Episode 407 Discussion: 19th Oct 2013 - Page 13

Created

Last reply

Replies

153

Views

16.1k

Users

29

Likes

1.4k

Frequent Posters

Poluk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: _charu_


WE will obviously not like MC yelling at Madhu bec. we can never like our favs being yelled at and controlled by someone..and we're so used to RK taking every tom dick and harry to task for not behaving with his wife 😆 till this point, he has been doing but this..but now it's a serious matter, the shooting was going on & Madhu had to perform which she cud not..everything was happening so fast that may be they didn't get time to discuss the scene or share their inhibitions...

Directors r known to be sanki and tough task masters...sometimes the actors think that they shot is okay but the director makes them reshoot the sequence, or they have something in their mind which actors don't register & the atmosphere becomes tense as shooting cannot progress..it's so regular in Bollywood..i heard a lot of stories abt Sanjay Leela Bhansali..actors don't usually interfere in their work...on the sets, Madhu is not RK's wife but his co star..yet, he has always been supportive of her..he has always encouraged her & made sure she feels comfortable..but RK also lost it when Madhu cud not concentrate in her first shot...


Even in our office before an imp. meeting I am the one shouting at my subordinates. My boss is shouting at me. No one even minds it because the environment is very tense and people are tired. They are working beyond their endurance limit.

It happens and is human. Here they did not show the number of takes MB was giving but must be lots.

And creative people do get cranky when what they are able to visualise in their brain doesnot get converted to real. Humans also are of different categories (established scientific rule). Creative people are picture people as compared to most of us who are sound people.

RK himself being creative and experienced could understand the problem at play and so kept quiet.

MC is used to dealing with film industry women/debutantes which as a rule do not have inhibitions. He also must have thought that they are husband and wife without realizing that being intimate in bedroom and being intimate in public are different.

But yes some amount of sensitivity should have been shown regarding keeping the minimum number of crew.


Edited by Poluk - 11 years ago
leelaa9 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
There was a lot of ranting in the past several months because then too leads were behaving uncharacteristically to accommodate a track.
Now when the same thing is happening for this track, if any of us do not like the butchering, why do we have to be told off for ranting just because the other ranters of the past several months aren't feeling like ranting now?

Guys, if any of us don't like a post's viewpoint as it differs from our own, we can ignore it.
But if no adverse comments are made for finding positivity in a track, then could there also be no adverse comments for not being positive about a track?

It's simple enough and very easy to be cordial and not hurt other people's feelings for a dratted track - ignore their posts, and don't make comments about their lack of understanding. Please?

And Hiya, please don't leave.
Edited by leelaa9 - 11 years ago
ClosetRomantic thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
WIP, nobody is getting personal! This is just a healthy discussion with everybody putting in their bit and the best thing is everybody is right in their own ways. Any type of art is open to different interpretations.

Please don't think of leaving the thread Different viewpoints is what makes EDT interesting.
Edited by ClosetRomantic - 11 years ago
Valar.Morghulis thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
Oyi Hiyu! Don't leave. Please.
I hardly see you these days!!
I don't think Charu meant it that way... aren't we all having a healthy debate here?
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: war_is_peace


i have issues when RK looks like a brainless fellow roaming around on sets.

i have never bashed RK...i am among those who started seeing during the wedding, left seeing during ballu track and again started seeing coz of unwedding...i saw all those episodes million times...i keep watching the knife scenes n terrace scenes coz i love them.

this is the only time i m not liking it coz it shatters my image of RK...

charu u dont need to get personal everytime.
i just shudnt have come to this thread too. i'm sorry if my comments hurt anyone.
i'm hurt to see RK like this.
i'm out now.

sorry MAS but, i needed to clear this.


you don't have to tell me Hiya, i know how much you like MB, and we all loved it till Sultan entered & spoiled it all...

i never got personal with you, i dunno which of my comments made u think so...freedom of speech is exercised both ways ? I was only trying to understand different perceptions on RK..I don't understand frm where do these terms like "RK is selling his wife, RK is making a public display of his wife" come from..what has he done actually ? there was a similar discussion on the MAT when Madhu was introduced as his heroine... do we want him to act like a possessive husband or understanding husband? do we want him to act like a MCP or broad minded individual? Sultan was eyeing his wife & he had a major problem with it...how is it similar to RM shooting for an intimate scene? if he should be calling the shots, why did he require a team ? he cud have directed the movie himself...honestly, i'm too much confused with our expectations frm these characters that's it...

till now, no other show has dared to experiment on the heroine's character as they're doing with Madhu...her husband is supportive of her (being an arrogant, obsessive, possessive psycho that he was made out to be), we should appreciate it or we should write it off...😕
Edited by _charu_ - 11 years ago
Poluk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: _charu_


Shruti ko dekh..."main raat ko akele repeat dekhoongi" 🤣


Mera beta pehle hi bahut bigada hua hai. Aur nahin bigadna.

Also, he has already been proposed twice in class the age of 8. Don't want him to accept.🤣

And being a mummy doesnt mean that I have to deprive myself. I also have human rights.🤣

Sorry MAS for the off the episode discussion.😊
Rangaaa thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: _charu_


WE will obviously not like MC yelling at Madhu bec. we can never like our favs being yelled at and controlled by someone..and we're so used to RK taking every tom dick and harry to task for not behaving with his wife 😆 till this point, he has been doing but this..but now it's a serious matter, the shooting was going on & Madhu had to perform which she cud not..everything was happening so fast that may be they didn't get time to discuss the scene or share their inhibitions...

Directors r known to be sanki and tough task masters...sometimes the actors think that they shot is okay but the director makes them reshoot the sequence, or they have something in their mind which actors don't register & the atmosphere becomes tense as shooting cannot progress..it's so regular in Bollywood..i heard a lot of stories abt Sanjay Leela Bhansali..actors don't usually interfere in their work...on the sets, Madhu is not RK's wife but his co star..yet, he has always been supportive of her..he has always encouraged her & made sure she feels comfortable..but RK also lost it when Madhu cud not concentrate in her first shot...

i didn't like it not bcoz RM r my favs...but wht he was expecting should have been from a seasoned actress and here Madhu is a novice...but after reading a lot of reviews on this particular scene, i guess his expectations might have got raised after seeing her do scenes in one take the prev day...so he got frustrated...may be he might apologize for his behavior or might understand Madhu's discomfort on the next shoot...
Poluk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Hiya, please don't leave. People will always have divergent views. What else makes a good discussion. Object if you don't like something but please stay.😊

601348 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
I dont understand what exactly did ppl find 'oh so hot' in that shooting scene?...RM have done hotter scenes than this in their bedroom and bathroom 😆😆
And for once i liked RK not reacting at MC for shouting at Madhu...we have had enough of hyper n crazy RK...lets see now what he has say abt it today coz he hasnt spoken yet 😆
Regarding this track...Pabho track is Madhu centric...movie track is not Madhu centric but RM centric..and Amar track is RK centric same way...just bcoz Pabho-Madhu track eats a lot of screen space thats why it looks all Madhu track 😆
Edited by EvIlNeSs_RoCkZ - 11 years ago
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: leelaa9

There was a lot of ranting in the past several months because then too leads were behaving uncharacteristically to accommodate a track.
Now when the same thing is happening for this track, if any of us do not like the butchering, why do we have to be told off for ranting just because the other ranters of the past several months aren't feeling like ranting now?

Guys, if any of us don't like a post's viewpoint as it differs from our own, we can ignore it.
But if no adverse comments are made for finding positivity in a track, then could there also be no adverse comments for not being positive about a track?

It's simple enough and very easy to be cordial and not hurt other people's feelings for a dratted track - ignore their posts, and don't make comments about their lack of understanding. Please?

And Hiya, please don't leave.


thanks..

Leela, just as everyone here has the right to rant, i can also present my POV...I have the same privilege of freedom of speech...this is exactly what i wanted to say if when I go non stop ranting, it may be very hurting & not very pleasant to read...I can be patient with all , you don't see me in ranting mode too often, not on the EDT or on the MF..i dun go about posting my views in every other threads opposing/supporting.. I expect some sensitivity frm others IN THIS GROUP bec. we all are mature , sane individuals, we're not crazy fangirls..

not liking certain character/track / story or whatever is perfectly okay...expressing your dissatisfaction over it is perfectly okay...but not beyond a point...pages and pages and pages of MAT were dedicated to it and now the EDT..same point...kill RK, shut down the show , the TRPs will tank is all tht i get to read ! fine yaar, u want the show to shut down, it will shut down, at least let others watch peacefully till the time it lasts...when you're in a group, and you're discussing a topic, and you're aware that your views may hurt someone, what do u do? exercise freedom of speech ? or may be I am too sensitive, i expect a little bit more...i'll rather follow your advise and ignore and rant freely frm now on, in favor of MB..

Edited by _charu_ - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".