Created

Last reply

Replies

107

Views

9.2k

Users

16

Likes

441

Frequent Posters

KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: shweta2728



And "IF" that doesn't happen then...?

Btw the next track is not that at all. Its RK-Sullu's bhai-bhai track cuz dd needs time for jdj.


Then I will admit that I gave these CVs too much credit, and they are just another bunch of writers and a PH that portray jackass love stories.

Maybe I'll watch Sultan's scenes, while RK and Madhu can be happy and in "love."
Edited by likarsh - 12 years ago
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#92

Originally posted by: shweta2728


So what should have RK done that would have made you and other people realize that he really loves Madhu and he has redeemed himself? Please answer! I will read what you wrote, tomorrow morning. Till then good night!


For one thing. Stop treating Madhu as a possession. When he does that, then perhaps we can talk about redemption.
alina.b thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: likarsh



Then I will admit that I gave these CVs too much credit, and they are just another bunch of writers and a PH that portray jackass love stories.

Maybe I'll watch Sultan's scenes, while RK and Madhu can be happy and in "love."



Good. I will watch Rishbala happy and in love while sullu has his own lil story going on. Now...good night! 😊
Charishma thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#94

Originally posted by: shweta2728

@Charisma

Well "IF" RK is lying then I would also want Madhu to leave along with 80% of the viewers. It would be torture to all of us.

But I don't think RK is lying. He might be teasing her.



I considered this too. But then this leaves very little story to be told. Because RK will have in essence been redeemed (whatever that means lol). What else then? They're going to stretch this show for all its worth, and redeeming RK (this early in the game) is not a part of it. They'd be shooting themselves in the foot. Him, Sultan, Madhu, they are all intertwined now. And redeeming RK would cut the story short and maybe even give it a different ending.

I do question RK's heartbreak when he found Sultan in Madhu's room. I had expected a quick forgiveness scene between him and Madhu, wherein he was clearly manipulating her. But they went a different route. If his pain was genuine then they might redeem him much later on. His character does have its worth. A lot hinges on keeping him as is.

RK will probably the same until they absolutely have to show change. Four things could happen I think: (1) He'll either slowly get darker and darker, until he looses himself fully in the darkness, (2) He genuinly tries to get "better", but fails every now and then. He might then die in some heroic attempt to save someone maybe. Basically redeeming himself in death, (3) Slowly redeeming himself. I find this least likely, because like I said, it changes his character mold. RK has no empathy. (4) They redeem him in a blast. Like if he lost his memory or something. The whole nature or nurture thing.

Idk if this is my bias or what else. I just have a very hard time seeing a 'good' RK. Because I don't think he's capable. And I don't think either he or the writers want it. I guess it depends on whether any of those things every change.

aand that concludes my essay lol
Edited by Charishma - 12 years ago
practicecalm thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#95

Originally posted by: Charishma



I considered this too. But then this leaves very little story to be told. Because RK will have in essence been redeemed (whatever that means lol). What else then? They're going to stretch this show for all its worth, and redeeming RK (this early in the game) is not a part of it. They'd be shooting themselves in the foot. Him, Sultan, Madhu, they are all intertwined now. And redeeming RK would cut the story short and maybe even give it a different ending.

I do question RK's heartbreak when he found Sultan in Madhu's room. I had expected a quick forgiveness scene between him and Madhu, wherein he was clearly manipulating her. But they went a different route. If his pain was genuine then they might redeem him much later on. His character does have its worth. A lot hinges on keeping him as is.

RK will probably the same until they absolutely have to show change. Four things could happen I think: (1) He'll either slowly get darker and darker, until he looses himself fully in the darkness, (2) He genuinly tries to get "better", but fails every now and then. He might then die in some heroic attempt to save someone maybe. Basically redeeming himself in death, (3) Slowly redeeming himself. I find this least likely, because like I said, it changes his character mold. RK has no empathy. (4) They redeem him in a blast. Like if he lost his memory or something. The whole nature or nurture thing.

Idk if this is my bias or what else. I just have a very hard time seeing a 'good' RK. Because I don't think he's capable. And I don't think either he or the writers want it. I guess it depends on whether any of those things every change.

aand that concludes my essay lol



👏 👏 👏 what changed RK if at all this little bit is also only the fear of losing her (to Sultan) - he fears competition and goes after the jugular just to get his way, by nook or crook, let the RK worshippers not keep dreaming of a completely redeemed RK who worships and loves Madhu as he is the one that wants to be worshipped and loved, bhaad mein jaaye Madhu aur uski har rishta, be it mother, sister or Mallik
alina.b thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#96

Originally posted by: Charishma



I considered this too. But then this leaves very little story to be
told. Because RK will have in essence been redeemed (whatever that means lol). What else then? They're going to stretch this show for all its worth, and
redeeming RK (this early in the game) is not a part of it. They'd be
shooting themselves in the foot. Him, Sultan, Madhu, they are all intertwined now. And redeeming RK would cut the story short and maybe even give it a different ending.

I do
question RK's heartbreak when he found Sultan in Madhu's room. I had
expected a quick forgiveness scene between him and Madhu, wherein he was clearly manipulating her. But they went a different route. If his pain
was genuine then they might redeem him much later on. His character does have its worth. A lot hinges on keeping him as is.

RK will probably the same until they absolutely have to show change. Four things could happen I think: (1) He'll either slowly get darker and darker, until he looses himself fully in the darkness, (2) He genuinly tries to get "better", but fails every now and then. He might then die in some heroic attempt to save someone maybe. Basically redeeming himself in death, (3) Slowly redeeming himself. I find this least likely, because like I said, it changes his character mold. RK has no empathy. (4) They redeem him in a blast. Like if he lost his memory or something. The whole nature or nurture thing.

Idk if this is my bias or what else. I just have a very hard time seeing a 'good' RK. Because I don't think he's capable. And I don't think either he or the writers want it. I guess it depends on whether any of those things every change.

aand that concludes my essay lol



Haha your predictions would be a dream come true for Sulbala fans! 😆 But I personally think that it isn't RK but Sultan's turn to turn dark.
alina.b thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#97

Originally posted by: likarsh



For one thing. Stop treating Madhu as a possession. When he does that, then perhaps we can talk about redemption.



Okay so we get past that part and now we are standing in front of the redemption part. Now will you please tell me how RK could have redeemed himself according to you?
gator thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#98
Looking at the argument Im so sure now that rk fans are PG-13 phans and sultan phans are rated R audience as in adults who look for more in their man than Just looks. I've yet to watch todays epi where ill fwd the wedding drama and watch sultans story 😉
693326 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#99
the forum tried their best to mk sultan kuku bhatias son...but alas sultan to the forumss beloved belovd dad MOHAN KUNDRA...

bravo cvs

forum tried utmost to prove sultan is a NAJAYAJ LUV CHILD...but Mkundra MARRIED meera...
bravo cvs


Forum wants Sultan to tk money frm rk...hv they forgotten Sultan himself is RICH...even rk said to mb once that her sadakchap bf PAISAWAALA hai..plus in the spoilers its written sultan will refuse to tk money...aww...dil ke armaan ansoo mein beh gaye

Bravo cvs

.
forum was all ready to demean sultan n his mom in every way possible BUT thnx to the spoilers...cvs hv Shut the doors real hard

SALUTE to cvs



n even if he tks badla on rk family...that will also b with dignity...SULTAN is all abt DIgNITY
Charishma thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: gator

Looking at the argument Im so sure now that rk fans are PG-13 phans and sultan phans are rated R audience as in adults who look for more in their man than Just looks. I've yet to watch todays epi where ill fwd the wedding drama and watch sultans story 😉



lol i love your analogy. spot on 👏. but really, no matter the actor (or character) fans will always get slightly worshipful. Hopefully cvs don't make Sultan out to be some saint in the show though. He is a trigger happy gangster afterall. I hope they get a balance with him.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".