding this track...Pabho track is Madhu centric...movie track is not Madhu centric but RM centric..and Amar track is RK centric same way...just bcoz Pabho-Madhu track eats a lot of screen space thats why it looks all Madhu track 😆

Guys..let's get a grip here..

Originally posted by: _charu_

thanks..

Leela, just as everyone here has the right to rant, i can also present my POV...I have the same privilege of freedom of speech...this is exactly what i wanted to say if when I go non stop ranting, it may be very hurting & not very pleasant to read...I can be patient with all , you don't see me in ranting mode too often, not on the EDT or on the MF..i dun go about posting my views in every other threads opposing/supporting.. I expect some sensitivity frm others too bec. we all are mature , sane individuals, we're not crazy fangirls..

not liking certain character/track / story or whatever is perfectly okay...expressing your dissatisfaction over it is perfectly okay...but not beyond a point...pages and pages and pages of MAT were dedicated to it and now the EDT..same point...kill RK, shut down the show , the TRPs will tank is all tht i get to read ! fine yaar, u want the show to shut down, it will shut down, at least let others watch peacefully till the time it lasts...when you're in a group, and you're discussing a topic, and you're aware that your views may hurt someone, what do u do? exercise freedom of speech ? or may be I am too sensitive, i expect a little bit more...i'll rather follow your advise and ignore and rant freely frm now on, in favor of MB..

Charu, look at it from the other way. And this is not about freedom of speech.
If those who don't like the track have to read page after page praising the track and they never comment on those praises, then can they not expect the courtesy of not having their criticisms commented on and belittled?
If some don't understand the criticisms, it's obvious that those criticizing find the praise equally ununderstandable.
I hit 'like' for many EDT posts I don't agree with because MAS used to have hitting 'like' as an acknowledgement.
Those who like this track's presentation for whatever reason, can they not imagine their own feelings if they disliked the track instead?
Can't all of us on EDT and MAT just be content to like what one likes and not criticize or try to understand why others don't like it. Please? That way everyone can express themselves without feeling their opinions will be adversely commented on.

Originally posted by: Soundarya22

SD made the MB VERSE CC precisely to rant so that MAT and EDT can do what they are supposed to do. let's move there and discuss, argue ? We don't have to get so het up after every episode, isn't it tiring?

Originally posted by: ClosetRomantic

Yes girls, lets take it to the chat thread or sort it out over PMs. And lets raise are hands and say in unison "MB ko leke emotional hone ka haq hai sirf mera" 😉 😛

Soundarya, CR, I disagree. Others have felt repeatedly targetted on MAT and EDT previously as well for being negative about something when others are positive about it.
If those who dislike something don't comment or criticize the positive opinions, then can't that courtesy and acceptance be reciprocated, please?
And to be shunted to the CC for being strongly critical about an episode and/or track is beyond biased.
Each person is free to ignore other's posts or just hit 'like' as acknowledgement even if one disagrees with the opinion.
We don't have to comment on - or even read - differing posts or hurt people's feelings by asking why they have such strange opinions. It's a mirror fact. If you disagree with an opinion, your own opinion is equally disagreed with in that context.
We can be courteous enough not to offend real people for a fictional track. Surely that is doable?

Originally posted by: leelaa9

[
Charu, look at it from the other way. And this is not about freedom of speech.
If those who don't like the track have to read page after page praising the track and they never comment on those praises, then can they not expect the courtesy of not having their criticisms commented on and belittled?
If some don't understand the criticisms, it's obvious that those criticizing find the praise equally ununderstandable.
I hit 'like' for many EDT posts I don't agree with because MAS used to have hitting 'like' as an acknowledgement.
Those who like this track's presentation for whatever reason, can they not imagine their own feelings if they disliked the track instead?
Can't all of us on EDT and MAT just be content to like what one likes and not criticize or try to understand why others don't like it. Please? That way everyone can express themselves without feeling their opinions will be adversely commented on.

Leela, please feel free to like posts that you genuinely like, whether they are of the same opinion or differing opinion..
Shri suggested that we like all posts just so that we can appreciate differing views and perspectives but it is not a hard and fast rule...

Negative views and criticism are much welcomed in this thread but can we all put forth it objectively instead of going on and on about it in a ranty manner.? It makes the thread messy for reading. I myself have ranted so many times in my stay in this thread and so I can understand when others rant..

It is the positive and negative reviews that have made me always seek refuge in this thread and I want it to continue that way..

Thanks and peace!!!!

Charu, if I wanted to say anything personal or critical to you, I would have PMed you, not posted here. Even when I don't agree with your opinions, I usually though not always hit 'like' as acknowledgement of your expressed opinions.
What I have posted today here was requests to everyone on EDT and MAT so that we can avoid any such altercations.
It's a track. And yet, if anyone has a different opinion, then that is picked apart so that a rejoinder is needed.
It becomes hurtful, and all for differing opinions about a fictional track.

Zoya, I know that it's not a hard and fast rule. But if people come to EDT and express their opinion, then it's an acknowledgement of their having posted. But sometimes an episode or track hits at what individuals love about the series. If those posts are acknowledged with a 'like' or ignored rather than turned into an argument, we may have less people worried about posting what they feel. And it does go both ways. Disliking something doesn't prevent us from acknowledging others praise of that very point.
I've posted a lot today on this, but would wish none of us - liking or disliking episodes or tracks - feel hurt in any instances simply because opinions differ.

Originally posted by: leelaa9

Charu, if I wanted to say anything personal or critical to you, I would have PMed you, not posted here. Even when I don't agree with your opinions, I usually though not always hit 'like' as acknowledgement of your expressed opinions.
What I have posted today here was requests to everyone on MAT on EDT so that we can avoid any such altercations.
It's a track. And yet, if anyone has a different opinion, then that is picked apart so that a rejoinder is needed.
It becomes hurtful, and all for differing opinions about a fictional track.