Tanya v/s Nandini... The difference? - Page 2

STOP THE KILLING! 😲

My God, are we all turning into homicidal maniacs here? 😕 😕

nice point here im agree im personally nandani's fan n i h8 tanya but it dosnet mean that i say stuff about her i no wt shes done for bhoomi n karan which is good.

oh, finally...at least someone on this forum MAKES SENSE. All others sould like mentally unstable psychopaths...kill him and kill her and all of that nonsense. While I applaud you for making a logical topic, I don't think it's going to help much...Most people on here can't seem to figure out the phenomenon known as "reasoning".

Originally posted by: darkness_123

STOP THE KILLING! 😲

My God, are we all turning into homicidal maniacs here? 😕 😕

I know eh? Everyone is after peoples' lives here! It's like geez...the only way you can be happy is if someone dies? 😕 How frikin pathetic and sad is that..

-Roohani

great topic, i feel sorry for every1 in this triangle

Fabulous post, Nimmi! 👏

I'm on nobody's side...I can understand the point of views of everyone involved -- Karan, Tanya and Nandini.

It's interesting to read opposing opinions and debates about this triangle. Personally I'd want Karan to stay with Tanya, based on principle. If Tanya walks out voluntarily, fine. I really can't imagine Karan kicking her out of SN after spending the last twenty years of his life with her!

Amazing post! 👏

I feel that Karan should stick with Tanya. Even through both women share the same pain, karan has been with Tanya since last 20 years, she has grown his children and has devoted her whole life to them. It would be unfiar to leave tanya now, even if he loves nandini in his heart, tanya is his resposinbility, if not his love.

i just saw yesterdays episode i can imagine people going nuts, i think karan made the right choice by sticking with tanya.

Originally posted by: darkness_123

She's been yearning to live with her family and husband and yet, circumstances force her to live apart, away from them, and watch her daughter look at her with hateful glares and accuse her of being promiscuous and what not...?? Can a woman be blamed for feeling a lil pang to live with her family and her daughter and want to correct her misguided opinion of her??

funny thing is that when i read this, i first thought you were talking about tanya! she yearns to be "with" karan and her children. but for all practical purposes, all these years she hasn't really got what she wanted. until recently, bhoomi kept throwing the fact that she was not her real mom in her face. of course, karan wouldn't even tolerate her putting her head on his shoulder!

so you're right -- nandini's been physically away, but tanya's been kept emotionally away. i think there's a great deal to be said about being physically there - but the emotional gulf is a true blue pain of deep dimensions. they've both suffered in different ways, but they have both suffered.

after having watched the last episode, here's a thought i had about the difference between the love of these two for 🤢 karan: nandini's shown how she can be without karan, even though she is deeply in love with him. tanya says she can be without karan, but she thinks she will die without him. nandini has apparently lived.

i think that might be a difference - but we should really be told what nandini's been upto all these years - 20 years! - that she was away. if it was nothing but waiting and watching, then it was a bloody waste. as much as tanya's last 20 years comes across as a bloody waste of a woman.

why does ganga come across as a very different sort from these two?

Originally posted by: estee

why does ganga come across as a very different sort from these two?

Coz she didn't spend her 20 years mooning over some confused guy, 🤪and made something of herself, instead of feeling sorry for herself...

GANGA ROCKS! *wooot wooot!* 😆