Jodha Akbar 100: Curiously unsatisfactory - Page 2

Originally posted by: elasingh

Paathittu vandu sollu Shyamala...

Awww aunty...

Sorry I don't want to offend you in anyway..after reading your reply on my thread about the one issue that possibly irked you the most - I reflected on it all for a while and then went online to do some reading.

Strangely enough even for people who suffer from acute/severe hypothermia in temperatures you are referring to (i.e. who are in a state of unconsciousness and whose body heat is diminishing, pulse is falling etc) - the treatment suggested in most medical websites (NHS/Webmed etc) is of warm blanket wrapping😕...

It doesn't state anywhere that skin-to-skin hugging is more efficient at restoring a person's body temperature than blanket & hugging...(I thought skin hugging is better too) Some websites state that it can be done, but nowhere has it been specified that it would be more efficient at reviving a person THAN wrapping them up in dry warm clothes...

I agree the 'BLACK' cloth makes little sense though...anyway, most websites seem to emphasize on dry warm clothes...and if that doesn't work then seedha 911...😆 If its only the black you are referring to then yes I agree with you ...but, warm blankets themselves are the main advised mode of treatment...😊

So, maybe Jo was suffering from moderate Hypothermia (where people get delirious and their vital signs are slipping away) In severe, they're nearly comatose and chances of surviving even with modern medicine is touch and go apparently😕!

One excerpt from a website...

Mild hypothermia: 90-95 degrees

Moderate hypothermia: 82-90 degrees

Severe hypothermia: Lower than 82 degrees

Since response to hypothermia varies among individuals, temperatures may differ.

What Is the Treatment for Hypothermia?

Hypothermia is a potentially life-threatening condition that needs emergency medical attention.

If medical care isn't immediately available:

• Remove any wet clothes, hats, gloves, shoes, and socks.
• Protect the person against wind, drafts, and further heat loss with warm, dry clothes and blankets.
• Move gently to a warm, dry shelter as soon as possible.
• Begin rewarming the person with extra clothing. Use warm blankets. Other helpful items for warming are: an electric blanket to the torso area and hot packs and heating pad on the torso, armpits, neck, and groin; however, these can cause burns to the skin. Use your own body heat if nothing else is available.
• Take the person's temperature if a thermometer is available.
• Offer warm liquids, but avoid alcohol and caffeine, which speed up heat loss. Don't try to give fluids to an unconscious person.

The Kala Vastra: e of the CVs. I was falling off my chair for laughing.

It was LUDICROUS. A black cloth, or even a black blanket, cannot generate heat, which was what was needed. Jodha's half frozen body had no heat to conserve. What was needed was an external source of heat. That is why the Khwaja recommended her husband hugging her tight to transfer HIS body warmth to her. And if not body heat, there could have been the Mughal equivalent of brandy, plus a blazing fire. Neither of which needed Jalal .

But how on earth can a black cloth wrapping thaw out a frozen body? This kind of nonsense is an insult to the intelligence of the viewers. And obviously none of the CVs has done even an elementary course in physics!😉

Having said all of this, this logic still seems more acceptable than the MC body double and talaaq fiasco to me...😆

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Yethai patthittu? Illai paditthuvitta? Allathu netri kathayai parthuvitta?

Seriously, Ela, I was taken completely aback! Aap bhi, aapki chahaiti Jodha Begun ki hi tarah, hunar ki khaan ho!

Shyamala

Originally posted by: september12

Originally posted by: munnirony

Awsum analysis aunty. I was initially happy about jalal's gesture yesterday. But when I gave it a 2nd thought I felt no reason can be big enough to leave ur throne. Nd to be very frank why should he? He havnt done anything wrong. On Friday i loved his answers to both jodha nd the malvis. But today how can he give up so easily? Nd about jodha wht can I say. Jalal was ready to give up his throne for her but she seemed to be least bothered. At least she should have stood up nd stopped him. Both jalal nd jodha should have firmly said tht neither jodha will convert nor jalal will leave his throne.

As per HB's plan goes wht if the messenger haven't reached at time? I think she should have directly conveyed tht the messenger is on his way. If evryone respects salim chisti's words so much then im sure malvis would have waited. HB's intentions were obviously pure but her plan had loopholes.

Originally posted by: lashy

Awww aunty...

Sorry I don't want to offend you in anyway..after reading your reply on my thread about the one issue that possibly irked you the most - I reflected on it all for a while and then went online to do some reading.

Strangely enough even for people who suffer from acute/severe hypothermia in temperatures you are referring to (i.e. who are in a state of unconsciousness and whose body heat is diminishing, pulse is falling etc) - the treatment suggested in most medical websites (NHS/Webmed etc) is of warm blanket wrapping😕...

It doesn't state anywhere that skin-to-skin hugging is more efficient at restoring a person's body temperature than blanket & hugging...(I thought skin hugging is better too) Some websites state that it can be done, but nowhere has it been specified that it would be more efficient at reviving a person THAN wrapping them up in dry warm clothes...

I agree the 'BLACK' cloth makes little sense though...anyway, most websites seem to emphasize on dry warm clothes...and if that doesn't work then seedha 911...😆 If its only the black you are referring to then yes I agree with you ...but, warm blankets themselves are the main advised mode of treatment...😊

So, maybe Jo was suffering from moderate Hypothermia (where people get delirious and their vital signs are slipping away) In severe, they're nearly comatose and chances of surviving even with modern medicine is touch and go apparently😕!

One excerpt from a website...

Mild hypothermia: 90-95 degrees

Moderate hypothermia: 82-90 degrees

Severe hypothermia: Lower than 82 degrees

Since response to hypothermia varies among individuals, temperatures may differ.

What Is the Treatment for Hypothermia?

Hypothermia is a potentially life-threatening condition that needs emergency medical attention.

If medical care isn't immediately available:

• Remove any wet clothes, hats, gloves, shoes, and socks.
• Protect the person against wind, drafts, and further heat loss with warm, dry clothes and blankets.
• Move gently to a warm, dry shelter as soon as possible.
• Begin rewarming the person with extra clothing. Use warm blankets. Other helpful items for warming are: an electric blanket to the torso area and hot packs and heating pad on the torso, armpits, neck, and groin; however, these can cause burns to the skin. Use your own body heat if nothing else is available.
• Take the person's temperature if a thermometer is available.
• Offer warm liquids, but avoid alcohol and caffeine, which speed up heat loss. Don't try to give fluids to an unconscious person.

The Kala Vastra: e of the CVs. I was falling off my chair for laughing.

It was LUDICROUS. A black cloth, or even a black blanket, cannot generate heat, which was what was needed. Jodha's half frozen body had no heat to conserve. What was needed was an external source of heat. That is why the Khwaja recommended her husband hugging her tight to transfer HIS body warmth to her. And if not body heat, there could have been the Mughal equivalent of brandy, plus a blazing fire. Neither of which needed Jalal .

But how on earth can a black cloth wrapping thaw out a frozen body? This kind of nonsense is an insult to the intelligence of the viewers. And obviously none of the CVs has done even an elementary course in physics!😉

Having said all of this, this logic still seems more acceptable than the MC body double and talaaq fiasco to me...😆