Kumkum Bhagya New Season | Episode Discussions Thread 4 - Page 17

Originally posted by: TintedBlossom

This assumption of urs actually has a strong chance of being true…

I’ve seen something very similar happen in another Ekta show. The ML and FL confess their feelings and then the FL spots the ML’s ex fiancee.. who was also his mother’s chosen one.. with her boyfriend, both were scheming to take over ML's business & destroy him.. She informs both ML and his mother but the mother accuses her instead, of several things and the ML stays silent, says he too doesn't believe her. He even pretends to go ahead with marrying the ex.

But then, on the mandap, he exposes the ex and her bf in front of everyone with a well made plan, confesses his love for the FL publicly, stops her from leaving the house, and they end up consummating that night, so..

I have something similar in a Ekta Show and a non Ekta show.

Originally posted by: monsoon_barsha

Was it just me or did he look disappointed at BM's reaction to his divorce announcement?

He did look disappointed at that . He expected her to be different but it’s needed for him to see his BM may have raised him but she may be reason why he never was close to his mother.

Maybe BM separated Shivansh’s parents same way as she is trying to separate PraShiv . Shivansh dad did not believe Smitha and he got divorced and when he learned the truth Smitha refused to return because he could not trust him. And BM and family did not allow Smitha to take Shivansh . Radhawas got his custody and he was brainwashed to believe his mom left for money so married somebody else. Smitha may have been pregnant during divorce time and she might not wanted to loose Sneha so she did not go back to get Shivansh.

I have seen this in few shows .

Originally posted by: asmitamohanty

You know... when you watch today 's episode...they have kept Shivansh really mysterious and stoic....

Like they are focusing on Prarthana 's heartbreak,her pain...how she is having flashbacks and not being able to believe that Shivansh could ask for divorce....,but they didn't show his side of reaction..

The moment he asked for divorce and he saw prarthana 's tears...he left right at that moment...as if scared that he would spill the beans regarding something if he stays here for more time as her tears are making him weak..

Something might have happened after the confession that Prarthana is unaware of

Definitely but what exactly is what we don't know that man is going to keep us in the dark for long as he can before we know the reason behind this is justify or dumb

To me the epidode was really satisfying but i must say something was just out of place . Why is Sonalika so happy , have she suddenly forgotten her big words about hurting shiv and wanting him to beg her ?" I felt like slapping that joy of their faces ,(BM and gang )

I really really loved prat confession, it wasn't grand but it had depth , so touching .. Shivansh you had better not let Dora cry for too long . Sort out everything soon

Urɠh for the first time I disliked BM 😡, why is she so blinded by that Sonalika .

I'm glad Prathna's confession of love was just a dream. I want her to make Mr. S work hard to hear in real what she said in that dream and that moment needs to be intense. I feel Shivaansh has not earned that yet. I still can not forgive him for standing and not saying anything when Sonalika pushed Prathna and kept insullting her.

As cute as the button scene was, I felt a bit disappointed that it was only a flashback. It could have been used during the divorce track instead. Imagine Shiv staring at her and Prathna cries in pain. Shiv shows concern, and Prathna asks him, “Why does it bother you if you want me out of this marriage?”. ". Do you only care about physical pain?Where was this concern when you told me to move out of the room and let your gf in"

I'm not sure if this whole divorce track is part of some plan. Maybe Shiv is doing it out of what he thinks is love, letting Prathna "free" for her "own good" as he genuinely believes that Prathna will be happier without tied to him in this revenge marriage and is trying to set her free.

Also, I’ve been thinking; what if Raunak is Shiv’s real brother? Maybe Smita finally confronts Shiv: "You’ve become just like your dad, making decisions for everyone but never listening to the truth. “Perhaps Kranti was only Smita’s business partner and his dads best friend, but Shiv’s dad accused her of having an affair. BM might’ve played a major role in fuelling that accusation and manipulated the situation. When Smita found out she was pregnant a second time, Shiv’s dad refused to accept her and told her to leave the house and Shiv with a condition so harsh that she had no choice but to walk away and never lookback.

Maybe Smita will lash out BM for repeating what she did years ago, inflicting Shiv pain one more time.

Originally posted by: Nikvi29

He did look disappointed at that . He expected her to be different but it’s needed for him to see his BM may have raised him but she may be reason why he never was close to his mother.

Maybe BM separated Shivansh’s parents same way as she is trying to separate PraShiv . Shivansh dad did not believe Smitha and he got divorced and when he learned the truth Smitha refused to return because he could not trust him. And BM and family did not allow Smitha to take Shivansh . Radhawas got his custody and he was brainwashed to believe his mom left for money so married somebody else. Smitha may have been pregnant during divorce time and she might not wanted to loose Sneha so she did not go back to get Shivansh.

I have seen this in few shows .

BM I don’t know the name of her character.., definitely has a role in Smita’s disappearance from his life ..

But why would Smita not recognise his name as shivansh Randhawa, that means his name and surname got changed sometime

If his dad’s name was Randhawa , Smita should have connected the man .. is she suffering from Alzheimer’s , or atleast partial amnesia that she could not recollect her son’s name is Shivansh Randhawa

Ekta can pull off wierd plots which is becoming true these days

Shivansh wanting to get divorce Prarthna after getting close ( maybe not doing the deed) but hugging her tightly is wierd ..

I hope they haven’t done it

Originally posted by: AvantikaP

I'm glad Prathna's confession of love was just a dream. I want her to make Mr. S work hard to hear in real what she said in that dream and that moment needs to be intense. I feel Shivaansh has not earned that yet. I still can not forgive him for standing and not saying anything when Sonalika pushed Prathna and kept insullting her.

As cute as the button scene was, I felt a bit disappointed that it was only a flashback. It could have been used during the divorce track instead. Imagine Shiv staring at her and Prathna cries in pain. Shiv shows concern, and Prathna asks him, “Why does it bother you if you want me out of this marriage?”. ". Do you only care about physical pain?Where was this concern when you told me to move out of the room and let your gf in"

I'm not sure if this whole divorce track is part of some plan. Maybe Shiv is doing it out of what he thinks is love, letting Prathna "free" for her "own good" as he genuinely believes that Prathna will be happier without tied to him in this revenge marriage and is trying to set her free.

Also, I’ve been thinking; what if Raunak is Shiv’s real brother? Maybe Smita finally confronts Shiv: "You’ve become just like your dad, making decisions for everyone but never listening to the truth. “Perhaps Kranti was only Smita’s business partner and his dads best friend, but Shiv’s dad accused her of having an affair. BM might’ve played a major role in fuelling that accusation and manipulated the situation. When Smita found out she was pregnant a second time, Shiv’s dad refused to accept her and told her to leave the house and Shiv with a condition so harsh that she had no choice but to walk away and never lookback.

Maybe Smita will lash out BM for repeating what she did years ago, inflicting Shiv pain one more time.

I don’t think kanti was aware of Smita’s past .. neither were his family

they did not recognise Bua Ma or show any recognition to Shivansh

Raunak is kanti’s son that’s why he is so much attached to him and his family dotes on him ..

he may not be Smita’s son .. she came into his life when he was 2-3 months old .. she became a substitute to his mother and he filled the ache in her life

Sneha might be the half sister to both Shivansh and Raunak

Originally posted by: asmitamohanty

As Dora herself says...that kabhi kabhi woh khud samajh nahi pati Shivansh ko....

Shivansh is such a complex character... someone whom she will understand step by step all her life... it's like every day peeling a layer and discovering something totally new.... about him...

You know yesterday when Shivansh said.." tum Raunak se milne gayi thi" ..she immediately said " "toh"....as it is meeting raunak is nothing important to her ..like it is so trivial that she doesn't even think about it....it doesn't matter to her at all..so she could not fathom that it could mean sooo much to him....it would break him to this extent..

And she realised that..and instead of reprimanding him for not trusting her ..she so easily understood his issues...and realised that it's the unspoken words and unexpressed emotions that brings such insecurities.. and she immediately went ahead to comfort him,relieve his pain,soothe him .. with the thing that he exactly needed...the assurance that he is important,he is seen,he is loved by her .. fiercely..and she is choosing him...She gave it that with so much boldness...it takes strength and courage to bare your heart infront of a person as dark and as complex as Shivansh...and today Dora showed how strong she is

This couple hardly quarrels in front of others. The way they defend each other in front of others is a treat to watch. Couples should be like tht.

The way writers handled the whole conversation it is really praiseworthy for an ITV couple .

Originally posted by: Fillowship

To me the epidode was really satisfying but i must say something was just out of place . Why is Sonalika so happy , have she suddenly forgotten her big words about hurting shiv and wanting him to beg her ?" I felt like slapping that joy of their faces ,(BM and gang )

Are Bua Ma , Sonalika and Tanya so blind and stupid .
can’t they see the difference in looks of Prarthna with any of them

Earlier Sonalika was still coldly beautiful..

but right now Sonalika and Tanya are very very average looking in comparison to Prarthna .,