RK's Redepmtion? Or RK's Victory? - Page 3

i am agree thats why i am not happy with cvs if they shown all this love or ishq or junoon this type of ishaq is psycho.

Agreed with you in each n every thing what u said somehow i do not know what people r asking for redemed RK when he convinced Madhu n we audience that his love was true n unwed thing came as shock to Madhu n to us also how authentic wl be redemed RK plus one mpre thing it has to be madhus acceptance n not RK s acceptance of Madhu if ever it happens but i would like Madhu not to accept the Redemed RK of as that wil be again the start of eyelocks n romance i want RK to reach a stage where he himself says that NO i donot deserved to be with Madhu n that wl be my defination of redemed RK . VD i must say is the lukiest actor having being selected for this role n doing full justice to it. Rest is in the hands of CVs n i wish they give us something really unique.

the way they are showing victory of RKs ego...I just cant see any redemption...

Firstly, regarding the part in blue. Who says Madhu SHOULD NOT move on? IF she WANTS...surely she has all the rights to move on. Forgiving RK...accepting his love and coming back to him or not...is her CHOICE absolutely. And though am a woman, but sorry am not a feminist and I just don't watch this show from Madhu's POV. (Hope its not a crime 😆). I am no feminist who TELLS what another woman should do with her life.

Originally posted by: PurpleHorizon

Firstly, regarding the part in blue. Who says Madhu SHOULD NOT move on? IF she WANTS...surely she has all the rights to move on. Forgiving RK...accepting his love and coming back to him or not...is her CHOICE absolutely. And though am a women, but sorry am not a feminist and I just don't watch this show from Madhu's POV. (Hope its not a crime 😆). I am no feminist who TELLS what another women should do with her life.

Anyways, I disagree with few things that you said. But before that just a reminder that...in no way it means I think whatever wrong RK did...the heartbreak he gave or the humiliation he dished is right.

I watch the show only as a show...so I will like a char that entertains me...it does not really have to be a saint...or I might like a char to which I can connect to...one who can be as flawed as anyone else. A fictional story always does not have to send across a social message...it can also be just entertainment (doesn't necessarily mean you support everything it shows though). But am not sure how right it is to just generalize that its only coz of the actor's look that ppl like his char. Is it a crime to look beyond the face and like a char for what he is...accepting his flaws too? Accepting that the char is no "epitome of love" but a self centered person? Is it only right to love an "epitome of love"? Can ppl not like a flawed person? Just coz a person made few mistakes or did the most selfish of acts makes him not a "good person"? Who does not makes mistakes or acts selfish? Does that mean everyone is not a good person??...So then no one deserves to be loved at all?? Coz as yet I have never met a single person in reality or seen a char in a show that has not made a single mistake.

Having said that...though the recent things that RK has done are mostly not right but does that erase all the goods that he has done? You say a sorry or apology does not makes things okay...totally agree...they are mere words. Its actions that makes things okay. Agree with you on the point also that certain things cannot be forgiven...but then is there a specific list that comes under it? I think it depends on the individual...like you think what RK did is unforgivable...but thats for you. It can be forgivable for someone else may be Madhu too...someone who has a diff mindset and that would not make that person stupid. Like I think killing a person cannot be forgiven at all...but ppl might think otherwise...like I might not be able to forgive the person who tries to kill me not once but thrice...but RK thought otherwise. Does that make me wrong or RK right..or the other way round? I guess no. Its just different mindset and way how one looks at things and understand the situation and the other person.

"Besides, this show is about Madhubala. Her Ishq and her Junoon. Not About Superstar RK. He is just an aspect to the story. The main focus is Madhubala so we should all be unbiased and think from Madhu's point of view, from a woman's point of view."

I don't think so...the makers themselves have repeatedly said the show is a love story...Rishbala's story...moreover the title says that too...so I would rather go with the show not being just about Madhubala. But anyways, you are free to watch it from Madhubala's POV...as am free to watch from whosoever's POV I would like to watch.

I dnt want just romance but a story too...and am not liking Sultan coz to me it seems a total disconnect to the show as of now plus the char does not interest me a bit. I would rather prefer to watch how Rishbala story moves ahead.

wonderful post yes we drool on rk but at the end of the day he is a abuser to women, if this was real would we put up with the crap that rk gave no.
you post is a execellent

Beautiful post. I am surprised now, many in the forum are coming fwd and making post with such a good analysis on characters. Good to read their POV. I appreciate your patience to come up with every detail. i am sure i cud have never written in such detail.

i don't think RK is abusive. this is a big word. you can use the word abusive for ballu but not rk. RK never did anything against Madhu's will
even the revenge thing she agreed to come with him.
and are you seeing people support RK drools over VD thats why we r taking his side.are u kidding me. i personally hated him that night when he said i did all that for revenge. and nobody is support his actions and even rishbala fans wants RK to repent for whatever he did. the revenge track wants handled well with the cvs. whats it got to do with drooling on the actor?
u said MB is about Madhu story and her ishq&junoon where is the junoon element in Madhu ..the junoon is related to RK. without RK there is no MEIEJ because makers even in a recent interview said its a lovestory and always will be lvoestory of RK and Madhu. so we r wrong becoz we supported RK. what logic is this?
and why are you even bringing actors here when you yourself want to talk about character only.
first of all its a freaking show in reality ppl r not as arrogant as RK and love to play god and r not as stupid and mahaan like madhu. there's difference between being human and being foolish. period.
no offence.