Bashing RK justified ? WHY ?? an analysis

670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Since RK has blasted his bomb that he never loved Madhu , we all became very sad . Thinking about Madhu's powder powder dil we all started to hate RK . How could he break her heart , how could he not love her ? He broke her trust , he doesn deserve to get called a human and so on . Everywhere just I hate RK ! I wanna kill RK etc etc . And now after Sultan's entry things got more complicated here . Now Sultan is in right's throne even after we got to see he is a gangster who kills people mercylessly , even uses his own son as bait against enemy . And RK is all wrong just because he claimed he didn't love Madhu . Who cares legally who is right ? RK is bound to be wrong because he didn't go crazy on Madhu . But my question is WHY ??? No no , am not against Madhu or saying whatever RK did was right . But if we think from RK's POV we can't really blame him just because he took revenge , coz that is what he promised for at beginning . Isn't it ?? I got to read many posts written from Madhu's POV n I don contradict with them . But now I am trying to think from RK's POV and just trying to analyse his actions . Lets see did he really "Backstabbed" Madhu ? Or ...
(I know it came out a bit long . But please kindly read the whole b4 throwing any random comment)

First of all what I remember while marrying Madhu RK never promised "I will love you" or "I will spend a happy married life with you" . Did he ?? NEVER !! He clearly said he is marrying her just to take revenge . He is marrying her to make her life hell . And so did he . He did exactly what he promised to do . At that time Madhu accepted his challange with brave words , but later she forgot for what this marriage was . Well RK didn't forget . Are we really bashing RK because he did not forget what he wanted to do 😳 ??

Now after that studio wala night when Madhu got to know about his father , Madhu tried many time to console him , to shower sympathy on him . But the question is from where did she get the idea that RK needs her sympathy ?? RK did not stand sympathy from his own mother , why is he bound to accept sympathy from his enemy ?? He repeatedly told Madhu "Janwar samjho mujhe" , "Mujhe sympathy nahi chahie" etc etc . But Madhu did not pay attension to his words . She was too much enthusiastic to shower sympathy on him what he clearly declared he does not want . Can we really blame RK because he did not pay attension to this unwanted , unnecessary sympathy ? Even after his clarification ?

Now moving forward towards Ganpati sequence . RK got shot and Madhu donated blood . This is the most hyped theory that RK should fall for her because she gave him blood . Radhaji , Bittuji screamed how could he not love that girl who gave him blood . Sorry , but this theory I really could not digest . What "Mahaan" kaam Madhu did by donating blood ? Even I too donate blood whenever theres a blood donation camp is arranged in our college . So basically all those ppl who used my donated blood in operation should fall in love with me 😲 ??? Errrmm... Really 😳 ?? And moreover RK didn shout from operation table "Madhu give me blood" , "Madhu save me" . It was Madhu who came forward over enthusiastically , otherwise Bittuji was arranging blood from Blood banks . If his blood group could have matched RK's blood , he too had donated blood khushi khushi . Seriously I don think it was manadatory for RK to fall in love with her because she gave him blood . She gave him blood , which again gets reproduced in body within 24 hours . She didn lose her kidney or liver or something else to save RK . And we know RK never asked for that too . So seriously I can't declare him a culprit just because he did not fall in love with the girl who gave him blood .

Now we all know Madhu walked to Siddhi Binayak . But I would like to ask again did RK ever asked her go to Siddhi Binayak for me ?? Nah . He didn't and we know he will never . It was Madhu's enthusiasm again . So why its compulsary for RK to be grateful to his enemy just bcoz she did something which he didn't even ask her to do ?
Now Madhu with full enthusiasm started to do nursing for him . But we know RK didn ask her to take care of him . Infact he forbed her many time "mujhe tumhare sahare ke jarurat nahi hai" . But it was Madhu again who didn't pay attension to his words and showered her over enthusiasm on him which he didn't ask for . Is RK at fault because he did not get impressed by this over enthusiastic nursing which he never demanded ??
Then came a big twist . It was Malik who wanted to kill him . If RK wanted he could have called the cop and insult him brutally in front of whole world . Madhu would have been shattered and he too would not get counted wrong . But he did not . Inface he tried to hid this discovery . He was always fair enough not to drag anyone else to win the battle . Thats why he always stopped Deepali to insult Madhu . Because here too he was fair . Madhu has enemity only with him , not with Deepali . So obviously Deepali don't have the right to insult her . He always maintained this fairity carefully . Whatever he did , he did alone . He never dragged any family member in between . I really praise this quality in him 👏
Now Malik got exposed and RK saved him . He had to . Because he knew whatever Malik did , he did it for Madhu's sake only . He doesn have any personal enemity with RK . So why should RK punish him ? His instict said whatever happened bcoz of Madhu , it should be Madhu who is paying off . So he let Malik go . Madhu and Paddo mistook it as RK is doing this because he doesn want to hurt Madhu . But did RK say that ? It was always RK did not want to hurt anyone else than Madhu because of Madhu . Was RK wrong here ?
Now Madhu went totally lattu on him and kept karwa chauth fast for him . RK couldn't digest the fact at first . But when he realised Madhu has done the mistake to love him it was the trumpcard for him . He never forgot because of Madhu he had to spend 4 nights in Jail . He never forgot Madhu slapped him in front of whole world . He never forgot his mission is to take revenge from Madhu . He has always counted Madhu as his enemy and he actually did not have any reason to consider otherwise . Now his enemy herself showing him the path to destroy her . Any sensible man will not let this golden opportunity to go in vein . So he too did not . He too determined to play along . Yes , he did not care about Madhu's emotion . But was he wrong ? Obviously not . No one cares about their enemy's emotion . So RK too did not . And moreover he too never demanded Madhu to consider his emotions . It was Madhu who wasted her enthusiasm on that , even after knowing RK doesn need her sympathy and all . It was Madhu who harped unnecessarily . RK never asked her to take care of his emotions , so neither he did that about Madhu's emotion . He didn't love that girl , he counted her totally as his enemy everytime . So obviously he couldn miss this chance .
Now he started to play with her . And Madhu too believed him blindly . How easily she forgot what RK promised to do with her while taking those 4 pheras . How easily she forgot what RK told her on the first night of their marriage . And obviously RK used this opportunity very well . Why shouldn't he ? The girl because of whom he had to stand so much humiliation is now want to get destroyed by her own wish . Why should he had spared her ? So he didn't and blasted the bomb at right time that he doesn love her . Why is he wrong ?? Because he didn't forget whats his mission was ? He couldn't forget those 4 nights in jail and those 4 slaps in front of whole world ? What did Madhu do to repair his image that she spoilt so hard ? Just because Madhu showered sympathy on him , donated her blood , did a little nursing in shooting time ...NONE of which he ever asked for , he should have forgotten everything ???? Errmmm...really 😳 ??? Is it so easy ?? Just because he did not forget his mission , just because he did not pay attension to the UNWANTED sympathy , just because he remained sticked to his promises what he did at the time of marriage we should say he is inhuman ? We should hate him ? We should bash him ? Errmmm... Seriously 😳 ?? I think we need to think again .



[NOTE : this post was totally my point of view . Ur POV may differ from mine obviously . But am not open for any arguements . So plz its a request ppl who think their comments may lead to arguements plz refrain from commenting here .]

Created

Last reply

Replies

99

Views

6k

Users

35

Likes

130

Frequent Posters

xxAqeelahxx thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Nice post Sayu👏 Liked your POV , Agree we should not bash rk just because of revenge , although i agree with the fact that he did wrong to madhu by doing revenge but then he always wanted that from the day he married her , i guess we just fell in love with the goody goody rk that we forgot this but this is no reason to bash rk ...
Nabakov_Musings thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
sayu she was in LOVE and she still is. You think feelings ever give a damn about what the head registers inside about revenge enemity etc? she was in love woh khud ki bhi nahi sunti even if she would have kept this in mind..rk did not tell her to do anything but she did cause she fell for him gradually but that is not her mistake..how can your feelings for someone be a mistake? it is not like she wanted to feel this way , it just happened..if only our feelings listened to our neurons. 🤔 You think even after understanding his intentions now she can automatically stop feeling the way does? if only our feelings were switch buttons.
JOHNdaCENA thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
agree with each and every thing.u said.
670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
@Aqui thanx for reading it out 😊
I know we all loved the goody RK 😆 but if u think from first RK always expressed how he wanna make Madhu's life hell , how he wanna make her suffer for next 40 years weren't we stupid to think RK forgot all his promises so easily ?? So when I was trying to analyse his actions till now I found he always kept throwing hints that emotions can't change him . n couldn't really . And if I say honestly I too don support RK much for his deeds ...but I found its unfair to bash him just bcoz he completed his revenge . after all that is what he promised to do .
xxAqeelahxx thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Saayaniz

@Aqui thanx for reading it out 😊
I know we all loved the goody RK 😆 but if u think from first RK always expressed how he wanna make Madhu's life hell , how he wanna make her suffer for next 40 years weren't we stupid to think RK forgot all his promises so easily ?? So when I was trying to analyse his actions till now I found he always kept throwing hints that emotions can't change him . n couldn't really . And if I say honestly I too don support RK much for his deeds ...but I found its unfair to bash him just bcoz he completed his revenge . after all that is what he promised to do .




I guess we were stupid , coz of his expressions we should have realised what he was upto but was to busy watching the cute rishbala romance😊... yes ur post does make sense right from the beginning the time rk wedded her, yes i don't support rk for his wrong deed but bashing nahi honi chaiye as he is a gray shade character ...
Opti thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
I want to ask a few questions. Yes, he was single minded in his revenge and Madhu was his enemy. So who benefitted from his action?
He set out to punish her but he himself is in pain, burning in the hell he has created. Madhu put him in jail but was he innocent? Did he not deserve to be in jail for endagering someone's life? Or is he above law because he is a super star? As to playing a fair game, he never did. If Madhu was his enemy, why did he set about destroying her family the first time around? He ruined Trishna's career. He humliated Padmini in the sets. He let his men bash Mallik up so much he nearly died and later used that to arm twist Madhu into a reluctant half wedding. He knew Madhu's stregnth was her family so he systematically set out to destroy it.
His about-turn after the studio night clearly indicated that his strategy changed because he was not only acting according to his head but also because he was acting according to his heart. Slowly but surely he had fallen for Madhu although it all started with mere acting. So his revenge agenda even after he had fallen in love with his 'enemy' appears to be wrong to many. Anyway he is paying a heavy price for it now.He set out to destroy her and now he himself is getting destroyed. He siad he wanted to spread slow poison of love and now he is getting consumed by that slow poison.
Edited by Opti - 12 years ago
670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
@Koyel thanx for commenting 😊 I agree with you . our emotions can't switch buttons instantly & exactly thats happened with RK too . he counted Madhu as his enemy n so he couldn change his hatred in love so easily . I am not arguing over Madhu should love RK or not . I am not arguing Madhu should have listened to him or not . thats a very delicate question to answer and m not risking any arguements on that . my point is we all r hating RK that how could he take revenge while Madhu loved him . Madhu loved him...okk ! she has a great heart I agree . but how is RK responsible for that ? he repeatedly warned her not to feel for him but she didn listen . I agree whn ppl is in love they don follow any logic . but my question is why are we bashing RK ? because he couldn love that girl whom he counted as his enemy ? or because he didn forget what promises he has done to himself while taking those 4 pheras ? I mean what was RK's fault ???
Monami_50 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Nice post Sayu.Agree with ur POV
Nabakov_Musings thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Opti

I want to ask a few questions. Yes, he was single minded in his revenge and Madhu was his enemy. So who benefitted from his action?

He set out to punish her but he himself is in pain, burning in the hell he has created. AGREED. Madhu put him in jail but was he innocent? Did he not deserve to be in jail for endagering someone's life? Or is he above law because he is a super star? NO HE DIDNT BUT YOU KNOW HOW IT IS IN REALITY..SUPERSTARS DO GET CAUGHT BUT RELEASED EASILY CAUSE THEY ARE SUPERSTARS NAA? As to playing a fair game, he never did. If Madhu was his enemy, why did he set about destroying her family the first time around? HE DID IT IN THE INTENTION TO DESTROY MADHUS LIFE CAUSE MADHU IS SOMEONE WHO DOES NOT CARE ABOUT HERSELF BUT HER LIFE IS HER MOM AND MALLICK AND HE UNDERSTOOD THAT..i mean cummon a girl who fights for a stranger against a superstar , will obviously not care about merself but her world will be her guardians..rk had brains at least to understand that so he shot in the right place for his revenge where it would hurt the most.He ruined Trishna's career. he didn't ruin anything , he used trishnaas ambition on purpose , as if he would launch her much anyway. , in fact so did madhu but rk did it for selfish intentions while madhu did it for selfless intentions. He humliated Padmini in the sets. yes he did do that. but he got a bigger slap back through her reply 😊 He let his men bash Mallik up so much he nearly died and later used that to arm twist Madhu into a reluctant half wedding.Dude he honestly had no idea that his goons made such a state out of mallick . he did not know then what bittoo ji was upto. he got to know later on.he arm twisted but he also helped right? He knew Madhu's stregnth was her family so he systematically set out to destroy it.
His about-turn after the studio night clearly indicated that his strategy changed because he was not only acting according to his head but also because he was acting according to his heart. he wasn't acting and maybe then he himself didnt realize he was not acting but yes his feelings were real even if his intentions were there. Slowly but surely he had fallen for Madhu although it all started with mere acting. So his revenge agenda even after he had fallen in love with his 'enemy' appears to be wrong to many. hmm i agree in fact it is wrong. Anyway he is paying a heavy price for it now. yes he is. He set out to destroy her and now he himself is getting destroyed. true story bro :) He siad he wanted to spread slow poison of love and now he is getting consumed by that slow poison.

@ bold- 👏 perfectly said.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".