Selfish!!! EDITED: Today's Thoughts Page 1

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Since I started watching the show, I heard Dev was referred to as Shravan Kumar.

The story of Shravan Kumar, is that he devoted his life to his ageing parents and took care of them at their old age. That's an example of a great son.

He never married because he already had responsibility of his parents. That's an example of a considerate and sensitive human being.

Dev is not Shravan Kuman because he is neither a great son nor a considerate and sensitive human being.

He and his mother, according to him has an unique relationship. They don't have to be like anyone else. Based on their action the interpretation is that they don't have to give a eff about anyone else as long as they are focused on each other.

Why bring another woman between this unique relationship? Where is the space for anyone else, let alone a wife? Who wants to live their life on crumbs? A woman leaves her family behind to share her life with her husband, and here she is provided whatever crumbs are left over after his mother takes the lion's share and his family takes the rest and some people expect that woman to just be content with that?

Let's be honest here. This is how the world works. Parents raise kids, kids grow up and get married and create their own family and the cycle continues.

Both side of the family through the couple becomes blended family who stand by each other through thick and thin.

Sona very easily accepted Dev's sisters as her sisters. She spends her time bonding with them. So they come to her for advice and their problems.

Did Dev spent any time with Saurabh beyond around family when Sona is there? Why would Saurabh ever consider sharing his problems with Dev?

Sona accepted Ishwari as her mother and gave her all due respect. Even if Asha told her to treat Ishwari like a stranger, Sona won't ever hurt Dev's mother.

But Dev? He did it in a heatbeat. Why would anyone consider Dev to be part of their family? He only belongs heart and soul to Ishwari.

Then why marry? Where is any space in his life for a wife? Hell, he doesn't even have space in his life for a cat, let alone another human being.

Marriage is a social custom where two people want to share their life and family together.

Otherwise, casual flings is also a possibility these days as well as convenient where two people can continue to have their separate life and just come together for sex.

In that arrangement, nothing has to change in their personal life including their family dynamics and lifestyle. There was absolutely no need for Dev to ever get married since Sona has to take a crowbar to pry her place in his home and his priorities constantly which is exhausting for anyone.

I am sorry. When a man hurts a woman for the sake of his mother, he is not a good human being and thus a FAILURE of her own upbringing.

Let me give you an example.

A mother raises two sons. One day she tells them that the begger on the street offends her. So they should go and throw her out of the city.

One son says no and tells her with all due respect that she has taught him to respect human being regardless their social status and that's why he can't hurt an innocent person just because she is bothering her with no fault of her own.

The other son goes and throws the lady out of the city and comes to the mother saying that whatever she wants, he will do it without considering whom he has to hurt.

Who do you think was the better son and better human being? Who do you think was an example of a good parenting?


A parents' job is not to create mindless slaves who runs around doing their bidding, their job is to create compassionate and caring human beings who respect everyone whether they are related by blood with them or not.

Ishwari is a failure as a mother and Dev is a failure as a son and worse, he is a failure as a husband and a compassionate human being.

Shravan Kumar could not do justice to a woman, so he didn't marry. That's fair and selfless. Dev is selfish because he wants just a woman on tap to use when he wants her and sideline her when he doesn't or she comes between his family matters. That's a shitty example of a human being and a husband.

And I don't know why would any woman want to put up with that.

EDITED: Wow, I must be psychic. I wrote a post on selfishness and Dev proved just how much selfish he can be.
To sum up Dev's definition of love based on today's episode.

He wants his room just the way he wants it.

He wants his life just the way his mother wants.

He wants every single ritual, custom, status quo of his family continue to be the same.

But he also wants an invisible woman when he wants to get laid and understanding enough to give up her family, her identity, her dreams, her happiness, her life to be at his beck and call at his service...

In exchange he will generously let her have her career and a space at the corner of his room. He will even throw in some romance in private.

Really, what an epic husband and awesome love story...

It's an example of just how much a person can love their own self that they don't even care about anyone else.

He deserves the best lover of self award!!! Let's give him a standing ovation..

Dev, I also have a prize for you. My wish from the bottom of my heart is to your company shares become the worth of your words and your promises... And we all know how much they are worth!!!


Edited by tia.o - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

99

Views

5.7k

Users

26

Likes

532

Frequent Posters

gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Take a Bow👏 Especially for these lines as to me being a Parent a Good one surpasses any relationship and that is what they are slaughtering in this show in the name of a skewed depiction of reality.
A parents job is not to create mindless slaves, their job is to create compassionate and caring human beings who respect everyone whether they are related by blood with them or not.

If it is any consolation I have stopped watching but even reading the written updates with a very detached frame of mind as a story which can be either a tragedy if Sona remains a doormat, Comedy if Easwari miraculously in the last episode redeems !!!!!!!!!, or inspiring if Sona has to Guts to walk out of a Toxic environment and Dev really Man's up ( I am not using the word Grown Up here because some people even grown do not become adults automatically)
Edited by gemini54 - 8 years ago
gmgi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Beautiful post as usual Tia. I have a request. Please don't stop posting even if you stop watching the show.
Now coming to the topic this has always been my doubt. Had Dev's father left his mother after he got married to Ishu? Or her MIL behaved the same with Ishu like she is behaving now. Because that is how the cycle of abuse goes on. What is your opinion on this Tia.😃
Rithu0203 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Agree with your points.
The sad part is, Dev is not even learning from his past mistakes.. he is repeating the same mistake he did during break-up time. not even 0.1% change in his behavior from break-up to till now.

Its high time, CVs should show some real progress in Dev's character, then Ishwari as good mother, then they can start with her journey to good mother-in law, instead of letting down Dev further low.

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Thank you, It's feels even better coming from a parent herself, Sabita. I am not a parent yet. But I know my mother would never want me to hurt another human being in the name of parental devotion. In fact, she would be proud of me if I defy her to keep another innocent person from hurt.

Originally posted by: gemini54

Take a Bow👏 Especially for these lines as to me being a Parent a Good one surpasses any relationship and that is what they are slaughtering in this show in the name of a skewed depiction of reality.

A parents job is not to create mindless slaves, their job is to create compassionate and caring human beings who respect everyone whether they are related by blood with them or not.

If it is any consolation I have stopped watching but even reading the written updates with a very detached frame of mind as a story which can be either a tragedy if Sona remains a doormat, Comedy if Easwari miraculously in the last episode redeems !!!!!!!!!, or inspiring if Sona has to Guts to walk out of a Toxic environment and Dev really Man's up ( I am not using the word Grown Up here because some people even grown do not become adults automatically)

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Thank you. Here's my opinion.

I don't know about Ishwari's background. I have no doubt it was sad and rough. But it's in our own hand to stop cycle of abuse.

If my mother-in-law behaved like Ishwari, I'd still won't behave like that with my own daughter-in-law because I personally know how it feels. That's compassion.

My daughter-in-law would be someone's cherished child, someone's loving sister and most importantly, my own son's life partner. Treating her with disrespect will not only hurt her, but will also hurt my son. That's motherhood.

As a mother who loves her son, I can't be the cause of hurt or bitterness in my son's relationship. If I try to control my son's life and keep hurting his wife to boost my ego, then I am selfish. I am not a mother who wants her child to be happy.

Hence the title of my post.

Originally posted by: gmgi

Beautiful post as usual Tia. I have a request. Please don't stop posting even if you stop watching the show.

Now coming to the topic this has always been my doubt. Had Dev's father left his mother after he got married to Ishu? Or her MIL behaved the same with Ishu like she is behaving now. Because that is how the cycle of abuse goes on. What is your opinion on this Tia.😃

Jessicafang thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
he and his mum are so sick.
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
My disappointment with Dev was that exactly what you said. He learned absolutely NOTHING from his heartbreak. It is now making me doubt that if he even had a heartbreak or he was just missing the connection to his only friend.

I wonder if he would be as desperately sad, had Sona not withdrawn her friendship after the break up.

Because by his behaviour since marriage, it seems that he had an uncertain business deal which he got signed, sealed and delivered. Now he doesn't even care about it anymore as long as it keeps generating profit without incurring loss.

I am sorry but I have seen zero effort on his part to make Sona comfortable.

He speaks a lot of high ideals. But when it comes to delivering them, he backs off.

He said to Sona in a very romantic dialogue that she can turn the room maroon, can make his room into a jungle, even change his name to Sonakshi Bose. But all Sona bought was a swing and he already started to feel irritated by it.

He told Asha that he is her son, but one command from Ishwari and he backed off his words faster than a speed train.

If he is that weak in personality and his words are that worthless, then why doesn't he ask permission from Ishwari before speaking anything?

Why pretend to have any personality when he has none? Why make any promises which is not worth spending breathe on?

Then what good is even his marriage vows? What is the guarantee that he will at least keep them?

Originally posted by: Rithu0203

Agree with your points.

The sad part is, Dev is not even learning from his past mistakes.. he is repeating the same mistake he did during break-up time. not even 0.1% change in his behavior from break-up to till now.

Its high time, CVs should show some real progress in Dev's character, then Ishwari as good mother, then they can start with her journey to good mother-in law, instead of letting down Dev further low.

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Thank you. 😊

Originally posted by: varshu_018

Very beautifully written

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Thank you. 😊

Originally posted by: raji91

beautiful post dear...
well written

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".