Bashing RK justified ? WHY ?? an analysis - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

99

Views

6k

Users

35

Likes

130

Frequent Posters

670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#81

Originally posted by: Smartangel

I have ans to ur que, u want to know na y people bashing him? Bcoz dey have not any rsn t praise him

u said,he already told that,he will make her life hell,so y bash him. It means agar koi person pehle bol ke bura kaam kare to hum use bura bi nhi bol sakte???

Tm ne kaha ki rk ne koi sympthy nhi maangi thi madhu se,bt he did good things to her n her family only to be in good books of madhu

trp aunties also bash rk,tm cannot explain dem dis analysis to dem

this is only my pov,plus he should be thankful to madhu bcoz of her ,he came close to his mother,


what "bura" kam RK did if he took revenge ?? r u trying to say after getting slapped he should have insisted "slap me more" ?? 😳

n one thing dear whatever RK did for Madhu's family he did NOT do that to be in Madhu's good book . if u remember the epis (if u don't u have option to watch them again from YT/DM) he never announced I did this I did that ! infact he always hid them from Madhu . how was he supposed to enter Madhu's goodbook without letting Madhu know what he did 😕 ?? he did all those bcoz his inner goodness asked him to do so .

n what did he do wrong if he completed the revenge ?? I mean seriously whats his fault ?? both of the couple was playing revenge revenge , but the husband who never touched the wife , rather almost died 3 & 2 times due to his wife's supposed to be n original father respectively is at fault because he had the last laugh in that revenge game ?? seriously ?? 🤣
Opti thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#82

Originally posted by: Saayaniz


See let me first clear one thing . I am not trying to prove RK is a saint . he is obviously not . I am just trying to figure out why he is getting bashed just bcoz he took revenge ?? isn't it that he promised for ? Madhu forgot the basic condition of their marriage slowly but RK didn't . is it the fault ? that he deserves to get bashed so ruthlessly ?

regarding Mukund's accident I won't argue . obviously he was wrong . but didn he try to pay off by bearing expense of his sister's marriage , setting a luxurious retired life for his father and so on ? surely money can't pay off damages everytime . but in Mukund's case it wasn't impossible . but surely am not supporting the fact that he ran over him .
n yes he sent Malik to hospital . but wasn't it Malik himself who tried to attack him ? RK didn send goons to Malik's house to bit him . even when Malik came to set Bittuji tried to stop him coming in but Malik forcefully entered and went to attack RK . So RK's bodyguards took care of him.

n regarding the current track u r right mann ! RK has actually fell in love with Madhu which he himself didn't realise till now . all these started with mere acting but slowly his heart actually accepted her but his brain couldn't n now its gonna be a heart Vs Brain track . I have no problem in it and it wasn't a point of my post too . through my post m just trying to figure out why completing the revenge is being counted so wrong when he was supposed to do that only ??

The point I was making is that he had already fallen in love with her much before he completed his revenge. If he wasn't in love with her and was merely acting, would he have done half the things he did like dreaming of her when she is not around (he clearly remembered that even in his drunk state), going to great lengths to hide the fact that Mallik tried to kill him (at the time he could not known that Dipali will ensure the truth comes to Madhu's knowledge), forcing her to forgive Mallik (by keeping her away from her father he could have ensured she feels isolated after he ditches her but here he was unifying her family and painting himself black at the time of ditching her so that she has her family to support her). That is why it is very difficult to believe he was acting purely on revenge. He must have known that he was falling for the girl. It is another thing that he may have tried doubly hard to act ruthless because he did not want to be vulnerable in love but I find it hard to believe that all along only revenge was his agenda. He fell in love, knew he was in love but still went ahead and broke her heart because he wanted to preserve himself and his big fat ego and arrogance. Now that makes him ruthless. Good he is now burning in the hell of his own making.
Nabakov_Musings thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#83
^^ brilliantly put . so bang on. 👏
Opti thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#84

Originally posted by: Saayaniz


n one thing dear whatever RK did for Madhu's family he did NOT do that to be in Madhu's good book . if u remember the epis (if u don't u have option to watch them again from YT/DM) he never announced I did this I did that ! infact he always hid them from Madhu . how was he supposed to enter Madhu's goodbook without letting Madhu know what he did 😕 ?? he did all those bcoz his inner goodness asked him to do so .

n what did he do wrong if he completed the revenge ?? I mean seriously whats his fault ?? both of the couple was playing revenge revenge , but the husband who never touched the wife , rather almost died 3 & 2 times due to his wife's supposed to be n original father respectively is at fault because he had the last laugh in that revenge game ?? seriously ?? 🤣

Now that is the point I was making. He did a lot of good and tried to hide it from her. A man who cares for no one cared enough to go out of the way to make things right for her and her family and you still believe he was only taking revenge? It is excusable if he did not care for her at all and was purely taking revenge but here he was in love with her and still let his revenge supercede his love.
itsRitzi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#85
😆i cant read such long essays but i too wonder why RK is bashed so much now dnt say he is evil he took revenge then wat the gangster is going to do he too is evil !!
Smartangel thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#86
@tm,don't u think revenge is "bura" kaam????

If he wants revenge,den y not by playing fair game???

U simply asked y bash him,i answered,bt now u ans me,y not bash him???? Just bcoz he took revenge n never tortured her????

Agar vo real hero hota na,to aise revenge ni leta,aise revenge villian karte h,use jhute sapne dikhaye,3 kids etc etc:-|
670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#87
@Opti I am not contradicting u . we all know RK has fallen for Madhu already . he doesn know it , but will know it very soon 😊 his heart has developed feelings for her but his brain is denying this fact . and soon the brain vs heart battle will start n he will realise his love . I agree with it totally 😊 but that wasn't my discussion point .
I saw in many post that ppl r bashing RK just saying "haww !! how could he think about revenge ?" , "how could he not love Madhu?" , "how could he leave her" ...so come bash him n call him by names . I just wanted to clear up this point . obviously RK isn't a saint , neither m trying to prove him one . but how can ppl bash him on the basis of revenge only ! isn't that he promised to do at first ? m just trying to clear up this point .
670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#88

Originally posted by: Smartangel

@tm,don't u think revenge is "bura" kaam????

If he wants revenge,den y not by playing fair game???

U simply asked y bash him,i answered,bt now u ans me,y not bash him???? Just bcoz he took revenge n never tortured her????

Agar vo real hero hota na,to aise revenge ni leta,aise revenge villian karte h,use jhute sapne dikhaye,3 kids etc etc:-|


errmmm...is there any person on earth who won't take revenge if he gets the chance ?? I never knew taking revenge for solid reason is bura kam . so I won't argue anymore 😆 n moreover gal or boy whatever u are ! wasn't he supposed to be a grey character from first ?? then why shouting "why r u grey RK why r u grey" !! isn't it a bit foolish ?? 😆 n yaa.. on ur point "revenge villain karte hai" I just wanna say one thing in many films (like Baazigar ? n many more) we saw the hero suffers a lot bcoz of some ppl n then he takes revenge from them . does it mean they r not hero but villain actually 😳 ?? revenge lena bura nahi hota hai , without any reason kisiko hurt karna bura hota hai .
670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#89

Originally posted by: Opti


<div>

Now that is the point I was making. He did a lot of good and tried to hide it from her. A man who cares for no one cared enough to go out of the way to make things right for her and her family and you still believe he was only taking revenge? It is excusable if he did not care for her at all and was purely taking revenge but here he was in love with her and still let his revenge supercede his love.


r e !! I understand ur point n I agree wid that too 😊 but m not currently discussing that . m just trying to figure out if bashing him bcoz he completed his revenge is right or not .
ornella_mg thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#90
I am sorry to say, but my pov is a little different from yours.

I have no qualms what so ever about RK taking revenge from Madhu, because that is what he set out to do from the very first.
But what I have a problem is the nature in which he took it.
He married her, so as to make her life a hell...I have no problems with that...she knew what she was getting into.
The turning point comes when he saves Malik from jail.
She never asked RK to save her Dad, but he still did it. If Malik was in jail Madhu would have never blamed RK, according to Madhu, her father was guilty of the crime, and she would have burnt in her private hell knowing that her father was the one responslble in the attempt of killing her husband. That would have been a revenge for RK, to make her suffer and break her family.
But no, he frees her father then saves her from his family. My question is, what was the need for him to do that? If he wanted revenge he was getting it served to him on a plate.

But then he decides to play the worst game, the game of hearts. He turned into a cold and calculating person and sucked out the life of the very person whom he promised to love till the very end. And that my girl, I consider the worst crime a person can do to the one whose love you reciprocate.

P.S. Here I am not comparing Sultan's sins with RK. I am just putting my pov as to why I consider RK guilty.



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".