*Season 2, Week 11* Analysis Thread - Page 29

Created

Last reply

Replies

383

Views

36.8k

Users

49

Likes

5.2k

Frequent Posters

amaypranay thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
Awww Deep's..I was looking for your post! And here it is... 👏 such cute moments today to start off Dev and Soha walking down the stairs so lovely ! And then just some nice gestures like the gift..the comfort in offering to help.. the smile when everyone was adoring his Soha..beautiful..I can say Dev is genuinely a very caring father and is comfortable at the Bose house!

I agree with you part regarding manhandling ..Sonakshi knows her ways around Dev Dixit.. she was a teacher to him few minutes later.. and he was her student! Both were in la la land
..



😆

Awesome post my Dear.. 👏
Edited by amaypranay - 8 years ago
_Payalj_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
So I came to know only today that Sonakshi was molested? Why couldn't I see it yesterday? Anyways I have taken an appointment with ophthalmologist for helping me out today.
On a serious note whatever happens between a couple is their business if both the parties agree to it. Those who follow a krishna sect where one has to stay fully dressed and fornicate only for the sake of reproduction are also right and those who indulge in BDSM are also right provided both partners agree and are happy with it.

I couldn't see any repulsion or feeling of humiliation on Sona's face. What I saw was attitude. She didn't push him strongly, hit him or abuse him. She didn't try to fight. Who cares about how many people are standing outside or what function is going on if they are being misbehaved with??

So if Mia biwi raazi why are we trying to be the kaazi?
Edited by _Payalj_ - 8 years ago
KumbhkarnKiNani thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: _Payalj_

So I came to know only today that Sonakshi was molested? Why couldn't I see it yesterday? Anyways I have taken an appointment with ophthalmologist for helping me out today.

On a serious note whatever happens between a couple is their business if both the parties agree to it. Those who follow a krishna sect where one has to stay fully dressed and fornicate only for the sake of reproduction are also right and those who indulge in BDSM are also right provided both partners agree and are happy with it.

I couldn't see any repulsion or feeling of humiliation on Sona's face. What I saw was attitude. She didn't push him strongly, hit him or abuse him. She didn't try to fight. Who cares about how many people are standing outside or what function is going on if they are being misbehaved with??

So if Mia biwi raazi why are we trying to be the kaazi?


Could I join you for the ophthalmologist visit ? Meri halat bhi bilkul aap ki tarah hai...😊😊
aaliah3108 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: _Payalj_

So I came to know only today that Sonakshi was molested? Why couldn't I see it yesterday? Anyways I have taken an appointment with ophthalmologist for helping me out today.

On a serious note whatever happens between a couple is their business if both the parties agree to it. Those who follow a krishna sect where one has to stay fully dressed and fornicate only for the sake of reproduction are also right and those who indulge in BDSM are also right provided both partners agree and are happy with it.

I couldn't see any repulsion or feeling of humiliation on Sona's face. What I saw was attitude. She didn't push him strongly, hit him or abuse him. She didn't try to fight. Who cares about how many people are standing outside or what function is going on if they are being misbehaved with??

So if Mia biwi raazi why are we trying to be the kaazi?


Woah !!!!! the lines in red !!! 👍🏼

Every couple is different ...just very very different. What happens between a couple is just not anybody's business. Not even ours .

We are just a 3rd party ... we cannot be in that position to judge what the couple is feeling while being in that position. I think I am being a bit explicit if I say that even the way people make love to each other can be done in 100 different ways, some that are fathomable, some that are completely fantasy so please lets just leave this here !!! Some will enjoy it while others will feel disgusted. But, but it all depends on the couple...we are no one to say .,...Hawww!!!! What are they doing ...??and all that jazz...let them do it if they are happy !

It was no manhandling !! Sona should have slapped him if she felt offended or turned off !!!

IF Dev exerted his rights on her Sona did too...how much was she scolding him...seedhe khade raho ...hilna mat and he was !!! Was he not listening ...why are we not talking about this too !!!
These two are just confused consenting adults and enjoy whatever effect they have on each other ... they really do !!!

Sona didn't have a problem tying the Dhotii to the man who supposedly manhandled her ...why the hell are we going ballistic !!! 😆😆

During Shimla trip, didnt Sona push Dev oh so many times ...I did not see any kind of manhandling posts then !!! Please lets not dig old pages !! 😛😛 . Both of them do such things to each other ,! To be clear I am Team Devakshi because I see a couple who has so much still in between them that it will take 7 lives to get over it, yet they are so far off from each other due to external factors !!!

It is just a matter of time ... these two are already so much in love... I in fact felt sad that they both are not able to embrace what they truly, madly , deeply want which is themselves in each other 's arms !!!

It makes me feel that they have accepted it that they cannot be together despite so much of attraction, love, rights , want. desire and their child between themselves !!!
Edited by aaliah3108 - 8 years ago
sona_naksh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
visit forum once after epi ...and i get to realise i watched d different show all togeder 😆
n den come back to this thread and u realise u are not alpne in watching d different show 🤣
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: deepsel

@Sam: I don't know about others, but meri saas tho hatak gai watching those pantless thighs even if its for micro seconds 🤣 (people please don't judge me as some hormonal fangirl deprived of everything but a smart woman who knows to take harmless pleasure free of cost in reel scenarios😉😆)


Deepa, I am like, beyond honoured that you chose to direct this keen observation at me I feel like my GM status has been fully validated now.🤣 But at this rate, we can all retire our GMs... CVs have taken over that job themselves. "Tum abhi aakar mujhe is dhoti se nikalogi" Jab baat itna seedha, to imagination ya analysis ki kya zaroorat? 😈

@all: Great discussions about the issue of manhandling vs. consensual foreplay. I personally saw it as the latter as well, in which Sona was a willing participant. Any doubts I had were put to rest when Sona retorted, "It's Dr. Bose for you, Mr. Obodhro." Those are very intimate references and nicknames that they shared when they were very much a couple and from their mention, I thought it was clear that Sona was in that space along with Dev. Dev stumps Sona with his actions, Sona stumps Dev with her words.

Sex/sexuality is a complicated beast and l suppose the way you view yesterday's scene depends a lot on how you view Dev. If his acts are irredeemable to you and he is an outright villain, then yesterday may look like manhandling, but if you see him as half of this suppressed, electric soulmate connection, then it looks like dark, coded foreplay.

*As a mod, a reminder that all views are equally welcome and mocking someone for seeing the scene differently is unfair*

Some other points of interest:

They focused on the picture that Sona gave Ishwari on her birthday, and soon after showed Dev giving Saurabh and Ronita something similar. I thought that was a beautiful echo. It also shows the undertone that Ishwari has to understand -- if she is to have any hope of getting her son back, it can only happen through Sona. He touched her feet for the first time in (I assume) seven years in the Bose house. I don't think that was a coincidence. Give Dev the tools to be a good son to you, Ishwari; don't resist Sona's magic touch and let Dev be part Bose; it gives Dev the desire and strength to be a happy Dixit (and you need a LOT of strength for that).

I loved the juxtaposition of Saurabh/Ronita with Sona/Dev. The former are very much in that innocent, puppy-love stage -- very similar to where Devakshi were during Neha's wedding. It was really effective to see their playful little games, with Saurabh manufacturing angst out of nothing, while on the other hand we have Devakshi drowning in the depths of their intense history. Saurabh pretending to be anangr just to hear those three words from Ronita vs. Dev and Sona, for whom anger is the only acceptable emotional outlet for their overwhelming feelings, anger which they are using to mask the too obvious presence of those same three words. Good stuff.

Dev and Bijoy are too cute. The tashan between sasur-damad is running just a few stops behind (ex)pati-patni. First comes tashan, then comes silly mind games, then Soha ke liye decency, and finally, one fateful night, mussoorie ki kasam, pyar ho hi jayega. 😳 Bijoy is not a hard man to please, and I am glad he is there to make sure Dev toes the line. Dev just needs to remember they are on the same side.
Edited by Samanalyse - 8 years ago
Drcs thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Guys thanks to all of you for bringing my sanity back😆...I may fall into minority, somehow I couldn't enjoy yesterday's epi...You know I am a hardcore Devakshian, whatever is dished out I take it happily and relish it...but yesterday was so different...I didn't find Dev as MH...I felt something was missing...being a weekend I borrowed time from my family to watch KRPKAB before going out ...hence my husband had no other choice so he watched the last 5 minutes with me...when the serial ended I said "I am so angry let's go out, I wasted my time"...my husband mockingly said "you are saying this, aren't they sooo cute ( voice modulation was exactly mine)...you said they got 1 yr extension so it will take 6months for her to reciprocate, another 3 months for touching and 3 more months for a kiss by then the serial will be over...with a devilish smirk he said "you were saying you watch this hadka serial bcoz its leads are sanskaris and now what happened?" I hurriedly put an end to this convo and said "acha baba abhi shuru math ho jao, its weekend"... morning when I read posts I felt better...thanks deariesss...may be if watch again I will go to devakshiland😉

Edited by Drcs - 8 years ago
JShukla thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Frankly even I did not find the jerky man-handling interaction between Dev- Sonakshi romantic. I though it was in the spirit of the thread to put forward your views.
Should I be referred to opthlmologist because I did infact cringe watching it? Many viewers appreciate mellowed sweet romance and its viewers experience. Also from where I viewed Sonakshi did not look thrilled even if not put off.

Though I agree she is not me and hence her experience and perception will be different. But as a viewer shouldn't I be made to enjoy it through her experience. So then can I put this down as a lack of acting skills there?

PS: Thanks Sam for allowing my post here. I am amidst many who did not like yesterday's scene. Even if I was with Dev or viewed him differently the scene in itself is not my genre.
Also Sam Dev had touched Ishwari's feet before leaving for Bose house and he touched again the next day.
Edited by JShukla - 8 years ago
_Payalj_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: JShukla

Frankly even I did not find the jerky man-handling interaction between Dev- Sonakshi romantic. I though it was in the spirit of the thread to put forward your views.

Should I be referred to opthlmologist because I did infact cringe watching it? Many viewers appreciate mellowed sweet romance and its viewers experience. Also from where I viewed Sonakshi did not look thrilled even if not put off.

Though I agree she is not me and hence her experience and perception will be different. But as a viewer shouldn't I be made to enjoy it through her experience. So then can I put this down as a lack of acting skills there?

PS: Thanks Sam for allowing my post here. I am amidst many who did not like yesterday's scene. Even if I was with Dev or viewed him differently the scene in itself is not my genre.
Also Sam Dev had touched Ishwari's feet before leaving for Bose house and he touched again the next day.


JShukla, it might have been distasteful to you. Even I am not a great fan of dark foreplay. But did it look forcing to you? Did the lead actress look repulsed by the attentions she was getting. Being angry for being asked to do a work one doesn't want to do and feeling forced upon or threatened by sexual overtones is something different.

Human emotions are never so easy to categorise as black and white. It is quite possible to be sexual attracted even while being angry. The fact that you and I don't appreciate such feelings will not turn them into something they weren't.

An ophthalmologist is not needed for not liking something because that purely depends upon personal taste. I for one didn't enjoy the scene but I don't think I need an ophthalmologist for not being a fan of this genre of representation of sexual tension.
But yes if I see something which is not there, then I do need a eye check up.
JShukla thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Payal- I said I did not like(can vary person to person) the scene. I also said Sonakshi did look repulsed . She looked angry and if I remember her 'so called consent ' reason was that she did not want her Dada's function to be spoiled. Understandable. Dev will not mind creating a scene at Bose house. And if he did loss would be Bose family's, not his.
Remember that Sona still feels he made them homeless 7 years back

If CVs wanted to show some good sexually charged scene create a situation where Sona is not made to chose difficult trade-offs. Here it appeared like she chose to remain silent for the sake of her family's honor. There could be numerous ways, but may be she was so surprised and didn't have enough wits to react or wriggle out of situations intelligently.

On second thoughts the CVs could have added a whole lot of dimensions with Dev blackmailing Bijoy to tie dhoti on him?Like "I would stay in my denims and attend your function. if you want me to wear Dhoti, you will help me.."Wouldn't it have been a notch more endearing for Sona to watch Dev coming down the stairs with her Baba ..
May be I am a not so satisfied fan of current story telling?.


Edited by JShukla - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".