Bashing RK justified ? WHY ?? an analysis - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

99

Views

6k

Users

35

Likes

130

Frequent Posters

Opti thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: Saayaniz


r e !! I understand ur point n I agree wid that too 😊 but m not currently discussing that . m just trying to figure out if bashing him bcoz he completed his revenge is right or not .

Looks like you have not understood the point because you are still asking the same question when I've already answered that question. People are bashing him for completing his revenge because taking revenege in itself is bad and more importantly he took that revenge on the girl he fell in love with. If you were paying attention to his speech he gave the chawl wallas. He not only said he took the revenge for the four slaps. He also asked them to warn their children to stay off love because in real life it will only destroy one's life. What he indirectly said here was that he was protecting himself from that love by destroying Madhu's life. It wasn't Madhu's fault that he fell in love with her much like it wasn't RK's fault that Madhu fell in love with him. So why did he have to destroy her to preserve himself? How is that justifiable? As I said if he had himself not fallen in love and had done it purely for revenge, it is at least understanable although it would still not be justifiable. But here he fell in love and effectively punished her for it because he couldn't afford to be seen weak in his love for her.
Edited by Opti - 12 years ago
Angelfan13 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#92
RK has no fault he cleared Madhu he is taking revenge ...it means he is again acting as he said he will ruin her life for next 40 years...till 40 years he will act like this😆revenge will go on
Edited by Angelfan13 - 12 years ago
kahkashansakina thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 14th Anniversary Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 12 years ago
#93
wow bang on post ..
well said each words 🤗👏
Agree with u 200%..

Smartangel thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#94
@tm,u urself said that rk is a grey character,so grey character will get bashed. He took revenge, ok bt this type of revenge!!!!!!!!.thats y people r bashing him. Now u say people r right or not???or u did not bash him bt u cant force ur opinion on people by dis analysis dat he alredy told dat he will make her life hell. Its ur opinion ,not others,

In baazigar, hero k saath bhut bura hota h, bt rk k sath kiya bura hua h?? Rhi baat uski image ki to vo to tabhi bigar gyi thi jab vo jail gya tha, uska badla usne madhu ko badnam karke le liya tha,
611615 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#95

Originally posted by: Rmuk

Agree with each and every point u said. Ur post urged me to comment here now, could not help it lol. Anyways coming to the point, according to my pov i find his action justified to certain extent. I am not saying he had done right or wrong cause that is a very delicate situation to talk about. R.k never said madhu come and fall in love with me. I agree love doesn't happens with one's wish but if u fall in love then u should prepare ur heart to bear the consequences. R.k's action in the beginning clearly stated that he hates madhu, and it is not easy to switch ur feelings from hate to love so easily, if it was then in reality hate couldn't have exsisted only. I am not telling it's madhu's fault that she fell in love coz as i said love never happens according to our wish but It was also not R k's fault if he could not forget his insult whicj madhu did by that 4 slaps infront of the whole world.. It was not his fault that his enemy fell for him. He never told or showed fake sympathy to madhu. Bashing r.k simply says that people wants to say that it is necessary to fall in love with the one who fall's for u which i find totally absurd. Any man with brains could have taken what R.k have done if he wanted revenge, R.k is the man of words and he proved it!!!
His junoon and is Ishq will be something whic we have never ever watched in indian television. I am eagerly waiting to this story to unfold more and more now.
Thank u sayu for this much needed topic.


romi😳 finally u r here in MF 🤗🤗
670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#96

Originally posted by: Opti


<div>

Looks like you have not understood the point because you are still asking the same question when I've already answered that question. People are bashing him for completing his revenge because taking revenege in itself is bad and more importantly he took that revenge on thegirl he fell in love with. If you were paying attention to his speech he gave the chawl wallas. He not only said he took the revenge for the four slaps. He also asked them to warn their children to stay off love because in real life it will only destroy one's life. What he indirectly said here was that he was protecting himself from that love by destroying Madhu's life. It wasn't Madhu's fault that he fell in love with her much like it wasn't RK's fault that Madhu fell in love with him. So why did he have to destroy her to preserve himself? How is that justifiable? As I said if he had himself not fallen in love and had done it purely for revenge, it is at least understanable although it would still not be justifiable. But here he fell in love and effectively punished her for it because he couldn't afford to be seen weak in his love for her.


errmmm... 🤔 m really feeling puzzled 😆 just leave it 😆
n I respect others pov . everyone has different povs n I don want to force my pov on others if it doesn make sense to them 😊 so...lets leave it . I can't change others POV forcefully (I should not even try to) n the same applies with me . so better just leave it 😊
670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#97

Originally posted by: Smartangel

@tm,u urself said that rk is a grey character,so grey character will get bashed. He took revenge, ok bt this type of revenge!!!!!!!!.thats y people r bashing him. Now u say people r right or not???or u did not bash him bt u cant force ur opinion on people by dis analysis dat he alredy told dat he will make her life hell. Its ur opinion ,not others,

In baazigar, hero k saath bhut bura hota h, bt rk k sath kiya bura hua h?? Rhi baat uski image ki to vo to tabhi bigar gyi thi jab vo jail gya tha, uska badla usne madhu ko badnam karke le liya tha,


dear Newbie , according to IF rules u can afford only 10 posts a day . so why r u wasting ur precious posts in my post if u find it this much disgusting ?? I am not putting u in gun point asking to agree with me . I will never . I respect others POV & I never force my one on others . so its a kind rqst to u plz u too don try to do so . I have already declared that its totally my pov n others pov may differ from me . U r free to simply avoid this post n not to comment here 😊
670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#98

Originally posted by: kahkashansakina

wow bang on post ..

well said each words🤗👏
Agree with u 200%..


thanx 😳
601348 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#99

i forgot to comment on this post...its awesome 👏

670134 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Nishi.Singh

i forgot to comment on this post...its awesome 👏


Nishi its u 😲 ! pheww ! thank God its u 😆 when I saw this post was pushed up I was like...firse koi English teacher mujhe English sikhane a gayi kya 😆 ?? but thanx to heaven its u 😃
& thanx for commenting 🤗 !

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".