had jodha not forgiven BB........ - Page 4

Originally posted by: minnie2308

nope you are not unfair...you are drameybaaz

Originally posted by: lashy

Seee Minooo...mein utni bhi unfair nahin hoon

Originally posted by: elasingh

Consciously, I'd try never to be unfair...

Many-a-time have come under fire for that in reality too!😊

Edited by lashy - 11 years ago

Originally posted by: elasingh

matlab kuch unfair toh ho...khud hi qubool kar liya...😛

Originally posted by: Cleo12345

I am glad that I am not the only one to be turned of by incessant negativity... I wouldn't mind it if the posts were intelligently written... I wrote a very civil( feel free to read it) to a very popular ( forum only...thank God) writer and made a plea to avoid bashing a community/ clan/ caste as a part of her anti Jodha rant...I looked for traces of intelligence and logic in the answer that was posted in response to my plea...didn't have any...I read the forum rules again and the language used this writer against some characters as well as a community...clearly breaking the rules according to me... and wrote to the forum managers to with my request ... No response from them either .

I plan to continue on the forum( unless they cancel my membership) and continue to post civil, positive and honest posts.

To me this is not about a character or caste/ community/ religion.

It is about not exploiting the ' freedom of expression' to push my thoughts and beliefs on others and presenting an unbiased and honest opinion of characters and facts from the show.

Honest comments and healthy criticism is welcome. Sick negativity , opinionated behavior and illogical explanations to bash a character or community should be strongly discouraged.

I hope the forum managers/ directors take notice and do something about it. At least acknowledge that the request was received . Reading the forum rules again will be useful. Thanks!

Originally posted by: lashy

I can't speak for others...but, had Jodha actually punished BB (as in by punishment I mean - banishment or isolation) I WOULD have admired her... 😊 just like I admired her when she used her feminine tricks to emotionally sway the Shehenshah in that act during Sukanya's wedding...

Jodha is an Empress...there is only so much you can let go or give...anything beyond shall not be called selfless, only ignorance!

What she did is politically not right (the same can be said of Jalal too) - to give it a reasoning of love does not mean its right... Then all crimes of love/passion today can be justified (by Jodha's reasoning)

Had BB's actions successfully ended up killing Jodha - or making her terminally ill - would you still stick by 'forgiving-BB-is-right' since she had done so in the name of love?

When Jodha took long to forgive her own mother (for just advising her harshly in court) and hasn't yet forgiven Sujamal (for actually demanding a kingdom that originally belonged to his father) - how is she expecting Jalal to forgive BB for trying to defame/banish/assassinate Jodha and betray him? Isn't the latter crime the worst of the lot? 🤔

Think of all these points without the mindset of which character your prefer and then you'd understand why this argument doesn't hold true...

Just as much as I'm disappointed with Jalal (and his forces) for not catching Shareef's mideeds yet, I'm disappointed with Jodha for letting go of a criminal scot-free and justifying the horrible crime committed with the reasoning of love.

Originally posted by: lashy

Dear that is politics for you...didn't her own father banish Sujamal (her own dearest brother) when he committed treason... she understood that bit, didn't she? Politics/law/judgement mein rishte nahin dekhe jaate...then you'll be favouring your own..

tomorrow if a commoner did the same crime and this got reported to the king, will Jodha/Jalal be able to let him/her go scot-free because it was committed out of blind love?

If they punished him, he can object that they let the Emperor's sister go...

If they didnt' punish him, then many many more people will start committing the same misdeed

After all, aren't all crimes committed due to some form of love/obsession - be it love for power, love for money or love for a human!

Its not a small mistake that BB can be pardoned once or twice and reprimanded...its a crime that could have actually led to changing the course of two royals and with it an Empire and thus thousands of people!

(what if Jalal in his rage against Jodha's adultery decided to take action by taking away support from Amer)then, other rajvanshis would have attacked. It would have led to loss of thousands of lives in war etc etc

Originally posted by: Cleo12345

Very well written indeed. I love Jodha's character but cannot come to her deference on this matter. Like you, I also don't agree with these emotional arguments. They are the royal family and have a responsibility to set up an example . There is difference between Abdul's and Bakshi Bano's pardon. Killing a incapacitated person was against the Ameri ( or was it Rajput?) code of conduct. Dont think that same will apply to Bakshi Bano in a Mughal court. In my opinion, she should have been punished.

I don't buy the fact that Jodha suddenly acquired so much knowledge and understanding about love. I think she did for Jalal's happiness and to get over her own guilt of misunderstanding Jalal. Even then, her action cannot be justified when you look at it from a neutral prospective.

Originally posted by: lashy

Ok Nabii...😳

then tomorrow, a commoner from the kingdom commits the same crime and the victim approaches the king and queen for justice...what would your answer as Jodha be then?

Would you support the victim who's asking for justice

or

Tthe criminal (who justifies that he/she did it in the name of love) - seeing how BB has been pardoned?

If she let the criminal go again, then what would happen if the victim pays for it one day with his/her life...hasn't the king/queen indirectly become responsible for that victim's death?