Is ishwari really wrong ?? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2.6k

Users

15

Likes

108

Frequent Posters

dlavanya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: aaliah3108

Yeah I get your point too but I think one can tone down a little...chalo I'll let go of her snapping on Sona before she knew that Even Dev is involved... But now she knows... I'm. Even OK with the fact that this is her house and she wants to do all for her children but ignoring facts even though they r in ur face is wrong... Her last line today... Mere bete ke peeche padi hai even though Dev was taking her name is ignoring the obvious...you have to snap... And be angry... Take it out on him
.. That's ur territory... Scolding Sona is ideally not her territory... Who gives her the right to scold her... It's all about how u look at this...



I agree. Dev didnot tell her yet. She still thinks dev is seedha saadha and sona did magic on him and trapped. I think she will tone it down a bit once dev reveals it to her directly.

Also i dont think she is actually acolding sona. She told her not to interfer and sona is still dojng it and ishwari doesnt like it. Lets see what happens after dev reveals...
Sonal99 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: dlavanya

Sorry i have been jumping across the fence too many times during the last one week...

Saw so many posts on how ishwari is treating sona like doormat or insulting her etc...
But is she really insulting her ??? Lets review some scenes

1. Halwa episode
If the kid doesnt eat his moms halwa becoz some doc said it is not healthy. How is the mom supposed to feel??? All the hatred and anger that are just shown to us . When she confronted sona, i feel all she did was drawing boundaries for her doc and reminding her that she is her nutritionist and no need to advice her kids as they dont have any health problems... Again this is not an insult. She just reminded sona her job...

The mom is supposed to respect the relationships that his son makes and promises that he makes that he has to keep. She is aware that at this point her son hesitated to eat the halwa and only ate it so as not to offend his mom. He did it to please her not because he wanted to. That sort of thinking is usually expected from a mother who does things for her child, not a son who has to worry about his grown up mom's feelings.

2. Hawan episode
She was broken that her son did noy sit in pooja because of her but because of sona (who is just a dcotor in the house). She behaved same witheveryone in the house. She said she is happy in an angry manner as she is hurt. I can totally understand her tone but again nothing alarming here.

It is alarming. She is more heart broken about her ego being hurt than being happy about the fact that he sat in the hawan. Her relationship with her son is all about her ego feeling high because he listens to her.



3. Inauguration day- sona said she is looking beautiful and asked if shr is going some where. Ishwari said "has kyu" . Yeah what is wrong in it. Haa bahar jaarahi hu .. Kyu kuch chahiye kya/problem hai kya bhi mean kar sakta hai...


We all know her meaning. We do not have to pretend otherwise.


4.nikki homework- same thing ishwari told her it is not her job to help nikki and all . It is very late and she should go home as her family will be waiting for her. Again as devakshi fan i do t like this but again there is nothing wrong in what she said

Her intentions were otherwise. Never mind what she said.


5. Today when she hear dev taking sonas name - yes she got to know that dev is also equally involved . She is heart broken as she alwys expected her son to share such major things in his life with her. I am sure she woulf have been ok if dev told her the next day after confession that he loves sona. Things wont be this bad.. But again dev wanted to have this time for himself and it is totally ok.

What is she heartbroken about her son is a grown man and he will make lots of decisions in his life; some very private that he will not share with his mom. What is wrong with that?


6. In todays precap- usually these precaps only show part ofthe conversation. So from flashback we saw that dev likes to eat khichifi eith lemon pickle when he is sick and ishwari probably cam down to make it for him. There she saw sona making soup for him ( again she told sona that she doesnt need to get involved in her kids matter) so she said it again that she will take care and no need to get involved . Nothing wtong here again.

It is wrong because her son wants Sona to be involved in his life. Her kids are not kids anymore that need her looking after. They are grown adults who can look after themselves and seek whoever's help they need to help them in their personal matters.

All i wanted to say is. Yes ishwari is not being very nice like before when she used to treat sona like her own daughter and family member and was ok when she used yo get involved in family matters, her kids diet and other things... But now since she knows that or atleast is in denial that sona has one sided crush on dev and her dev is not like this that he likes a girl and doesnt tellher... She is not able to digest this and is getting territorial and defending her possession ( dev in this case)

I am sure all mothers go thru this phase (could be hours/ days/ years) before they welcome their daughter in law wholeheartedly. It is just that this show is showing this phase in detail/the entire thought process/how they defend their territories. it is beautiful and this is the story of every family and i love it.

No, not all mothers go through this phase because their lives do not revolve around their children. They have their own ambitions to fulfill besides just having children.
Children are never possessions. Only selfish parents make them so; to please their egos. It is never about the love for their kids, they are too selfish for that. For such parents, it is always about themselves.

Just my thoughts and would like to hear your thoughts
🤗

Lisa012081 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13
She didn't feel any thing during Natasha why sona
AnuPurva thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#14
Nice post dear.. 😃
I dont want to say she is wrong or right.. but Its her possessive nature... I know many of you might wont agree with Ishwari's behavior, even I am also not at her side...she is hurt that her Son didn't shared such important decision of his life that he likes someone... she is wrong that she is expecting too much from his son... she is always dependent and doesnt want to share her son with anyone.. she is not understanding that her son is grown up now.. But thats her nature...
But situation would have been little different... she might have not hurt that much OR behaved that weirdly, if Dev would have told her about Sona before she came to know from someone else or by herself...
todays episode we saw she was totally broken when she heard Sona's name from Dev's mouth at unconscious state.. where she knows that Dev always wanted his mom with him when he is sick.. she was shattered knowing that Dev has someone else in his life.. but thats her nature... honestly I am not that shocked because I have seen such MIL so closely in my life...😉

My MIL was more or same like Ishwari (now she has changed a lot..😉😊... ) But I do like her or ignore her few things because I know that because of her I got so loving, caring , charming, husband like Dev ... 😳
thats why KRPKAB is close to my heart .. feels to me real 😉😃

it will take Ishwari to accept Sona as DIL... With Sona's matured nature will make Ishwari realized that her son has different place in his heart for mother and wife..😊 no one can take each others place. 😊
Edited by AnuPurva - 9 years ago
dlavanya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: AnuPurva

<font size="4" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Nice post dear..😃</font>
<font size="4" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">I dont want to say she is wrong or right.. but Its her possessive nature... I know many of you might wont agree with Ishwari's behavior, even I am also not at her side...she is hurt that her Son didn't shared such important decision of his life that he likes someone... she is wrong that she is expecting too much from his son... she is always dependent and doesnt want to share her son with anyone.. she is not agreeing that her son is grown up now.. But thats her nature... she might have not hurt that much OR behaved that weirdly, if Dev would have told her about Sona... because she is exploring by herself that Dev and Sona likes each other, she is hurt and feeling bad... But honestly I am not that shocked because I have seen such MIL so closely in my life...😉</font>

<font size="4" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">My MIL was more or same like Ishwari (now she has changed a lot..😉😊... ) But I do like her or ignore her few things because I know that because of her I got so loving, caring , charming, husband like Dev ...😳</font>
<font size="4" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">thats why KRPKAB is close to my heart .. feels to me real 😉😃</font>

<font size="4" face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">it will take Ishwari to accept Sona as DIL... With Sona's matured nature will make Ishwari realized that her son has different place in his heart for mother and wife..😊no one can take each others place.😊</font>



Absolutely ... She will accept sona over period of time. I know my mom is possessive of both me and my brother and it has been more than 10 yrs and my mom is still in the process of accepting her son in law and dauther in law 😛 . Just that she is independent and not insecure like ishwari. But doesnt leave a chance to dispaly her stake in our say 😃
AnuPurva thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: dlavanya


Absolutely ... She will accept sona over period of time. I know my mom is possessive of both me and my brother and it has been more than 10 yrs and my mom is still in the process of accepting her son in law and dauther in law 😛 . Just that she is independent and not insecure like ishwari. But doesnt leave a chance to dispaly her stake in our say 😃


Even my MIL took long time to accept her Son in law (my SIL's husband.) unlike Ishwari who accepted Ranveer easily...😉 I did faced problems initially after my marriage but mom's advice helped me a lot.. 😊

My mom used to say me that just like our all fingers are not same, at one house also we can not get people with same nature... we cant expect everyone to think like us..we do get some odds and evens in our life, need to learn how to handle the situation wisely... before reacting need to understand other side of the coin..😊
Edited by AnuPurva - 9 years ago
poojak thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
Whatever she us dping is wrong. Just bc she doesn't want share her son with anyone doesn't mean that dev can't live anyone else. I m hating this track. So annoying
mena_k thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
Of all her intentions are never that straight when she scolds Sona. She means exactly the way it feels (wrong way) to all of us. Like staying away from home late nights, take care of your lehenga, these are all so cheap comments.

Lets see how cv's deal the track. Hoping to see some good Devakshi moments before the storm really hits hard.
Jade0001 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
Ishwari has been someone that I liked she always had this soft nature understanding person so yeah I liked her then seeing that she showers all her love on Dev I at first thought maybe because he is the only child that cares so much for his mother but then all the girls love and care for Ishwari its just that she takes less time in bonding with her daughters .
she always praised Dev's efforts but never not once praised Neha's efforts now that is wrong as a mother .
Ishwari as a mother as the right to tell Sonakshi not to interfere in her children's diet that is fine the problem with Ishwari she is stuck in the past where Dev was a little boy clinging to his mother she still wants that
I agree she is disappointed that Dev did not speak to her about Sonakshi then get angry at Dev but no she punishes herself making herself get more sick so that Dev will give her his attention .
today's episode where Dev mutters Sonakshi's name Ishwari's expressions were of deep pain now Dev is her son not her husband he did not cheat he fell in love .
Ishwari needs to move forward from the past and realize her son has grown up
Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20
I have huge huge objections to some of the terminologies being used here -

1. Marking Sonakshi's territory..

From what I saw since Epi 3, it was Mr. Dixit who had appointed Dr. Sonakshi Bose.. So professionally it's Dev who is her employer.. And with that, marking her territory or drawing the line or sketching the job profile is something which Dev can do.. Ishwari doesnt become her employer just because she is Dev's mom.. Employer's family members are not Bosses.. Only the employer is.. So Ishwari has no business in getting involved about what Sona should do and what not.. She is a Patient and should behave like one first..

2. Before pointing to others, is she doing her part as a patient ? A doctor asks you to rest, a doctor asks you not to exert yourself in kitchen work, a doctor orders you to eat food on time, and you totally ignore her ! She is not acting her a patient either, it's her who is compelling Dev to leave office every freaking time to come home to convince her, she is one who is involving Dev between her and Sonakshi.. Why should she point out that Sona should act only as Doctor when her every action demands the attention of a son and not a doctor..

3. What's with this 'with time Ishwari will accept Sona'..

Is Sona some sort of criminal or anti-social, or forget about that, is she a bad/evil person with any bad quality that she is aware of that Ishwari needs to 'accept' with time ? Is Ishwari some Lord or something whose approval will decide the fate of 2 Adult individuals ? Who is she to accept or reject Sona ? Why wont Sona take time to 'accept' Ishwari.. In between the 2, I see Ishwari as a selfish irresponsible arrogant egoistic woman who needs to be accepted by everyone and lived with.. It should be Sona who needs to accept such obsessive MIL in her life.. Else who would tolerate such taunts and snide remarks on her character like this ?

Sorry to say but I cant agree with her characterization at all.. And I think she is getting bashed for all valid reasons here.. But I am happy to see one more Ishwari fan here which feels great 😳 .. Hopefully soon me too will be able to defend her actions.. 🥳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".