Adiana, this is an excellent example, but you do remember what happened to Renuka Devi, don't you?
For those new to this story, she saw the reflection of a gandharva in the river and was attracted to him for an instant. Till then, the
kachcha ghadas she used to make daily would hold water without being baked, due to the power of her
paativratyam. This day, the
kachcha ghada disintegrated in the water and she could not carry the river water back for her husband's morning pooja. That was how he found out about her momentary lapse.
Parasurama was commanded by his father to execute his mother with his
parashu (axe) as the only befitting punishment for her moral transgression. He obeyed,though he loved his mother very much, and his father was so pleased with his implicit obedience that he granted him any boon he wanted. Parasurama promptly asked for his mother's life to be restored and that was duly done.
See how easy Jodha has had it here! I liked the film version infinitely better.
As as for your analysis. Adiana, it is spot on.
Shyamala/Aunty
Originally posted by: adianasr
You all must have read the story of Renuka Devi, the mother of Bhagawan Parashuram and wife of Rishi Jamadagni??? She also had a moment when she was attracted to another - just becoz a person has been honest, has shown integrity or chastity - that does not mean, something like this cannot happen - and Indian and Hindu belief does provide space for such narratives too - hence, saying that Jodha, having shown integrity and loyalty, makes her above falling in Love lacks strength.
Since she has never told Jalal that she is in love with him and has always called him a duty, it is not surprising that he thought what he did - hence we cannot absolve Jodha of her part - and now if we want to shift all the blame to Jalal - that in my eyes is a gross travesty of justice - that is not equality - that is not what I as a woman approve - I would have had sympathy for her if her letter had been a better display of justice, that is all I have to add.
Edited by sashashyam - 11 years ago
365