My dear Mansi,
You are like a pep up pill first thing in the morning. Thank you!
As for the mahal, it will come soon, I think, for the CVs cannot fudge that. There has to be a separate Krishna mandir in a separate palace, not because there were both there in the Fatehpur Sikri complex., but because they will need both for the prasad scene. That scene will be far more important as a milestone in this much harsher and more confrontational Jalal-Jodha relationship than it was in the film.So the palace will come, never fear. For now, the bewildered harem will be treated to Krishna bhajans, Ruqaiya in the first place! As for the rest, your explanation is spot on.
You seem to have very wise menfolk in your family. First there was your father, and now your uncle, each so perceptive in his own way. That mirror image take on what Jalal said to Jodha is, I too think, exactly what is going to happen.
As I wrote to Meghana above, in Jalal's reaction to Jodha, there is one thing on the surface - his being attracted to her because of her beauty and because she does not fawn on him - and there is a different undercurrent as well, of which he is not conscious as of now. That is the strange pull that dragged him on a very dangerous mission into Amer, and this when he had not even seen her.
Right now, he will be more and more angry with her for the immediate future, and I am waiting to see when it dawns on him that what he wants is not
her. Not the possession of her, legally or physically even, for if he sought the latter, she, as a dutiful, wedded wife, will not refuse her husband that intimacy. What he will want is for her to want
him, in the sense of caring for him, even if the idea of love is very long in coming.
Now he can, soon enough, command her dutiful obedience in all acceptable things. but not her respect and her caring. This will gnaw at him, and we shall see how he handles that entirely unfamiliar situation. This exactly where your uncle's wisdom comes in. No one can protect him from that sense of deprivation that will eat away at him from within. It is going to be very interesting.
Shyamala
Originally posted by: skanda12
Shyamala:
Awesome post again! 👏👏👏What a read! It brings back the night's episode in sharp focus on the morning after ... and you cover every nuance of it!
One thing that I want to ask you about: I thought Jalal had planned that Jodha would not live in the harem but would get her own mahal? So how come she has been housed in the harem?
I am assuming that we have to imagine:
a. Her own mahal is not yet ready (nor her mandir yet)
b. We viewers, via Jodha's eyes, are getting to be shown the real insides of the harem and its politics in the duration that Jodha stays there
c. We are going to have confrontations between Jodha and Ruqqaiya (self-styled harem Field Marshal)
And after a taste of all this we will see perhaps Jodha sashaying to her own mahal?
Is this what you think will happen? Or have the creative conveniently forgotten the separate mahal thing?
Okay one more thing: that bedroom scene of Jalal. Just see this sentence Jalal says to Jodha and then tranverse it and apply it to him. He says "I like seeing that fear of me in your eyes. No one can protect you from me".
Now when he says it, it is his forewarning to her! Just imagine the same words said to him instead. That is the TRUTH! He hates seeing that fear of him in her eyes. And no one can protect him from her!
I used to have a very wise old uncle who revelled in turning things people said against them and he would very often use the same logic as I have done above to show that it is no accident that certain words slip out of certain mouths at certain times. And that very often the truth could be found by simply reapplying the words of the speaker against himself!
Yesterday I remembered that uncle!
Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago
364