kick out tanya from sn. - Page 6

Originally posted by: aamna2

i don't care who were u talking abt, and i am not komal life, i just couldn't stop replying after ur biased opinion,i'm just sticking up for nands bcoz whatever u said abt her was wrong esp the part when u said that she doesn't even deserve to be called a mother! yeah right frankly speaking i'm fed up of this tanya and nands fight, the story doesn't even revolve around them anymore, it's all the new gen track going on.

The fact that you actually bothered to read my latter post and reply to it shows exactly how much you care. Yes. It was my opinion but of all of the posts in this topic, you found only mine to be biased? If you did, then that's a downright joke. If you are standing up for someone OBVIOUSLY your going to be biased. Your post is biased towards Nandini. And yes I did say Nandini doesn't deserve to be a mother, because she really doesn't. Most of them were *FACTS* I really don't see anything wrong in stating facts with a bit of spice from me. And yes. The fights are irritating but it is solely the Nandini fans that bring them in. This topic was not needed or called for yet some Nandini fans bashed Tanya left, right and center. If you can protect your idol by bashing the other don't expect that the other can't bash your idol. The procavation lies alone with the Nandini fans - Tanya bashers not with Tanya fans. Obviously if useless reasons are thrown, fights are bound to happen.

Originally posted by: complication

yea seriously! i wish they would at least acknowledge that she isn't the she-devil herself, here on earth to destroy their favorite jodi. anyways, great comments again! i hope that we get something original to debate against soon... but i guess i shouldn't hold my breath...

yah totally agree jaysean and complication...some people just need to act more mature..and see whos wrong and see whos right and stop thinking about there FAVORITE JODI😡(h.g) they really shud just put the favorite jodi aside and really start thinking..jus because karan and nandini make a good couple that DOESNT MAKE NANDINI A BETTER MOM😡

yah man i dont like her ither!
she doesnt deserve KARAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!and such a nice familly !she does spoil her son and DAUGHTER a lot!she makes me mad!

Originally posted by: sweetie_rk

The fact that you actually bothered to read my latter post and reply to it shows exactly how much you care. Yes. It was my opinion but of all of the posts in this topic, you found only mine to be biased? If you did, then that's a downright joke. If you are standing up for someone OBVIOUSLY your going to be biased. Your post is biased towards Nandini. And yes I did say Nandini doesn't deserve to be a mother, because she really doesn't. Most of them were *FACTS* I really don't see anything wrong in stating facts with a bit of spice from me. And yes. The fights are irritating but it is solely the Nandini fans that bring them in. This topic was not needed or called for yet some Nandini fans bashed Tanya left, right and center. If you can protect your idol by bashing the other don't expect that the other can't bash your idol. The procavation lies alone with the Nandini fans - Tanya bashers not with Tanya fans. Obviously if useless reasons are thrown, fights are bound to happen.

Nice one sweet rk ..i 1000% agree..

Originally posted by: angel_mimi92

yah man i dont like her ither!
she doesnt deserve KARAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!and such a nice familly !she does spoil her son and DAUGHTER a lot!she makes me mad!

excuse me...plz give a logical answer..😊

Originally posted by: sweetie_rk

LOLZ. Nandini made a sacrifice?! Hahaha😆. She DESERVED what she got! That's what you GET for being a murderer and a threat to the community. On the other hand, she abandoned her daughter when she fancied a stroll in the prison. And that isn't much of a sacrifice, is it?

Tanya was equally as shocked as Karan. She never for a second accept the baby but cared for Bhumi's feelings unlike some random woman who keeps abandoning her, and for once, who wanted to kill her, oh yes she did--Some great momma your Nandini is🤢🤢🤢!!! Don't even start denying it! You can't deny Nandini didn't want to finish off Bhumi before her birth. At least Tanya is a better human than Nandini! She doesn't have the desire to make plans about or murder people every second day!! Anyways, that news about Bhumi being pregnant was a fib so why are you bringing it in?? It justifyies NOTHING you say about Tanya.

Buddy, to begin with - what exact relation does Karan have with Bhumi? He is touted as Bhumi's father while the biological one is Ansh - funny none of those bashing Tanya say Karan's not her real dad and he's the one who actually was lenient with Bhumi, not Tanya!! But I can imagine what the lame excuse is going to be. "OHH. He raised her" and yes he is her father - even though he may have adopted her, but I don't see the need of extra tedious paper work - which means Tanya is her only mother. because SHE RAISED HER! Nandini ,as much as she loves to pretend she's a great mother, hasn't done as much as an ounce for Bhumi as Tanya has. And as far as Bhumi's fib is concerned, lying is a sin, is it? Last I remember the seven sins - referred to as the cardinal sins - are: gluttony, wrath, envy, pride, lust, sloth & greed. Bhumi's actions fall under none. 😛 so from what point are you calling it a sin? And Karan's no god. It doesn't matter if he forgives her or not - he's not god, he can't judge her, he can't forgive her cuz he's not even her biological father! More like a surrogate father - who tried his best to spoil her! Karan deserved to be humiliated in public because it is the result of his lenience with Bhumi. Tanya on the other hand doesn't deserve it. And at least she doesn't create a racket in the hardest of times and make the guilty feel worse about themselves - which is the best thing a mother can do, IMO. And where exactly was momma Nandini then? Partying with darling Aseem? And you call her a good mom! ROTFLMAO!😆😆 A mother who is with her daughter in the toughest of times is a bad mother while a mother who parties while her 'daughter' is having a tough time is a good mother? Some great logic you Nandini fans have!!

Tanya wants Bhumi to marry Abhir but she doesn't have a friken idea about Abhir's reality! GOSH! Where are YOU when the serial is in progress? Are you too biased towards Nandini to even care about getting your facts right about Tanya?? Get your facts right, komal. Tanya is not aware of Abhir's reality and Tulsi mata - who is so conceited that she decides not tell the whole family what she's up to - hasn't bothered to even clarify it for the mother of the one whose life she's just spoilt, badly enough. Given a choice, any mother would prefer Abhir over Joydeep oblivius to the former's reality. Tanya is one of those mothers. She'd rather see her daughter happy than care about the double standard rules of the society she lives in. That is what a TRUE MOTHER does unlike some random woman who keeps crying her eyes out over her so called "daughter" (And believe me, if it was up to me, I'd strip her of every right to call Bhumi her daughter! Actually she's stripped herself of the right by marrying Aseem. So PLEASE don't call Nandini Bhumi's mother because she never was, never has and never will be.)- whom she gloated at. Some great mother Nandini is. It's no wonder that she doesn't have any children with Aseem. Such woman should not - when they can't take care of them, for a start. Or kill people...Tanya IS a better mother than Nandini - who frankly doesn't deserve to be called a mother - not after what she's done, she doesn't.

Nicely put sweetie_srk

Originally posted by: sweetie_rk

LOLZ. Nandini made a sacrifice?! Hahaha😆. She DESERVED what she got! That's what you GET for being a murderer and a threat to the community. On the other hand, she abandoned her daughter when she fancied a stroll in the prison. And that isn't much of a sacrifice, is it?

Nandani did it cos she feared dat gujral wud take her away frm her, which she didn't want i mean she jus got outta a coma nd al of a suddn gujral pops bk into der lifes, which kinda reminds her of Ansh nd she dint wanna be in fear her whole life, i mean always lukin behind her shoulder, u don't hv to agree wid me but to me she had a her reasons for doin it i mean de virani family did try gettin rid of him anoda way, which dint work nd gautam also tried killin him as wel, but nands got to him first, so r u sayin his reasons for tryin to kill gujral were unjustifiable?

Tanya was equally as shocked as Karan. She never for a second accept the baby but cared for Bhumi's feelings unlike some random woman who keeps abandoning her, and for once, who wanted to kill her, oh yes she did--Some great momma your Nandini is🤢🤢🤢!!! Don't even start denying it! You can't deny Nandini didn't want to finish off Bhumi before her birth. At least Tanya is a better human than Nandini! She doesn't have the desire to make plans about or murder people every second day!! Anyways, that news about Bhumi being pregnant was a fib so why are you bringing it in?? It justifyies NOTHING you say about Tanya.

The only reason nandani dint want de baby was because it was also a part of Ansh's put urself in her shoes for a second i mean, god forbid but, if u were raped nd to top dat up u got pregnant how wud u feel, de baby wud b like him always bein der apart of u, which is how sum ppl feel in dat position. For sum ppl dat can b really traumatic, no joke, i mean i'm sure if tanya was in her position she wud hv reacted de same at first.

Although wat tanya did was nice, takin care of bhoomi nd al, growin up widout a mother can also hv a bad effect on a kid but thanx to tanya bhoomi neva missd out, which is y i like tanya as wel as nandani.

Buddy, to begin with - what exact relation does Karan have with Bhumi? He is touted as Bhumi's father while the biological one is Ansh - funny none of those bashing Tanya say Karan's not her real dad and he's the one who actually was lenient with Bhumi, not Tanya!! But I can imagine what the lame excuse is going to be. "OHH. He raised her" and yes he is her father - even though he may have adopted her, but I don't see the need of extra tedious paper work - which means Tanya is her only mother. because SHE RAISED HER!

I think dat tanya nd karan r both at fault in de way bhoomi has turned out, karan cos he flashes money at her nd makes sure she gets nythin she wants nd tanya does de same, i know dey luv bhoomi nd al but dey dint show bhoomi as wel as manthan de true value of relationships, as dey r not only based on class as in rich or poor.

Nandini ,as much as she loves to pretend she's a great mother, hasn't done as much as an ounce for Bhumi as Tanya has. And as far as Bhumi's fib is concerned, lying is a sin, is it? Last I remember the seven sins - referred to as the cardinal sins - are: gluttony, wrath, envy, pride, lust, sloth & greed. Bhumi's actions fall under none. 😛 so from what point are you calling it a sin? And Karan's no god. It doesn't matter if he forgives her or not - he's not god, he can't judge her, he can't forgive her cuz he's not even her biological father! More like a surrogate father - who tried his best to spoil her! Karan deserved to be humiliated in public because it is the result of his lenience with Bhumi. Tanya on the other hand doesn't deserve it. And at least she doesn't create a racket in the hardest of times and make the guilty feel worse about themselves - which is the best thing a mother can do, IMO. And where exactly was momma Nandini then? Partying with darling Aseem? And you call her a good mom! ROTFLMAO!😆😆 A mother who is with her daughter in the toughest of times is a bad mother while a mother who parties while her 'daughter' is having a tough time is a good mother? Some great logic you Nandini fans have!!

Karan was right in slappin bhoomi, cos wat she did was wrong i mean she lied to her father bout doin sumthin behind his bk, yeah it shudn't always b bout virani parivaar izzat nd all but stil wat wud ur dad say if u did sumthin like dat, (not dat i'm sayin u wud) giv u a pat on de shoulder nd say no worry's u'll get ur way again i'll get u married to abhir, but i guess tanya was a bit right in givin her support as her mother cos if u turn ur bak on ur kids den dat jus pushes dem further away nd makes dem do sumthin evn more stupid.

In real sense i do thin dat karan nd tanya r bhoomi's parents cos dey brought her up out of der own accord, blood mayb thicker dan water but luv is wat al relations r based on.

Tanya wants Bhumi to marry Abhir but she doesn't have a friken idea about Abhir's reality! GOSH! Where are YOU when the serial is in progress? Are you too biased towards Nandini to even care about getting your facts right about Tanya?? Get your facts right, komal. Tanya is not aware of Abhir's reality and Tulsi mata - who is so conceited that she decides not tell the whole family what she's up to - hasn't bothered to even clarify it for the mother of the one whose life she's just spoilt, badly enough. Given a choice, any mother would prefer Abhir over Joydeep oblivius to the former's reality. Tanya is one of those mothers. She'd rather see her daughter happy than care about the double standard rules of the society she lives in. That is what a TRUE MOTHER does unlike some random woman who keeps crying her eyes out over her so called "daughter" (And believe me, if it was up to me, I'd strip her of every right to call Bhumi her daughter! Actually she's stripped herself of the right by marrying Aseem. So PLEASE don't call Nandini Bhumi's mother because she never was, never has and never will be.)- whom she gloated at.

Wat tulsi did was reasonable in her senses but wat can u do, ekta likes to keep every1 frm tellin nythin once dey find out de truth to drag de serial a bit longer. Ok tanya neva knew de truth bout abhir, but he walkd out on her daughter on de weddin day! wud u stil go to abhir's house nd beg him to marry ur pregnant daughter, cum on she's got sum respect as wel as bhoomi, joydeep thing is a different story in a way i think it was right, as joydeep was tryin to help save the viraani parivaar's izzat nd bhoomi her dad's izzat, but wrong cos der izzat went down de drain nyway as in wat happnd on de weddin day, but stil ppl wud stil keepin talkin in who wud marry a pregnant girl

Some great mother Nandini is. It's no wonder that she doesn't have any children with Aseem. Such woman should not - when they can't take care of them, for a start. Or kill people...Tanya IS a better mother than Nandini - who frankly doesn't deserve to be called a mother - not after what she's done, she doesn't.

I say nandani must hv had her reasons for leavin which i think stil r unknown so i can't say nythin bout dat, i stil think ders sumthin more to it, but i'm sure dey were gud enough in her sense, nd tanya is a gud mother as wel as a gud friend, cos she brought bhoomi up as she dint want nandani to say she dint luk afta her wel or neglected her in nyway cos dey weren't blood related nd tanya was also ready to giv her nd her husband up to nandani wen she found out dat she returned.

She neva stoppd bhoomi frm meetin nandani, but bhoomi respectd tanya for everythin she did for her as wel nd considered her as her mom as wel, showin dat karan nd tanya's upbringin wasn't al bad cos she atleast respectd tanya who wasn't her real mother.

So i think dat both nandani nd bhoomi both hv de right to be calld bhoomi's mothers which is jus my opinion, cos dey did alot of things for her out of motherly luv nd i know every1 mite not agree nd i'm not forcin u too jus wantd to say wat i thought not argue or nythin. By de way i'v only really read sweetie_rk's post, which is de one i'm replyin to so i don't know wat oda comments hv been said, hope u don't think i'm bashin ur post in ny ways.

At the end of the day hard core tanya and nandani fans u'll b goin in circles u shud jus agree to disagree i mean dey r really fictitous characters written by de one nd only ekta.

Originally posted by: dlfc

i also want her out of sn 😡
i personally like rakshanda but certainly not tanya

agreed
Tanya is getting on my nervesssss😡

Devki gave birth to Krishna but Yahsoda maa brought him up and his upbringing was flawless. Yes he was naughty and did mischief as a child but in the end he was good.

Mandira gave birth to Karan and gave him bad upbringing but Tulsi's love made him a good human being.

Gujral gave Ansh bad upbringing and even Tulsi's love could not change him, in the end Tulsi had to kill him to save Nandhani's life.

In the same way Nandhani killed Gujral to save Bhoomi's life, Bhoomi who was Ansh daughter, the same daughter who is the result of a rape. Imagine telling your child that - that he/she is the result of a rape and that his/her father was killed while trying to kill his/her mother. Would you want to bring that kind of child into the world?

Ekalaya is also Ansh's child he and Bhoomi both have Ansh'a blood but Damini's upbring has made him a good human being.

I agree it is both Karan and Tanya's fault in spoiling Bhoomi but a major responsibility of upbringing resides with the mother as she is at home with the children. Tanya and Karan both in their guilt over not being Bhoomi's birth parents spoiled her completely, they neither respect elders, culture or relatives.

About Bhoomi lying about her being pregnant - noone in the family knows its a lie. No mother will hug her daughter if she tells her she is pregnant, any decent human being would die of shame, esp when the announcement is made in a party and then printed on the front page of the newspaper. Its not anything to be proud of the way Tanya is proud of Bhoomi.

Tulsi is Bhoomi's grandmother and loves her, Tanya keeps blaming Tulsi unnecessarily. I agree that Tulsi did not tell Tanya the truth but in all the time that Tanya lived in SN does she not know that Tulsi maa never does anything wrong. Why does only Sahil have to keep supporting Tulsi? When all her daughters in law whom she always supported keep blaming her now? Tulsi forced Karan to marry Tanya and alsways fought for Tanya's rights and now Tanya forget everything and Tulsi is her daughters enemy and does not want her to be happy?

Besides as per the Hindu Marriage Act and the Indian Constitution a man can have only one wife, only his first wife is considered his legal wife. All other marriages are considered illegal and the woman have no status or rights, even the children are considered illegitimate and cannot fight to inheiret any property, so legally Nandahi is still Karan's wife and Tanya is just the other woman.

At least Sahil divorced Ganga and married Tripti so that makes her Sahil's legal wife but Tanya she has no status and no dignity, she is just the other woman.

Originally posted by: ann_belle

Devki gave birth to Krishna but Yahsoda maa brought him up and his upbringing was flawless. Yes he was naughty and did mischief as a child but in the end he was good.

Mandira gave birth to Karan and gave him bad upbringing but Tulsi's love made him a good human being.

Gujral gave Ansh bad upbringing and even Tulsi's love could not change him, in the end Tulsi had to kill him to save Nandhani's life.

In the same way Nandhani killed Gujral to save Bhoomi's life, Bhoomi who was Ansh daughter, the same daughter who is the result of a rape. Imagine telling your child that - that he/she is the result of a rape and that his/her father was killed while trying to kill his/her mother. Would you want to bring that kind of child into the world?

Ekalaya is also Ansh's child he and Bhoomi both have Ansh'a blood but Damini's upbring has made him a good human being.

I agree it is both Karan and Tanya's fault in spoiling Bhoomi but a major responsibility of upbringing resides with the mother as she is at home with the children. Tanya and Karan both in their guilt over not being Bhoomi's birth parents spoiled her completely, they neither respect elders, culture or relatives.

About Bhoomi lying about her being pregnant - noone in the family knows its a lie. No mother will hug her daughter if she tells her she is pregnant, any decent human being would die of shame, esp when the announcement is made in a party and then printed on the front page of the newspaper. Its not anything to be proud of the way Tanya is proud of Bhoomi.

Well what exactly is it that you want Tanya to do? Jump of a bridge because her daughters pregnant?? Beat her down? She knows that Bhoomi's made a mistake and shes acknowledged it .. the best thing to do is to get her married to the father which Tanya tried to do.. not knowing that he's out to get revenge ..

Tulsi is Bhoomi's grandmother and loves her, Tanya keeps blaming Tulsi unnecessarily. I agree that Tulsi did not tell Tanya the truth but in all the time that Tanya lived in SN does she not know that Tulsi maa never does anything wrong. Why does only Sahil have to keep supporting Tulsi? When all her daughters in law whom she always supported keep blaming her now? Tulsi forced Karan to marry Tanya and alsways fought for Tanya's rights and now Tanya forget everything and Tulsi is her daughters enemy and does not want her to be happy?

Besides as per the Hindu Marriage Act and the Indian Constitution a man can have only one wife, only his first wife is considered his legal wife. All other marriages are considered illegal and the woman have no status or rights, even the children are considered illegitimate and cannot fight to inheiret any property, so legally Nandahi is still Karan's wife and Tanya is just the other woman.

At least Sahil divorced Ganga and married Tripti so that makes her Sahil's legal wife but Tanya she has no status and no dignity, she is just the other woman.

Other than that "dying of shame" part that you mentioned ..your points are well written