SEEMA v/s SUPRIYA - Page 2

Originally posted by: Hamlet53

Rosie brilliant post.. your write up alongside others is so extensive and individualistic, that I too endeavour to share my ideas...
So may I then shuttle back and forth between these two woman who feature in Dutta's.
Supriya ,to me has to be a pawn manipulated to perform accordingly to the wishes of Kala and a certain unseen ,unheard ,but felt presence Bade Haste.Although she is a becoming woman both in carriage and appearance.She lacks the strength of character whereby she can say defy Kala's instructions. So she is a marrionette dancing to the whims of others.
Seema comparitively appears more clear in her vision of what she wants,and unlike Supriya follows her own dictates and initiatives.
Supriya is a woman selected for Dutta for matrimonial purposes and as such, has the backing of both families to be united in marriage. People take decisions for her,Kala, her family ,and Dutta's family.
Seema on the other hand is independant in her sense of decision making i.e firstly she reciprocates to the advances of the shy Dutta and later on rejects him for another.When she returns, she again fares alone without a family unit,but is capable enough to conclude that she desires Dutta back in her life.
Seema is a girl that Dutta selects for himself, whereas Supriya stands as a woman arranged for him to be married to.
Supriya happens to be the woman who has Naku's recommendation. For it is Nakusha who chivves her Saab into giving his consent to this proposal.
Supriya I also see as a pertinent topic of discussion bewteen the master and his servant girl.Thus it's her presence which acts further to gel the bond of friendship, support and gradual building of trust,especially in Dutta...between Dutta and Naku.
Now with regards to who out does the other.One thing is clear that they both humilate Dutta.Seema disgraces him in front of his family and friend Baji, and last of all the garage boss. However Supriya lowers his dignity when she disowns him publicly before all guests ,well whishers and family.
There remains little doubt that both women are the cause of emotional truama in Dutta's life but out of the two Supriya emerges as the more dangerous one, for she puts on a semblance before all and is actively party to the secret plot of Dutta's murder, eventually.
Seema thus despite her betrayal of Dutta,and being the cause of his entry into the world of crime , still rises up when compared to Supriya ,due to her final act of saving his life...
xxhammie. thank you for a great post Rosie...

Originally posted by: stranger2rose

Seema v/s Supriya

So from where should I start? Both the ladies ( though I am sure you wouldn't like me to call them ladies)||No, don't call them ladies...androids will do just fine|| had quite a few similarities, firstly their names started with a 's' and ended on an 'a'. secondly they both came in the life of dutta as a whiff of fresh air ||Yeah, fresh air...my foot!|| and with time our hero lost his heart to them only to be broken by them later on, he trusted them, somewhere loved/liked them but they didn't feel the same about him. ||I have to admit that Seema actually fooled me with the first impression. when she was shown bringing in food for him and not making a fuss over the bangles she wanted but he couldn't pay for, I thought that meant she wasn't all about money...but then...|| Thirdly he wished to marry and settle down with both of them but I guess none of them deserved him. Fourthly if seema transformed dutta to dutta bhau by betraying him then supriya's elopement awoke the ruthless gangster in him. Fifthly and most importantly both of them had a pathetic taste, ||😆 Should we even say that they had a sense of taste? Maybe for Sups because she was in love with mawali...so yeah she had a pathetic taste...but Seema? Her taste buds were numb and/or dead. She was so hungry for money she would basically savor the dirt if it carried cash.|| went for that old garage owner and later on for that monkey chaskar ||Aww, Rose, Chasku ko bandar banadiya...I thought Suds had a claim on that title 😛|| then supriya was no less she loved that constipated ||Someone must have had my Suds on her mind while typing this 🤣|| looking man who wore tight fitting shirts'seriously leaving a handsome hunk like dutta for those idiots..amazing

Hi rose

I vote for seema! Thank you for, doing the same, even with a heavy heart else I would have left heartbroken...such a drama queen i tell u ...lol. Now on a serious note, it's hard to choose! You choose, either an earthquake or flood, the result is gonna same''.DISASTROUES! ...well said ...but yes, it can't be ignored that these two ladies sorry witches..correct word used .. are quite similar yet poles apart.

One of the basic differences between seema and supriya is while former was a gold digger, latter never lusted for money, throughout her existence in the show; supriya never seemed ecstatic about all the luxury that entered into her life along with dutta. and i quite admire that quality of sups ...hard to admit

One more aspect..loyalty! Though both were cheats, but yet supriya remained loyal towards that person whom she claimed to be in love with! ..oh god one more positive trait of sups ! aish why are u trying to change my mind ?

Another one seema was CUNNING to cheat a guy madly in love with her, whereas Supriya was dumb to think that she could fool a don (ye alag baat hai ki aapna don got fooled!)

Well in the above stated I kind of praised supriya, (OMG! Bring a doc, there's seriously something wrong! Wait a sec, don't bother to say, "Dr. Suds on his way"..u know u shouldnt make fun of Dr. Suds he's very good at his job😆) what made me pick Seema? The fact that seema lied to the world not to herself! When she cheated dutta, and left him heartbroken, she knew what she did was wrong and even kind of accepted it, she accepted her mistake coz dutta had a gun in his hand and she feared he might kill her..atleast that's what she thought in the flashback scene

What supriya did was, constantly pushed dutta under bad light, since he's a ganster, I didn't told him that I love someone else, arey, no matter to which ever occupation a person belongs to, he/she has full right to know about such grave information about his/her fiance and without having occupation anything to do with it!...aish bacchi darr gayi thi ..but still she should have told him when he himself asked her .. And she better not use that "I was scared" sorry ..i used that word to defend her excuse, yes you were scared that's why you tried to lust a don! ohh very bad sups ..this cannot be accepted ..i refuse to take ur side now .. Wow! You were disgusted with the blood on his hands,..seeing blood shed is not easy aish so doesn't the blood as a result of your fake suicide attempt disgusted you?...sups , ur truly a witch and aish very valid points taken up ..main kya sochti thi aur yeh kya nikali .. Naah! She belongs to that category of people who would live a century of lie, but not a moment of truth!

She encouraged a man to weave dreams of his future around her, and then mercilessly crushed them...Bad very bad, but what's worst? She justified her misdeeds in the name of LOVE! That love which makes human divine. It was love na, which naku believe that dutta is alive, it was love na which incorporated so much courage to a blind DSP that he fought and won single handedly against people mightier than him physically (at that point of time) So when did Love became so cheap that it allowed her to stoop so low for it's sake?👏👏👏

Khaak (soil) ko boot,(idle) aur boot ko devtaa karta hai Ishq

Intehaan toh ye hai Ki bande ko khuda karta hai Ishq !..kya baat hai

Waise, toh I dislike every woman who comes close to dutta..not me atleast 😆, but the above stated is the reason I HATE supriya! I know, not many will agree with me, but still I hope you'll understand😳. Do, I need to say, that it was a wonderful thread,..thanks but ur take on sups was mindblowing ...seriously u changed my perception big time .. yet another wonderful write up from your side, great job!⭐️

N.B. Though, after seema re entered, I felt that was useless, chacha didn't needed seema's recommendation to help dutta, anyways he would be doing that, but still I'm thank ful to her, but I excluded that track while comparing, since I feel that would be unfair on supriya's part, who knows, if given a chance to come back, maybe change could occur to her also!..agreed even i wished the cv's showed what happened to sups later on

@ tahera