RK's Redepmtion? Or RK's Victory? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

3.3k

Users

28

Likes

145

Frequent Posters

mozart66 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
Beautiful post as always!! Perfectly logical!! Agree with you wholeheartedly. I have been thinking of the same thing. After reading so many posts, I pity those thread makers for rooting for Rishbala without understanding the essence of the characters or the story. Often actors are abused by the viewers keeping in mind the characters they play! Even though it is an actor's accomplishment that he / she has succeeded in portraying the character well!

In case of Madhubala, she has been shown as a strong girl who stands for what she believes in and fights for it. She was literally tricked by RK in creating the illusion of his love for her successfully but once she realizes it, why should she go back to such a person?Never in the history of Indian television have they shown a hero with a few grey shades really repenting, regretting, redeeming or seeking help, proving himself to be worthy of the woman he has abused. And I must agree with your point that most of the viewers just relish these "heroes" the way they are and if for any reason the actor chooses to leave a show (very unprofessional on their part but that is not the point here), viewers create a ruckus over these issues spoiling good stories. Almost all viewers forget that actors PLAY the characters!!

I really appreciate your post here that hopefully will open the eyes of the viewers and will stop creating threads that are mostly nonsensical or very superficial. In spite of the fact that every person has a freedom of speech and can express their views on a public forum, at least the content should be sensible.

As for the strong characters of any serial, one should learn something good from such characters and not accept anything that is dished out by the creatives that can hamper a healthy society. If a woman like Madhu is trying to come out of the trauma and is learning to fight for her survival then by all means we should support that and not expect some stupid goody-goody romance between the leads where the male lead is invariably a flawed character. In all the reality, we do accept flawed people in our lives, no doubt. We even live with them but do we ever try to stand up for ourselves and make a difference? If a serial is providing me ways to tackle things in my own life, teaching a good lesson or two then I wouldn't want the leads to just engage in the stupid romance. Anyway, romance is what sells. What can I say? That's exactly what the mind-set of the viewers is. So this is just a wishful thinking.
..Sujith1001.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: fia21



It's alright. Haters will hate. And she indirectly just proved my point of the biased attitude I was talking about so no worries. All is well 😉


Well said, But it is really hurting to see neutral posts getting snide comments! 😕
Anyways, Let me ignore that, just like u did! 😉
Edited by BrightLover - 12 years ago
..Sujith1001.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: mozart66

Beautiful post as always!! Perfectly logical!! Agree with you wholeheartedly. I have been thinking of the same thing. After reading so many posts, I pity those thread makers for rooting for Rishbala without understanding the essence of the characters or the story. Often actors are abused by the viewers keeping in mind the characters they play! Even though it is an actor's accomplishment that he / she has succeeded in portraying the character well!


In case of Madhubala, she has been shown as a strong girl who stands for what she believes in and fights for it. She was literally tricked by RK in creating the illusion of his love for her successfully but once she realizes it, why should she go back to such a person?Never in the history of Indian television have they shown a hero with a few grey shades really repenting, regretting, redeeming or seeking help, proving himself to be worthy of the woman he has abused. And I must agree with your point that most of the viewers just relish these "heroes" the way they are and if for any reason the actor chooses to leave a show (very unprofessional on their part but that is not the point here), viewers create a ruckus over these issues spoiling good stories. Almost all viewers forget that actors PLAY the characters!!

I really appreciate your post here that hopefully will open the eyes of the viewers and will stop creating threads that are mostly nonsensical or very superficial. In spite of the fact that every person has a freedom of speech and can express their views on a public forum, at least the content should be sensible.

As for the strong characters of any serial, one should learn something good from such characters and not accept anything that is dished out by the creatives that can hamper a healthy society. If a woman like Madhu is trying to come out of the trauma and is learning to fight for her survival then by all means we should support that and not expect some stupid goody-goody romance between the leads where the male lead is invariably a flawed character. In all the reality, we do accept flawed people in our lives, no doubt. We even live with them but do we ever try to stand up for ourselves and make a difference? If a serial is providing me ways to tackle things in my own life, teaching a good lesson or two then I wouldn't want the leads to just engage in the stupid romance. Anyway, romance is what sells. What can I say? That's exactly what the mind-set of the viewers is. So this is just a wishful thinking.


Superb thoughts, well said ! 👏
leverne thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: BrightLover


How rude?!
She hasnt bashed anyone!
Like u urself said, if u don't like this post, Y r u wasting ur precious time in this Post?
Y cant u please practice what u preach?

This was what u told me in ur Post :


"if u don't like no problem Ignore my post apna khimti waqt kyun wast karti ho..."



Lol Suj...People should practice what they preach.

@fia...what an awesome post...Very well written...Even i know Rishbala are the end game...but I dont want madhu to return back to RK at this very point...may be in future if RK repents, we shall see...

But right now...i am seeing lots of potential in Sulbala are am rooting for them...

PS: This show is about madhubala only...not RK or Sultan..they are just a part of her story...👏👏👏
Arnav90 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#15
I agree with each n every word u said, Even I can see only Rishbala as jodi but not now bcoz Rk had done enough, I want redemtion 4m Rk for each n every mistake then i can think of Rishbala but the terms n conditions I will support when I will feel satisfied with the repenting n Madhu can forgive now
_innocent_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#16
What a fantastic post! I have to run, so will not be able to give a detailed jawab! But then again your post is so brilliant that it does not require me to say much anyway. I prefer taking a realistic stance to situations in fictional shows, especially when that show tries to convey real social messages! Becuase I feel like, illiterate people learn a lot from these types of shows (eg..women who have not been to school, sit at home and watch the show, tend to get something back from it)
Anywhoo! This show is about Madhubala as an individual! Its about ehr joourney, her life her end! If only those blindfull individuals would understand that! ANyways, finally, the makers have sttarted to focus on building the character of Madhubala, and am loving it!Fantastic post! Agreed with each and every point! I logged off, but came back on just to comment here😆See you around!
Renu13 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
nice post..loved it👍🏼
though I love Rishbala but I dont want Madhu to go back to RK untill he realise his mistake & accept her infront of whole world with respect n dignity...Im surprised how could female fans defending RK & blams Madhu for humiliation only coz he looks hot n smart everything is justified
Edited by RENU1111 - 12 years ago
-Veritaserum- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#18
Brilliant post 👏
I don't want Madhu to go back to RK..
I'm not so sure about the redemption too... RS told that redemption has already started but all I got to see after that was RK insulting Madhu in public 🤢


Edited by Luv_Drashti - 12 years ago
Manonidz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#19
Well written Fia 😊

Swapna actually raised a very valid point why Madhu can't love anybody else after suffering an utter abusive relation!...Practically, its very much feasible as some girls really show the guts to allow their heart to FEEL the same emotion once again but certainly, its not easy for all! 😊..As far as this show is concerned, its all upto the makers what sort of message they want to put across. As far as many female members here not empathizing with Madhu's pain, I guess they are quite busy searching pain in RK's eyes!😆 See, that's indeed a tough task !😆
asp99 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#20
nice post..loved it👍🏼
though I love Rishbala but I dont want Madhu to go back to RK untill he realise his mistake & accept her infront of whole world with respect n dignity...Im surprised how could female fans defending RK & blams Madhu for humiliation only coz he looks hot n smart everything is justified
Agree but one thing It has to Madhus acceptance n why should RK has to accept Madhu noways if ever it happens it has to be Madhu who wl decide whether to forgive RK or not and how Madhu will convince herself as to when he is acting n when not? if she ever accepts she wl always be under this question i alwasys ask this question if i am in her place wil i ever get hapiness or will i hav doubt about the persons love? Sorry if i am wrong.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".