Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

4.4k

Users

17

Likes

174

Frequent Posters

YASHO1997 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Shaavi



Yosho, I am a working woman. But I don't agree with anything that you said. I work for my happiness. My husband supports me if I have extra work in office. If not I am the one who is with the kids. Not because he forces me to, but because I want to. I come home and cook, not just one meal for the whole family, but I make different dishes for each of them. Not because I am forced to, but because I want to. Work is in it's place, but family comes first. I don't want to "grow" if it means hurting my family. Yes I spend a little more time with our kids than my husband. But I don't see that there is nothing wrong with it. Both of us love our children and both want what is best for them. Both my kids love and look up to me not because I am a professional or that I buy the things they ask for. But they do that for the love care and the priority importance I give them. When I make them the dish of their choice even after having a hard day at work, they appreciate me for that. They respect me for making them a priority and giving them importance.

My mom is a homemaker. After my father passed away she worked hard to give us an opportunity to have a life. She fought for us, protected us, was there for us. She didn't put herself as more important than us. And for me I couldn't have been more proud of my mom. She gave us such values that today we are praised for them.

Recently I was talking to one of my colleague. He is around 60 yrs old and has grand kids. I have seen him work like 18 hrs a day. He is very smart and intelligent and is also adept in technical knowledge. While talking to him for some topic I answered if I have to make a choice between my career and my kids, I choose my kids in a heartbeat. And he said I applaud you and respect you even more than that. Family is important. You shouldn't let other things consume you and take you away from that. And he was telling me that when he is with his wife, he is shut down to the world. Cause she is there at other times, so he wants to be there with her. His idea of a gift for his wife -- hand written coupons which can use any time she wants. And all of them are something that she could get easily with money outside but getting them from partner can give such a marital bliss. Usually they are like I will give you massages, will be your beck and call maid for a week etc. and he was saying that he has been doing this for like years and his wife loves it. Even more than the other gifts hie buys with money.

I do not agree with anything you said. What Sonakshi is doing is very selfish and all she wants to do is satisfy her false pride and ego. I am really glad the makers are showing that family is important more than what Sonakshi is doing.



Wow I never thought I would get a response like this!
Firstly I don't agree with what you said.
For me, this dichotomy between her work and her family has never risen. My mother is exactly like you. I mean does everything you said you do and by her choice only and we love and respect her for that.
But I don't get why this point is rising? Did we ever see sona giving more importance to her job? I never felt so!
And even if she did or any woman does... Why is she called selfish?
For you your family may come before everything, for someone else it might not. Or rather it may be equal just as I have always felt with sona.
So your point is she should sit at home? Or do her work from home so that she can be close to sona?
I am appalled that she is being called egoistic and selfish and what not just because she wants to make a name for herself!
But I guess should have expected it.
It's clear we will never agree on this so I will stop here.
dlavanya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#22
@yasho .. thank you for ur posts. I agree with everything you said. I am also a working mother and i like to do things for my family too. My husband cooks and cleans too just like i do. It doesnt make me not giving priority to my family.

I dont know why ppl feel sonakshi priotizes her work above family... i just dont get it... she is just prioritizing her work above dev dixits emotional and temper tantrums... thats all i could see..

Did sona go to meet the client even after school called her that soha met with accident? No .. How much sense does it make to expect her to sit at home and wait for the accident to happen again in future so that she could serve her purpose..

I am confident makers would support that in a family both husband and wife can take care of the family members and kids together without sacrificing their identity. It is not necessary for both parents to be available incase there is an emergency. Yes if soha is bedridden and need constant parental care then we can talk abt priorities between work and family.

Again it boils down to the individual choices. You cant ask sona to quit the job or work from home to be available all the time. Dev could do the same. Or if it really that important then they could split the work from home days.

But again sohas accident is just an excuse. Dev just wants to keep sonakshi in his golden cage inorder to protect her. He needs to go for
Counseling or psychiatrist immediately before the condition worsens.. his emotional issues need to be addressed asap.

Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#23
Calvin, Asha and Yasho, I never said that Sonakshi should sit at home or give up her work. All I am saying is she needs to treat others fairly and treat them as she wants to be treated. She cannot preach something and not follow it. She is like the person who gives a lecture about how smoking is injurious to health and how one can get rid of that bad habit, but once that lecture is done is found smoking herself. She wants freedom of choice then she should give Dev the same freedom of choice. Why did she force him to get his sisters back home. Who is she to interfere in his or for that matter Ishwari's personal space when she is not ready to give them access to her space. Before reminding Dev of his responsibilities as a father, husband, son or brother, she needs to fulfill her duties of a wife, mother, daughter or sister. She doesn't really does anything of the sort. It is a wife's responsibility to protect her husband and his family being destroyed by anybody. It was her moral and ethical responsibility to tell Dev and Ishwari about Vickky's acts. She has no right to decide for them. And if she makes such a decision then she should be ready for the other way around too. She cannot keep crying foul anytime someone questions her for her mistakes. She needs to stop acting like Soha and start acting like her mother and be a responsible adult. Being an adult doesn't just mean taking decisions, it is also about taking responsibility for that decision. She made the decision to go to that meeting, so she needs to take responsibility for not being there when Soha needed her. Not blame it on something else. And that is what I am saying. She cannot keep interchanging her stance where she can justify herself to be right all the time.

A relationship is a two way street. You have to give what you want to get. You cannot get without giving the same. Yes it should be her choice where she works from. But then no matter what the consequences are, good or bad, she is responsible. She cannot blame someone else when her choice results having a negative impact.
Edited by Shaavi - 8 years ago
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: _suchi_

Yup agree di
Dev's situation is in a great mess now even he can't help himself from this .
Donno about God but I believe sona only can calm down him. I Don't think anyone except sonakshi can help him now.
I wish more than God sonakshi understand dev's situation and make him believe that she never leave him instead of ignoring him. Hope they will not witness another pathetic separation.

Agree with you Suchi. But Sonakshi is not helping so only god can save him.
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: WeRockTheWorld

I think the story line is written to suit the interest of the characters...I somehow feel they don't want to show romance or show any track in which Dev and Sonakshi will be appreciated as a pair. They don't want to make ppl believe that the USP of this show is Dev and Sonakshi...hence trying to highlight other characters by giving better story line and dialogues to all supporting characters...

I feel its done on purpose...they don't give IVs together ...its all about what the PH and CVs want to project abt their serial...so no point in feeing bad or angry...this is what I think is happening ...I could be wrong ...not sure...but I have stopped seeing logic in this story or even expecting anything...

I watch it these days because I am used to seeing it...that's all...

I can understand.
dlavanya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#26
@shaavi
If I remember it correctly... sona did not twist Dev's arm or had him at gun point and asked him to get the sisters back. She only put forward her honest efforts.. who is she to do it? She is his wife and she can definitely suggest things that are good for family with out forcing them and by using proper arguments and sensible talks.. that's exactly what she did...

Regarding not following what one preaches - this is a big problem of both mom and daughter (asha and sona). But dont think this is applicable to this particular situation (though there are many where this happened).

Sona did not agree to stay at home . Dev just announced what he wanted and left inthe morning. He is invading her little personal space and making decisions (every individual has this tiny bit of personal spacethat the spouse should respect).

Now taking responsibility for decisions... clearly she did take responsibility in this situation. She explained the reason for delay - traffic and also apologized to soha that she could not be there at the school .. so i dont know why you say she is blaming something or someone else for this. What else do u expect her to do?
randommusings thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: ltelidevara


Dev Dixit's mornings are not different. He won't get any passionate welcoming kiss when he gets up in the morning. Instead he will find his wife hurrying up to meet the demands of her profession .Ofcourse she will see to it that his mobile and laptop are charged and ready


Well it happened quite recently when Sona told him to sleep little more n gave a good morning kiss...

BTW is Sona getting blessed with passionate welcoming kiss every morning ?? Or did she wake up to see her husband going thru her office files n rescheduling her meetings...

Sorry but didnt agree with rest of your post either..its important that we try n understand pov of both Dev n Sona rather than being biased to one n completely refuse to accept other's pov.

Gaon_ki_gori thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#28
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your post. It seems that giving passionate kisses in the bed, sharing coy glances in the car and having naughty moments at the dining table are the only qualifications for being a good wife.
Whatever a woman chooses to be her priority be it either home or career should be totally her choice. We can't undermine one and praise the other.
I found that scene of Dev arranging Sona's meetings at home to be extremely interfering. How will Dev feel tomorrow if Sona starts doing it with his work. There should be certain boundaries in personal and professional lives which should be respected by both partners.
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: randommusings


Well it happened quite recently when Sona told him to sleep little more n gave a good morning kiss...

BTW is Sona getting blessed with passionate welcoming kiss every morning ?? Or did she wake up to see her husband going thru her office files n rescheduling her meetings...

Sorry but didnt agree with rest of your post either..its important that we try n understand pov of both Dev n Sona rather than being biased to one n completely refuse to accept other's pov.

You are welcome to disagree with my post.I know how difficult it is to understand Dev's point of view for those who stand on the other side and talk about understanding both . Atleast I am straight away admitting where I stand.
If you really are neutral you won't say what you said above and disagree.

And I am not talking about one random morning when Dev had the good fortune of seeing her shower a little quantity of her grace in the form of love.
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Gauri.0109

Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your post. It seems that giving passionate kisses in the bed, sharing coy glances in the car and having naughty moments at the dining table are the only qualifications for being a good wife.

Whatever a woman chooses to be her priority be it either home or career should be totally her choice. We can't undermine one and praise the other.
I found that scene of Dev arranging Sona's meetings at home to be extremely interfering. How will Dev feel tomorrow if Sona starts doing it with his work. There should be certain boundaries in personal and professional lives which should be respected by both partners.

As much as I know if Sona interferes in his work Dev will welcome her. He has high regard for her and allow her to have her way with even his affairs. He became ready to offer her support when she took decisions in Khatri issue .
By the way he never wanted Sona to stop working.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".