kick out tanya from sn. - Page 5

lol hahaha...yah i guess theyll never get sik of it..hahaha. 😆

Originally posted by: komal_life

and girls or guys plz act mature , we have no fun in blaming or accusing any character but if soe 1 is wrong only then we do .

really, you don't? seems like it to me because all you keep saying is that tanya is a horrible person and i'm sorry, but your reasoning for doing so is very bias!

Originally posted by: komal_life

yes im blaming tanya because she is at fault!!!!!anyways if u dont find any snce in this debate u can lave plz . as for tanya she is the worst mother for sure , when a kid goes wrong u should give him/her a tight slap obviously good karan has slapped manthan on and off esp when he didi batamzii with baa but tanya? she has literally spoiled the kids rotten ! QUOTE=complication]

omg, i can't believe komal_life is justifying bhoomi being a brat but blaming manthan's attitude on tanya's inability to give him proper sanskars! what kind of biased, illogical argument is that? whatever, i'll continue with the debate when the person i'm debating with actually makes some sense! but jaysean, keep it up! glad to know someone someone around here is logical!

kajal

oh, you're just making me wanna stay! thanks for that!

if your nandini is so right and if she cares about her kid so much, than she should have put everything else aside and given her some sanskars herself. she could have been apart of bhoomi's life and still put her foot down in front of karan and told him she wasn't willing to be apart of her life. however, she didn't, she left and has never done anything motherly for her daughter and hence she isn't bhoomi's mother.

and karan's slapping manthan all the time is what has made him rebel. since you seem to be all for karan slapping manthan, why don't ou go ask him to give bhoomi a couple because she aint no angel herself!

Originally posted by: Jaysean

thanks a lot for the compliment dear😉i know...i think they cant get enough of this😆😆thats why they make 100000000000000000000000000 posts blaming tanya and how much they hate her and stuff.....they never get sick of this i guess

yea seriously! i wish they would at least acknowledge that she isn't the she-devil herself, here on earth to destroy their favorite jodi. anyways, great comments again! i hope that we get something original to debate against soon... but i guess i shouldn't hold my breath...

Originally posted by: komal_life

nandini left every thing for tanya every thing her home her love/ husband and her daughter because nandini is not selfish when tusi told her not o blame tanya she actaully left every thing happily for her and till date she is alone and crying and itching to be with her husband and kid but for tanya she is acting as if she cares two hoots for them

nandini never l;eft her kid just like tht its all done fr tanya amma, and unfortunately nandini is wrong she should have never tht of being o nice for this women !

and kaan slappng manthan wouldnot make hima rebel because he has enug money but when ever he dos an batemezeei only then karan s;laps him because tanya will never do tht in past 20 yrs allshe did was how to get the bst jewellery and cry !

sorry but if she would have given 1 perecnt of sanskars thes ekds would not have ben devil !

oh, you're just making me wanna stay! thanks for that!

if your nandini is so right and if she cares about her kid so much, than she should have put everything else aside and given her some sanskars herself. she could have been apart of bhoomi's life and still put her foot down in front of karan and told him she wasn't willing to be apart of her life. however, she didn't, she left and has never done anything motherly for her daughter and hence she isn't bhoomi's mother.

and karan's slapping manthan all the time is what has made him rebel. since you seem to be all for karan slapping manthan, why don't ou go ask him to give bhoomi a couple because she aint no angel herself!

right, she left everything, she made that decision so now she has no right over anything. she's a good friend, she's willing to sacrifice her love for her friend's sake, but that's what makes her a bad mother. she left her kid, PERIOD, and a real mother wouldn't do that for any reason.

you're a girl right? then why are you blaming everything on the mother? hurting a child physically can make him rebel because there comes a day when the child is big and strong enough to hit back, and that only happens when the parent has only hurt the child and has never given him love. that is exactly what karan has done. he always shows up to punish manthan when he's wrong, but other than that, manthan doesn't even exist to him. and till the abhir fiasco, he's never thought bhoomi could ever be wrong, even though she's always been manthan's sidekick/savior in all his wrongdoings.

also, you keep saying that tanya should have slapped her kids for acting out when they first started. well, i'm sure she's tried and as a result, learned not to because could you imagine how psycho karan would have gone if he heard someone laid a hand on his angel child? he wouldn't allow anyone to punish bhoomi and that's what spoiled her. also, she does reprehend and reprimand manthan time and again. plus tanya's the one parent that he doesn't hate because she's actually been there for him. karan's lack of love is what is slowly turning manthan's heart to stone, not tanya's inability to raise children.

Tanya knew Karan and Nadhani were in love still she helped Ansh break them up.

She did not become good because she realized Ansh was bad, when Karan found out Ansh was bad, she joined him as by then she fell in lvoe with him and wanted to be close to him.

She became there friend so she could always be close to them, instead of going away and leaving them alone.

When Nandhani went into comma she agreed to marry Karan even knowing he was not interested in marrying her and was being forced by the family. There are so many women in Shantiniketan anyone could have taken care of Bhoomi. Ganga took care of Damini's kids and vicecersa. Instead she happily married Karan knowing when Nandini wakes up she will be hurt.

After Nandani came out of comma, she left but kept meeting Bhoomi, who told Karan and Karan found her. Then she kept meeting Karan, till Nandani found out about them.

Nandani went to jail for 14 years to save Bhoomi from Gujral, she proved that even though she did not bring Bhoomi up she still loves her.

After coming out of jail she stayed away from Karan and Tanya because she wanted them to be happy. Karan went looking for her and found her, but she broker him heart and did not come back.

Tanya stayed in SN for 20 years and failed as a wife, as a mother and now as a daughter in law. She could not give good up bringing to her childrem. Trupti gave good upbringing to Nakul and Laksya though they are not her own children. Mohini and Damini gave good upbringing to their children only Tanya could not becuase she was too busy feeling sorry for herself.

Then when her daughter in a unwed mother instead of gettign upset with her, she calls Abhir up to talk to him!!! What kind of mother is that?

She knows Tulsi maa is always right for the last so many years she does good only and today becuase Tulsi maa told Karan about Joydeep so that her own daughters respect is saved she says she won't forgive her. Why? because she saved Karan and the family's respect when Abhir was run away.

But you all are right the fault is Nandhani's, she did not take a break from her comma jail to come and give good upbring to her child. Also after comming out of jail she did not come and break Karan and Tanya's marriage to look after Bhoomi.

The fault is also Tulsi maa's she should have let Bhoomi marry Abhir and the whole family to be destroyed that Tanya would be happy.

Tanya is the best, becuase she has no self-respect or dignity.

Today's woman has self respect, she has dignity and she will not be a cry baby doormat but will take control of her life and either improve the situation or leave it. Like Nandani has done, she left Karan so that her friend who lived with him for so many years can be happily married. She came in hiding to her own daughter marriage so her friend who looked after her daughter for so many years can do her Kanyadan. She is today's woman, strong, decision making and selfless.

Originally posted by: komal_life

WQell there are only handful of people who an make such big sacrifices like wht nandini did .

abt the kids obviosuly karan is wrong in spoling bhoomi but he did slap her tight when he hrd she is pergnanat whiel tanay went hushing her no baby u got pregnant dosnt mater ? my foot!!!!!

atleast karn had guts to say he has broen ties with tht bhomi because she did a sin but tanay went on husing her her why?
sorry to says ome times its hows as if tanya wants to prove bhomi tht im a bterr mo thn nandini . and now finally when every 1 knws wht abir did stiltanya wanted bhoomi to marry him bravo !

jai ho tanya mom ki

LOLZ. Nandini made a sacrifice?! Hahaha😆. She DESERVED what she got! That's what you GET for being a murderer and a threat to the community. On the other hand, she abandoned her daughter when she fancied a stroll in the prison. And that isn't much of a sacrifice, is it?

Tanya was equally as shocked as Karan. She never for a second accept the baby but cared for Bhumi's feelings unlike some random woman who keeps abandoning her, and for once, who wanted to kill her, oh yes she did--Some great momma your Nandini is🤢🤢🤢!!! Don't even start denying it! You can't deny Nandini didn't want to finish off Bhumi before her birth. At least Tanya is a better human than Nandini! She doesn't have the desire to make plans about or murder people every second day!! Anyways, that news about Bhumi being pregnant was a fib so why are you bringing it in?? It justifyies NOTHING you say about Tanya.

Buddy, to begin with - what exact relation does Karan have with Bhumi? He is touted as Bhumi's father while the biological one is Ansh - funny none of those bashing Tanya say Karan's not her real dad and he's the one who actually was lenient with Bhumi, not Tanya!! But I can imagine what the lame excuse is going to be. "OHH. He raised her" and yes he is her father - even though he may have adopted her, but I don't see the need of extra tedious paper work - which means Tanya is her only mother. because SHE RAISED HER! Nandini ,as much as she loves to pretend she's a great mother, hasn't done as much as an ounce for Bhumi as Tanya has. And as far as Bhumi's fib is concerned, lying is a sin, is it? Last I remember the seven sins - referred to as the cardinal sins - are: gluttony, wrath, envy, pride, lust, sloth & greed. Bhumi's actions fall under none. 😛 so from what point are you calling it a sin? And Karan's no god. It doesn't matter if he forgives her or not - he's not god, he can't judge her, he can't forgive her cuz he's not even her biological father! More like a surrogate father - who tried his best to spoil her! Karan deserved to be humiliated in public because it is the result of his lenience with Bhumi. Tanya on the other hand doesn't deserve it. And at least she doesn't create a racket in the hardest of times and make the guilty feel worse about themselves - which is the best thing a mother can do, IMO. And where exactly was momma Nandini then? Partying with darling Aseem? And you call her a good mom! ROTFLMAO!😆😆 A mother who is with her daughter in the toughest of times is a bad mother while a mother who parties while her 'daughter' is having a tough time is a good mother? Some great logic you Nandini fans have!!

Tanya wants Bhumi to marry Abhir but she doesn't have a friken idea about Abhir's reality! GOSH! Where are YOU when the serial is in progress? Are you too biased towards Nandini to even care about getting your facts right about Tanya?? Get your facts right, komal. Tanya is not aware of Abhir's reality and Tulsi mata - who is so conceited that she decides not tell the whole family what she's up to - hasn't bothered to even clarify it for the mother of the one whose life she's just spoilt, badly enough. Given a choice, any mother would prefer Abhir over Joydeep oblivius to the former's reality. Tanya is one of those mothers. She'd rather see her daughter happy than care about the double standard rules of the society she lives in. That is what a TRUE MOTHER does unlike some random woman who keeps crying her eyes out over her so called "daughter" (And believe me, if it was up to me, I'd strip her of every right to call Bhumi her daughter! Actually she's stripped herself of the right by marrying Aseem. So PLEASE don't call Nandini Bhumi's mother because she never was, never has and never will be.)- whom she gloated at. Some great mother Nandini is. It's no wonder that she doesn't have any children with Aseem. Such woman should not - when they can't take care of them, for a start. Or kill people...Tanya IS a better mother than Nandini - who frankly doesn't deserve to be called a mother - not after what she's done, she doesn't.

what the hell are u talking abt sweetie rk? yes nands is a murderer but eho did she came a murderer for her daughter bhoomidaughter bhoomi
by the it was tanya who herself said to nands that she should abort bhoomi at that time nands didn't wanted to do it, and who would like to give birth to a child who was rape born!just becasue tanya stayed with bhoomi for 3o yrs she deserves to be called a mother so in that case tripti also stayed in sn for 20 yr, even if she is bad, she is the one who raised nakul and lakshya, so doe sthat mean ganga doesn't deserve to be called a mother.
nands was dancing with aseem bcoz she doesn't want to come bwtween karan-tanya so she put up this false act, the evidence for this si when bhoomi's wedding was happening nands said to bhoomi that she couldn't coem bcoz she was going to a party with aseem but if u see the epi she was at home cruying with her pic, she weren't out there mingling with aseem in parties.

ha ha 😆 😆 tanya doesn't cry her eyes out and nands does, the biggest joke of the century,i think there hasn't been a single epi after leap or even pre leap that ands hasn't cried.
does tanya has the guts to say bad things to tulis infront of karan, no instead she starts talking behind his back so she doesn't get shouted.
tanya thinks that she is the only one who cares or that bhoomi, even tulsi loves bhoomi, if u can't remember refresh ur memory before the leap, there was a bond between the two but bcoz of tanya and karan's bad upbringing bhhomi and manthan both turned out to be like goons like she is. 😡
i agree tulsi should have told the truth to only karan but she owuld have trusted her unlike tanya who would have in reply said that tulsi can't see bhoomi's happiness that's why she doesn't want them to reunite.
we clearly know what type of mother tanya is when bhoomi said that she was preggy, what did she do, nothing except crying, if there was another mother in her face she would have slapped her!
before tulsi came to sn damini was the only one who tried to have peace, she always tried to stop fights between saahil and karan but tanya on the other hand instigated karan and manthan, whenevr tripti said something to her she went out like a cry baby and complained to manthan, she knew that this will cause fights but as if she bothered.
tanya loves bhoomi i know, but u can't also deny the damn fact nands loves bhoomi, no less, she proved that she was her biological mother when she had killed gujral 4 her, i can still remember tanya said to nands that"ik maa chahe woh apne bacche ke liye kuch bhi kar sakti hai, kisika hoon bhi" tanya only said that like she was really gonna do it(whatever) nands was the only who actually did it. and now don't say that tanya was preggy at taht time that's why she didn't kill gujral , nads was also preggy but ddi she care!
for me nands will always be bhoomi's mother no matter what, she sacrificed 14 yrs of her life what more prove i needed that she loves bhoomo to bits

^Was I even talking to you? 😛 LOL. My post was directed to komal_life, not you. so unless you have multiple ids and you are komal_life, it's rather better not to say anything to me because I will be snide, you can vouch that.

i don't care who were u talking abt, and i am not komal life, i just couldn't stop replying after ur biased opinion,i'm just sticking up for nands bcoz whatever u said abt her was wrong esp the part when u said that she doesn't even deserve to be called a mother! yeah right frankly speaking i'm fed up of this tanya and nands fight, the story doesn't even revolve around them anymore, it's all the new gen track going on.