So, what do you think? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

74

Views

7.5k

Users

12

Likes

42

Frequent Posters

ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Malvika07


That's so sweet, Arch🤗
You girls can continue discussing. I will catch up soon and reading your analysis will just add to my experience, like it did with Sultan.😃



🤗 that's sweet...

Initially I didn't find the leads all that engaging. The girl was acting too innocent & cutsie and the guy seemed forced... But they seem to have smoothened their edges now...
The other 'friends' acting is quite natural. And yes, it takes effort to do justice to each character's story and am glad they didn't take the short route and turn all focus on the leads...

liked their song selection as per the scene requirement so far but YT is muting the songs now (copyright issue) - started muting it somewhere around episode 65 or so... so if it's not an original score created for the show, I can't hear anything...

bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#32



You are most welcome my friend!! I was sure the two of you would like it.🤗

Which episode are you at?

I am loving this discussion btw. I love reading both of your views and I look forward to dissecting this one with you guys.

Btw - do you like their background score selection??


I like how they use different songs according to the situation. They keep mixing it up. Though I love how our home show has tailor made songs for it, I also like the change this show offers with the tracks!

I like that our home show has a playlist so they can play songs appropriate for the track/scene ..quite like what these guys are doing but with famous tracks...

I find it very painful when shows have just one track irrespective of the situation
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#33


<font color="#0000ff">Absolutely. If you like her now, you will like her even more later...😊</font>

<font color="#0000ff">Yes, the ensemble cast and multiple parallel tracks which are all linked makes it interesting.</font>

Your's and Arch's analysis just makes me want to get there faster!! I need to buck up!


<font color="#0000ff">😊We are waiting!</font>




@bookworm - thank you for suggesting this show... I watched some more tonight and loving it. Am hooked...
Malvika is still to catch up so don't want to say too much and spoil her fun... 😃

That's so sweet, Arch🤗
You girls can continue discussing. I will catch up soon and reading your analysis will just add to my experience, like it did with Sultan.😃


🤗 that's sweet...

Initially I didn't find the leads all that engaging. The girl was acting too innocent & cutsie and the guy seemed forced... But they seem to have smoothened their edges now...
Thankfully they toned down their characters and that helped the actors deliver better performance. As it is they were quite raw initially. Niti who plays Nandini is good in emotional scenes and the post break up ones saw her come into her own because she got to portray a hurt young girl whose hopes are crushed, but with steely determination lurking underneath...The Nandini that we see after this break up does not have any of those childish and cutesy mannerisms neither is she innocent in a cliched way..she is more genuine...

The other 'friends' acting is quite natural. And yes, it takes effort to do justice to each character's story and am glad they didn't take the short route and turn all focus on the leads...

They did that for ~ 150 episodes, after that the tracks for the other cast were not of the same quality

liked their song selection as per the scene requirement so far but YT is muting the songs now (copyright issue) - started muting it somewhere around episode 65 or so... so if it's not an original score created for the show, I can't hear anything...

Oh! that is a pity! The background score really adds to the scenes. I wonder how Ishq bulava, mere maula maula, sindori rang suhaagan sacha etc, were not blocked but the ones after 65 are

Edited by bookworm123 - 9 years ago
ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#34
Ok so after ages, there's an Indian show that has me hooked. Thankfully, I don't have to wait for the next day to follow the story but dangerously, because I don't have to wait, I can't seem to wait either 😃
Had a 3 day business trip this week but still caught up on eps at airport lounges and after dinners...
It's working as a stress buster 😊

My most favourite character is Cabir. I love how natural his characterization, mannerisms, being the mirror to his friends (especially Manik) without any judgement, always having his friend's back and just laying it out as it is... This is what friendship is all about. V are most fortunate to hv such friendships in life and I hv some friends who would just blindly do if I asked for something, hv my back and then tell me later in private if they thought it was wrong but they would do it anyways because I asked - blessed.

Alia-dhruv - very good characterization there. both held by shadows of what they had - best friend/first attraction and BF. Totally get their feeling of betrayal as they come to know the truth of Manik-Nandini. Aptly portrayed. The insecurities and mixed emotions due to this and the growing feelings towards each other - very natural.

Mukti - I am not convinced of the Abhimanyu angle but this is a broken girl living with the hurt of a relationship that was broken brutally. Abhimanyu is a good catalyst to her healing while she decides to be with him in his little time.

Fab 5 - the whole situation of feeling something is going on between Manik-Nandini, the anger at not being included in this truth, the guarding of boundaries when seeing there is someone new entering the fab 5 circle - Friend groups defined right.
My most favorite moment is when Manik leaves his performance to go look for Nandini and the 3 guys in Fab 5 realise Manik loves Nandini. Cabir backing up his Friend when the others are screaming 'why didn't he tell us'... Loved Cabir's 'because he hasn't recognised his feelings yet. He hasn't put a name to it yet.' That was just perfect. Talk about a Friend knowing you better than you might want to see yourself and standing by you.
Cabir's acknowledgement of Nandini. His always being straight with her just because he knows his friend's feelings - I love this characterization.
Loved the scene where Nandini sneaks into the car and reaches Soha's Farmhouse... and Cabir spots her, brings her to his room. The easy acceptance of what she told him and the best - When Manik comes in, very coolly bringing out Nandini, introducing the 2 and just leaving them to themselves. He simply trusted Nandini for what she was saying just because she is important to Manik.
I would do exactly the same if it was one of my friends...

The lovebirds - the whole equation has turned very relatable. Manik does what Nandini says but he's not changed as a person. He's just included her in his thought process. Nandini is young and this is love's first brush and I like that she doesn't get carried away but stays true to herself.
Loved nandini's realization that she loves him. She finally defined her feelings and the change in body language, need for closeness and just soaking the moment in - beautiful.
Loved manik's realization. It was a stressful moment and when in deep crisis, mind has a knack of reaching the truth.

best is the dialogues are all natural. They don't keep mouthing big philosophies, they talk regular simple stuff that we might when with friends or loved one... They don't overly moon over each other, neither are throwing heavy words; they just flow with normal life. I would think this would be most difficult to write. To keep things regular without making it boring!

Chemistry - natural is the word that comes to mind. I don't want to say sizzling because if 2 people are attracted towards each other, there should be sparks and that's what I see so - natural.
And you can't just have emotional/mental attraction without physical attraction.
It's nice to see this shown the way it is without the flying dupattas and dreamy sequences.

I even like Navya for her simplicity and strength. Good characterization here.

I liked that they are touching on youth issues - drugs/depression, pregnancy, gay... and playing it out without being preachy.

I hope one day the youth shows & General entertainment shows dissolve the worlds they seem to be operating within and bring in each other's issues in their stories. Showing youth issues on a youth channel doesn't get parents involved and continuing with the saas-bahu equation (or whatever is happening in our home show) just widens the crevice between youth reality & older generation mindset. The youth will simply grow up to be confused adults - talk about promoting generation gap!
No wonder the mainstream channels seem to write such confused stories... They don't know what to do with their progressive characters so easy way out - turn regressive.

One thing I noticed is that some situations are same as our home show (being at cross-roads between friends & love, the thought of leaving love for Friend and few more) but this show handled all of these very well so far. Nandini telling him 'what if something else happens with your friends and you leave me again'... Manik telling Nandini he is at a cross-road and Nandini knowing how imp his friends are - understanding. She telling him 'follow your heart' and he does just that... He follows his heart. Plans out everything so the album goes ahead (that he knows is imp to his friends) and being there himself to protect Nandini... He doesn't need to leave one for the other but you can balance both if your heart is in the right place...
Wish our home show had walked the path of logic!

Ok! So after this long 'what I loved' post, you can see am totally in and loving the show 😃
I lost count of the episode numbers... It's just in YT autoplay 😃

Edited by ARCH21 - 9 years ago
ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: bookworm123



<font color="#0000ff">Absolutely. If you like her now, you will like her even more later...😊</font>

<font color="#0000ff">Yes, the ensemble cast and multiple parallel tracks which are all linked makes it interesting.</font>


Your's and Arch's analysis just makes me want to get there faster!! I need to buck up!


<font color="#0000ff">😊We are waiting!</font>




@bookworm - thank you for suggesting this show... I watched some more tonight and loving it. Am hooked...
Malvika is still to catch up so don't want to say too much and spoil her fun... 😃

That's so sweet, Arch🤗
You girls can continue discussing. I will catch up soon and reading your analysis will just add to my experience, like it did with Sultan.😃


🤗 that's sweet...

Initially I didn't find the leads all that engaging. The girl was acting too innocent & cutsie and the guy seemed forced... But they seem to have smoothened their edges now...
<font color="#0000ff">Thankfully they toned down their characters and that helped the actors deliver better performance. As it is they were quite raw initially. Niti who plays Nandini is good in emotional scenes and the post break up ones saw her come into her own because she got to portray a hurt young girl whose hopes are crushed, but with steely determination lurking underneath...The Nandini that we see after this break up does not have any of those childish and cutesy mannerisms neither is she innocent in a cliched way..she is more genuine...</font>

The other 'friends' acting is quite natural. And yes, it takes effort to do justice to each character's story and am glad they didn't take the short route and turn all focus on the leads...

<font color="#0000ff">They did that for ~ 150 episodes, after that the tracks for the other cast were not of the same quality</font>

liked their song selection as per the scene requirement so far but YT is muting the songs now (copyright issue) - started muting it somewhere around episode 65 or so... so if it's not an original score created for the show, I can't hear anything...

<font color="#0000ff">Oh! that is a pity! The background score really adds to the scenes. I wonder how Ishq bulava, mere maula maula, sindori rang suhaagan sacha etc, were not blocked but the ones after 65 are</font>





Oh btw, the songs came back on after 20 eps of silence so I get the full feel now. Beautiful song selections to fit the situations... 😊

bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: ARCH21

Ok so after ages, there's an Indian show that has me hooked. Thankfully, I don't have to wait for the next day to follow the story but dangerously, because I don't have to wait, I can't seem to wait either 😃
Had a 3 day business trip this week but still caught up on eps at airport lounges and after dinners...
It's working as a stress buster 😊

My most favourite character is Cabir. I love how natural his characterization, mannerisms, being the mirror to his friends (especially Manik) without any judgement, always having his friend's back and just laying it out as it is... This is what friendship is all about. V are most fortunate to hv such friendships in life and I hv some friends who would just blindly do if I asked for something, hv my back and then tell me later in private if they thought it was wrong but they would do it anyways because I asked - blessed.

Alia-dhruv - very good characterization there. both held by shadows of what they had - best friend/first attraction and BF. Totally get their feeling of betrayal as they come to know the truth of Manik-Nandini. Aptly portrayed. The insecurities and mixed emotions due to this and the growing feelings towards each other - very natural.

Mukti - I am not convinced of the Abhimanyu angle but this is a broken girl living with the hurt of a relationship that was broken brutally. Abhimanyu is a good catalyst to her healing while she decides to be with him in his little time.

Fab 5 - the whole situation of feeling something is going on between Manik-Nandini, the anger at not being included in this truth, the guarding of boundaries when seeing there is someone new entering the fab 5 circle - Friend groups defined right.
My most favorite moment is when Manik leaves his performance to go look for Nandini and the 3 guys in Fab 5 realise Manik loves Nandini. Cabir backing up his Friend when the others are screaming 'why didn't he tell us'... Loved Cabir's 'because he hasn't recognised his feelings yet. He hasn't put a name to it yet.' That was just perfect. Talk about a Friend knowing you better than you might want to see yourself and standing by you.
Cabir's acknowledgement of Nandini. His always being straight with her just because he knows his friend's feelings - I love this characterization.
Loved the scene where Nandini sneaks into the car and reaches Soha's Farmhouse... and Cabir spots her, brings her to his room. The easy acceptance of what she told him and the best - When Manik comes in, very coolly bringing out Nandini, introducing the 2 and just leaving them to themselves. He simply trusted Nandini for what she was saying just because she is important to Manik.
I would do exactly the same if it was one of my friends...

The lovebirds - the whole equation has turned very relatable. Manik does what Nandini says but he's not changed as a person. He's just included her in his thought process. Nandini is young and this is love's first brush and I like that she doesn't get carried away but stays true to herself.
Loved nandini's realization that she loves him. She finally defined her feelings and the change in body language, need for closeness and just soaking the moment in - beautiful.
Loved manik's realization. It was a stressful moment and when in deep crisis, mind has a knack of reaching the truth.

best is the dialogues are all natural. They don't keep mouthing big philosophies, they talk regular simple stuff that we might when with friends or loved one... They don't overly moon over each other, neither are throwing heavy words; they just flow with normal life. I would think this would be most difficult to write. To keep things regular without making it boring!

Chemistry - natural is the word that comes to mind. I don't want to say sizzling because if 2 people are attracted towards each other, there should be sparks and that's what I see so - natural.
And you can't just have emotional/mental attraction without physical attraction.
It's nice to see this shown the way it is without the flying dupattas and dreamy sequences.

I even like Navya for her simplicity and strength. Good characterization here.

I liked that they are touching on youth issues - drugs/depression, pregnancy, gay... and playing it out without being preachy.

I hope one day the youth shows & General entertainment shows dissolve the worlds they seem to be operating within and bring in each other's issues in their stories. Showing youth issues on a youth channel doesn't get parents involved and continuing with the saas-bahu equation (or whatever is happening in our home show) just widens the crevice between youth reality & older generation mindset. The youth will simply grow up to be confused adults - talk about promoting generation gap!
No wonder the mainstream channels seem to write such confused stories... They don't know what to do with their progressive characters so easy way out - turn regressive.

One thing I noticed is that some situations are same as our home show (being at cross-roads between friends & love, the thought of leaving love for Friend and few more) but this show handled all of these very well so far. Nandini telling him 'what if something else happens with your friends and you leave me again'... Manik telling Nandini he is at a cross-road and Nandini knowing how imp his friends are - understanding. She telling him 'follow your heart' and he does just that... He follows his heart. Plans out everything so the album goes ahead (that he knows is imp to his friends) and being there himself to protect Nandini... He doesn't need to leave one for the other but you can balance both if your heart is in the right place...
Wish our home show had walked the path of logic!

Ok! So after this long 'what I loved' post, you can see am totally in and loving the show 😃
I lost count of the episode numbers... It's just in YT autoplay 😃


Loved what you wrote above and will respond in detail shortly...

I see that you are somewhere in the 130s which is why you are commenting on the most recent storyline...

Since Malvika is yet to catch up, don't want to ruin it for her but I so want to discuss one of my favourite phases in the show in detail I.e. the episodes 70 to 120 odd, especially the ones after break up..
Edited by bookworm123 - 9 years ago
Curlyhairdiary thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#37
Girls, dont stop on my account. I have reached somewhere in the 60s. Start discussing. I won't check up on this thread till I cross a substantial number of episodes, if thats what it takes 😊
ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: bookworm123



Loved what you wrote above and will respond in detail shortly...

I see that you are somewhere in the 130s which is why you are commenting on the most recent storyline...

Since Malvika is yet to catch up, don't want to ruin it for her but I so want to discuss one of my favourite phases in the show in detail I.e. the episodes 70 to 120 odd, especially the ones after break up..



I sure am loving it... 😊

There are so many instances now when I felt 'satisfied' (yup, that's the feeling) while watching how the particular sequence played out. Nothing dramatic and keeping things simple, the emotions have been brought out well... Looking back, am even liking nandini's drunken cuteness. Didn't like it much then but now as things moved on, I look back to the scene with them on the car bonnet and manik's expression when Nandini says 'then stay with me forever and I will shine for you'... He worked the relationship how he knew life - give & take. Him asking for forgiveness - I will do this then you have to forgive me etc... But loved Nandini's quiet strength and clarity on relationships - it's no give & take. It just is!

They have shown some of the usual silliness but with how they are showing all relationships, am ignoring the cliched silliness... It's worth just flowing with the characters...

Which phase are you referring to??

ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: Malvika07

Girls, dont stop on my account. I have reached somewhere in the 60s. Start discussing. I won't check up on this thread till I cross a substantial number of episodes, if thats what it takes 😊



Hahaha... Nah! If we comment here, don't avoid it as long as it doesn't spoil the suspense for you ...
Somewhere in the 60's is around break-up I think... As @bookworm pointed out earlier, the story really takes off after now...
Would love to hear your thoughts as you see through this phase... At least these episodes are worth talking about than our once-lovely home show...
Curlyhairdiary thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: ARCH21



Hahaha... Nah! If we comment here, don't avoid it as long as it doesn't spoil the suspense for you ...
Somewhere in the 60's is around break-up I think... As
@bookworm pointed out earlier, the story rea,lly takes off after now...
Would love to hear your thoughts as you see through this phase... At least these episodes are worth talking about than our once-lovely home show...


Actually reading your discussions enriches my experience of watching the show. Looking forward to watching the break up phase now.
. 😊 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".