a question! - Page 12

Created

Last reply

Replies

143

Views

10.6k

Users

38

Likes

762

Frequent Posters

deepi04 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
deepi04
na na, logic kabhi kabaar nikalta hai EK ki shows mein 😆 I thought Jallu's actions in the 4th April outburst were very logical. Any man with the slightest hint of knowledge about logic would be able to put two (midnight strolls to an unknown man in a hut) and two (bhaashans on kartavye, no love + lies about the midnight strolls) together and react like Jallu did, albeit for 16th century standards it should have been much worse.

Seee that's exactly what I'm saying, her dialogues and how she is portrayed are hardly ever in sync 😆 we are not shown any love, only kartavye dialogues on repeat and suddenly they change it to 'prem' 😕 why are we forced to listen to prem dialogues if this 'prem' was never shown 😡


@bold Yes u r right deepi👏 ... jallus outburst was justified ... n he being a 16th century king was far too liberal with jodha ... by giving her the freedom to bring kanha to agra & by not converting ... i dont think any other kings would have given such liberty to any wives ...rather rajput kings were very rigid in their cultures & manner's & not that liberal ... n no rajput would come begging to forgive for the act where the wife is equally responsible for a MU... this spoil brat jodha is lucky 😡

She should be thankful to her kanha for giving such a considerate husband in 16th century... what was jo expecting from jalal that even after midnight walks with a stranger he will come & fall at her feet thanking her for saving his life 😡 ... indeed that also came true ... he did fall at her feet with folded hands n still this arrogant female didnt give a damn !!!😡 even if she had married suryabhan & if some MU like this had happened.. i bet he would not have cared for once who she is & would have thrown her out of the palace & his life without a second thought ... forget about begging forgivence !!!




Jallu has always been liberal, broad-minded, unprejudiced and lenient. iss liye sab uska faida utha the hai 😒

They were indeed very firm and inflexible; the amount of freedom Jo got in Agra, she never ever had, or would have gotten had she married into a Rajput family. And any Rajvanshi husband, no matter how lattoo he is over her, will not run after her crying and begging, and will not fake his death, especially when she is the reason the MU happened and she isn't accepting her faults. Suryabhan would have killed her probably 😆
Edited by deepi04 - 11 years ago
knumnum thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Hiii Mandy,

I know I am late to the party. Everyone said everything that needs to be said.

Jeans and dips and everyone, U ppl said it all 👏

I wud like to add only few things, Viewers will connect to a scene by the dialogues and by the actors' expressions.

In Jodha's case, we get neither which is why its becoming hard to understand where she s coming from in terms of loving Jalal.

For Ex, in the telepathic nightmare scene, she got the dialogues, but her expressions neither convey tat urgency nor the worried state.

In the same track, Ruks is also shown standing in balcony and missing Jalal. This we were able to connect becos the actress did a gud job in emoting. And same goes for MA.

And if u guys remember the scene where Jalal gives his head gear and coat to Jodha in Amer fort track to feel wat he goes thro being a shehenshah, tat scene warranted her to show sympathy and feel the pressure he s going thro. But at the end of the scene, all u get is an arrogant female who only insults him for being a shehenshah as if its Jalal's mistake for being born as shehenshah And in the same scene, Jalal comes out as person who knows wat he s missing in his life being a shehenshah but still doesnt want to accept pity.

This show of multi layered expressions is very much missing in Jodha from the beginning. So I wud say everything went wrong for the character Jodha (dialogues, expressions, characterization etc)

The only emotional scene where I think Jodha got everything right was drinking poison scene (there myt be a few more but I dnt remember now).

So, as long as we don't have the supporting acts leading to the prem dialogues, we ll forever bang our heads this way to determine whether Jodha loves Jalal or not.
Edited by knumnum - 11 years ago
sunshine_sun thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: knumnum

Hiii Mandy,


I know I am late to the party. Everyone said everything that needs to be said.

Jeans and dips and everyone, U ppl said it all 👏

I wud like to add only few things, Viewers will connect to a scene by the dialogues and by the actors' expressions.

In Jodha's case, we get neither which is why its becoming hard to understand where she s coming from in terms of loving Jalal.

For Ex, in the telepathic nightmare scene, she got the dialogues, but her expressions neither convey tat urgency nor the worried state.

In the same track, Ruks is also shown standing in balcony and missing Jalal. This we were able to connect becos the actress did a gud job in emoting. And same goes for MA.

And if u guys remember the scene where Jalal gives his head gear and coat to Jodha in Amer fort track to feel wat he goes thro being a shehenshah, tat scene warranted her to show sympathy and feel the pressure he s going thro. But at the end of the scene, all u get is an arrogant female who only insults him for being a shehenshah as if its Jalal's mistake for being born as shehenshah And in the same scene, Jalal comes out as person who knows wat he s missing in his life being a shehenshah but still doesnt want to accept pity.

This show of multi layered expressions is very much missing in Jodha from the beginning. So I wud say everything went wrong for the character Jodha (dialogues, expressions, characterization etc)

The only emotional scene where I think Jodha got everything right was drinking poison scene (there myt be a few more but I dnt remember now).

So, as long as we don't have the supporting acts leading to the prem dialogues, we ll forever bang our heads this way to determine whether Jodha loves Jalal or not.

agreed with all u have said ...since m no basher of any characters unnecessarily🥱..i want to add one scene in favour of jodha . The scene goes like this ; After she drank n came to life rukaiiya says u can ask for anything but shehenshah n the way she side glance n wiped her tears thats the jodha i want thats the jo is missing after badal kajri track 😭. Her adhik prem ..uff really i know one thing we cant leave everything to speculation n kuch actions hona chhahye to prove ur adhik prem . The whole thing gone wrong ..well dont want to bring that topic but bear me pls santaram paridhi riff. I still believe yehan kuch gadbadh hui n hence the results bcz she proved herself as a good actress ..emoting scenes for her shall not be a problem . Isnt ??
😕 Im sorry if i digressed from the topic . I love them both equally but somehow i cud not realte with jodha anymore ..but nevertheless time will tell😃
Edited by sunshine_sun - 11 years ago
knumnum thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: sunshine_sun

agreed with all u have said ...since m no basher of any characters unnecessarily🥱..i want to add one scene in favour of jodha . The scene goes like this ; After she drank n came to life rukaiiya says u can ask for anything but shehenshah n the way she side glance n wiped her tears thats the jodha i want thats the jo is missing after badal kajri track 😭. Her adhik prem ..uff really i know one thing we cant leave everything to speculation n kuch actions hona chhahye to prove ur adhik prem . The whole thing gone wrong ..well dont want to bring that topic but bear me pls santaram paridhi riff. I still believe yehan kuch gadbadh hui n hence the results bcz she proved herself as a good actress ..emoting scenes for her shall not be a problem . Isnt ??
😕 Im sorry if i digressed from the topic . I love them both equally but somehow i cud not realte with jodha anymore ..but nevertheless time will tell😃


No problem wid wat u said Hema🤗. Even everyone here wants to see heart touching performances of Jalal-Jodha. No one wants to see the half baked performances😆.

So keep up the hope👍🏼 One day, we might get wat we are missing😃
shiningways2407 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: sunshine_sun

agreed with all u have said ...since m no basher of any characters unnecessarily🥱..i want to add one scene in favour of jodha . The scene goes like this ; After she drank n came to life rukaiiya says u can ask for anything but shehenshah n the way she side glance n wiped her tears thats the jodha i want thats the jo is missing after badal kajri track😭. Her adhik prem ..uff really i know one thing we cant leave everything to speculation n kuch actions hona chhahye to prove ur adhik prem . The whole thing gone wrong ..well dont want to bring that topic but bear me pls santaram paridhi riff. I still believe yehan kuch gadbadh hui n hence the results bcz she proved herself as a good actress ..emoting scenes for her shall not be a problem . Isnt ??
😕Im sorry if i digressed from the topic . I love them both equally but somehow i cud not realte with jodha anymore ..but nevertheless time will tell😃

santa is nomore directing her, codirectors direct her solo scenes!! But first n foremost question is who is her dialogues writer?? 😡 they never let her come out of kartavya mode!! Krishi di mentioned in one of the post that jodha said kartavya after drinking poison n person doesnt say lie while he/she is on death bed,which I totally agree, so I seriously want to know who is her writer. Seriously speaking agar us time jodha ko kartavya mode se uturn dete to aaj story epic k aas paas jaroor hota (from both side n notjust from jalal's side) I liked jodha's character (as a wife) from vishpan's end till boat ride scene. But as of now while watching this show I couldnt connect to her.
sunshine_sun thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shiningways2424

santa is nomore directing her, codirectors direct her solo scenes!! But first n foremost question is who is her dialogues writer?? 😡 they never let her come out of kartavya mode!! Krishi di mentioned in one of the post that jodha said kartavya after drinking poison n person doesnt say lie while he/she is on death bed,which I totally agree, so I seriously want to know who is her writer. Seriously speaking agar us time jodha ko kartavya mode se uturn dete to aaj story epic k aas paas jaroor hota (from both side n notjust from jalal's side) I liked jodha's character (as a wife) from vishpan's end till boat ride scene. But as of now while watching this show I couldnt connect to her.

So these r the professionals 😡😡 .Itna professional k lead heroine ko beech bazaar mein chodh diya 😡
shiningways2407 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: sunshine_sun


So these r the professionals😡😡.Itna professional k lead heroine ko beech bazaar mein chodh diya😡


nope it was mutual deal b/w all three when quitting scenerio came, thats what I read somewhere few weeks ago. (all credit goes to soap queen 😡 she has adhik prem for her female leads)
Edited by shiningways2424 - 11 years ago
sunshine_sun thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
The soap Queen just kept her just for the sake of keeping her...professionalism is in heights wow 👏😡.
Kya koi joke hai 😡🤢
shiningways2407 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: sunshine_sun

The soap Queen just kept her just for the sake of keeping her...professionalism is in heights wow👏😡.

Kya koi joke hai😡🤢


yup professionalism reaches its zenith amidst all controversy!! 🤣🤣
i have become fan/ cooler/ ac of such professionalism
skandi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
till now i never connected with jodha character, she always showed dual personality...😕😕...on that suddenly she is saying she wants to correct her mistake after seeing her people are happy with jallu...😲😲😲...what the hell this...this type of love is never called epic love or love story...she is always in the mode of changing her husband she never fell in love with real person...she fell in love after he changed according to her...😕...she always does what she wants never what her husband or other wants...drank posion to prove that she was right and told everyone that she is doing her duty...😕...if they show from tmw that she is in love with him...I think this CV people are certainly gone mad...😡...if they have to connect audience with jodha they have to show jodha falling in love with him from now on like they showed about jallu...rest left to this CV, who have the capacity of showing love of a man and changing a man because of his love to his wife but they lack the capacity of showing a women's love and changing for her husband in love...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".