had jodha not forgiven BB........ - Page 5

Originally posted by: lashy

Perfectly stated Sunny! 👏 and like you I'm part of this seeming to be ever-dwindling minority too 😆

Originally posted by: ashpat

same here. I am here for Akdha and their epic love story.

Originally posted by: minnie2308

Well I have always seen we like and appreciate people we identify more with...

Ru is an absolutely unfair character who makes no bones about taking unfair advantage of anything...Pardon me but she has displayed next to zero depth in terms of behaviour and understanding. She'll never be the first to say she is in love for fear of rejection-- She is scared of rejection, not with lack of love.

Watching her interact with Jalal looks like he is doing a great service, a chore, handling a responsibility, which he is not enjoying. With Jo even the worst of times, the interaction appears like a challenge, that Jalal is enjoying...

Jo is a stubborn, forthright, crystal-clear woman who is clear about the identity of the proverbial spade. According to Jo, where there is love all else follows...Nothing right is going to come out of wrongs...

Originally posted by: prejudiced

1. Her realizing that it was Shareef who had orchestrated the whole thing and Bakshi was doing whatever she did without realizing the repercussions.. Not that this made BB innocent, but her crime a lot less severe.

She did realize the repercussions...they even showed a scene of her asking Shareef not to do this because it might lead to his death

2. When Jodha passed by Bakshi, she realized the woman was repenting her deed... staying aloof...which in her eyes was a form of self imposed punishment.

No Anu...BB on the contrary clearly said if it came to it again - she'd do the same thing...where is this repentance?😆

3. Somewhere Jodha realized that meting out punishment to BB would actually end up being a punishment for HB and Jalaal.

This is the only argument that might hold good dear...but, if Shareef strikes again...using BB as a scapegoat...then hasn't she ended up hurting Jalal/HB more? 🤔

That talk abt love and what one does in love, well we all share the same thought...

A tad unbelievable that Jodha would gain so much wisdom...😆😆😆

Anu this decision of her's showed she didn't use the judicious wisdom she should have been using...😕

Originally posted by: lashy

Originally posted by: lashy

I can't speak for others...but, had Jodha actually punished BB (as in by punishment I mean - banishment or isolation) I WOULD have admired her... 😊 just like I admired her when she used her feminine tricks to emotionally sway the Shehenshah in that act during Sukanya's wedding...

Jodha is an Empress...there is only so much you can let go or give...anything beyond shall not be called selfless, only ignorance!

What she did is politically not right (the same can be said of Jalal too) - to give it a reasoning of love does not mean its right... Then all crimes of love/passion today can be justified (by Jodha's reasoning)

Had BB's actions successfully ended up killing Jodha - or making her terminally ill - would you still stick by 'forgiving-BB-is-right' since she had done so in the name of love?

When Jodha took long to forgive her own mother (for just advising her harshly in court) and hasn't yet forgiven Sujamal (for actually demanding a kingdom that originally belonged to his father) - how is she expecting Jalal to forgive BB for trying to defame/banish/assassinate Jodha and betray him? Isn't the latter crime the worst of the lot? 🤔

Think of all these points without the mindset of which character your prefer and then you'd understand why this argument doesn't hold true...

Just as much as I'm disappointed with Jalal (and his forces) for not catching Shareef's mideeds yet, I'm disappointed with Jodha for letting go of a criminal scot-free and justifying the horrible crime committed with the reasoning of love.

Originally posted by: stuti123

hey guys i read many comments saying that it was very silly of jodha to forgive BB and her justication for this about BB 'S love for her husband was even sillier ..soo my question is that had jodha not forgiven BB and given her some punishment instead so would she have been correct ..or again people would have to say that no how can she do this it very insensitive and selfish on her part ...the fact remains that no matter whatever jodha does she will always be the ONE at fault ....even if she does something good it will be brushed under the carpet...sad but true...

For me, Jalal did not ask Jodha to make a decision regarding BB's punishment because Jodha is his queen. He asked her to decide the punishment because she was the victim of the crime. As the crime was committed against her and not anyone else and the king gave her the right to decide the punishment in this instance it is her right to forgive or punish.

If it had been two subjects coming in front of Jodha and the victim is demanding justice from the queen then it would have been a different story. I think if this is the case Jodha would have given a punishment befitting the crime. That is not what happened here.

I also think Jalal made the right decision by punishing BB because as the king he can't be seen as favouring his family even though the victim of the crime decided to forgive the perpetrator.

If I am the Jodha, I would have asked BB to get a psych evaluation to see if she is all right in the head 😆 followed by years of intense therapy 😆but in the case as the victim of the crime it was Jodha's decision to make not as a member of the royal family but as the victim of the crime.

Anyways, that's my take on the whole fiasco. 😃