Vivian elimination, just in 8th week??

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Titli

@afterlife.

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

#31

Excellent post joseph.. All u have said I dont have anything more to say. I failed to understand whats colors' problem with vd? He has been used widely for their profit then at the end he is humiliated and insulted.. Such a demeaning act. Shame on such biased show n channel.

Quote

DiyaS

@DiyaS

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 9 years ago

#32

Good post, Joseph. Ignoring the voting issue ... which the channel is keep under wraps for their own purposes, and we have no way of knowing what they're doing.

But in the face off, I definitely felt Vivian was better than Raftaar ... I don't know how the judges gave Raftaar more marks for his act. It was messy and confused ... Vivian's act was much better, it was more entertaining, and his dance moves were much cleaner. If his elimination was based on that one act, he deserved to stay and Raftaar should have gone. No offence to Raftaar fans ... on the whole he is a good dancer, but not last night.

Edited by DiyaS - 9 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

charmee

@charmee_sammy

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

#33

bang on post joseph.. I wanted to talk to someone about this injustice.. I wont say I m not a fan of vivian, I watch this show for Sanaya n vivian both.. Nor would I say I felt they were partial to give vivian 40 wen performances were ok but not great .. All that being said I m extremely upset with this injustice.. No one has idea what they are judging, what they comment on performances and at d end what they score bcoz everything is irrelevent.. They give vito power to trained dancers or d ones like Mohit Malik who'd gain sympathy by reciting story of his struggle.. Obviously that power was out of sympathy bcoz they hadnt seen any other performance before his...

anyways coming back to Vivian he definitely has gained our respect... He reached till 8th week solely by his caliber.. And went out as a winner..

Quote

Joseph

@Joseph_A

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: faria86
I'm a huge Drashti fan i got to know VD in MB show as RK & liked him as RK but unfortunately his fans made me stop liking him but i'm a kind of person who can't hate anyone i don't like him but don't hate him too
yes his elimination was really unexpected since he is popular i know his fans are not so keen for voting as i hv seen in MF but i don't think he would go so soon was expecting him at least in top 4/5

honestly Radika's elimination was so unexpected too she has good fan following too but she & VD both were not able to give their best but at the same time both were not suppose to go so soon too bcoz they has good fan following & VD was improving as well

about Mohit he is really good hard working dancer & improving too we can't count only online fans since ppl can do sms votes too & neutral fans see the dance & vote he surely has fans but yeah his fans might be less than VD
as i said neutral fans see the dance & vote

& i'm a neutral not Mohit fan but i hv voted for him twice in JDJ8 seeing the improvement & his hard work
& i hv voted for other contestants to whoever impressed me with their act of the week

Mohit deserve to stay for more weeks i will really respect if we don't point finger on someone else...

it all in show makers hand not in mohit & Raftaar's hand

Hi Faria !
Thanks for sharing your detail take on this Issue. n I truly respect your take on this elimination but,I have some points to clear here.

As I mentioned,I am also not a VD fan,I am just sharing my POV as honest viewers. I never seen Drashti or VD shows so,I am not aware wid their fanbase,Its totally different thing for this issue. Its really a not right place for discuss those things. Nice n Arrogant fanz are part of all Fandom, Its very natural thing that's why, we can't point out to any particular fan Group.

I am just questioning abt Channel policy for 'Elimination of Contestant' because,as per my POV, Its not looking fair in VD case. Its just my take. I am not pointing any other contestant because,they are definitely not responsible for VD elimination.I am pointing Channel doubtful procedure to eliminate a contestant.

Here,I refuse to accept any possibility of Radhika n VD comparison. As per my knowledge ,Radhika was/is a Dance instructor but,we all know that VD was totally new in Dancing. Radhika face off act wid Faisal was also a big reason for her elimination.

My question is still same,How can they compare a trend dancer performance wid untrained dancer performance? If,Makers want to judge all contestant equally,then they should be sign all trend dancers for 'Jhalak' why are they wasting our time??

In my 4th point,I am questioning abt this so called 'Equality'. As a neutral person I feel VD was far better then Raftaar in that 'Jaan ke Liye Dance' act so,Obviously I am not convinced wid Judges decision. He was decently performing a 'Rajnikant' act,how can any1 expect Michal Jackson moves in that performance??

You can take this,I am questioning abt Umpire decision. Because,As a viewer, Its my right.

I didn't say anything abt Mohit so,don't want to drag his name in this topic. If,Fanz are wasting their money n valuable time for save their fav then, they have full right to know abt exact voting position of their favorite.

If,Fan want a clear transparency in this elimination procedure then what is wrong in this wish??

Edited by Joseph_A - 9 years ago

Quote

GoldenEyes

@GoldenEyes

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

#35

You raised very good points!! Things that have been annoying me for awhile now and i am just watching the highlights of the show once in awhile. Although i am Sanaya's and Vivian's fan, i try not to be biased. I have seen others performances, the good ones, and i can also admit when Sanaya and Vivian have not such a good performance. So really Jalak, Judges and Colors have been crap so far!! Lets not start about this years Judges. They are so biased that even a child can see through it.

Quote

Joseph

@Joseph_A

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: NavyaKavya30
Hi Joseph, I stay as far away as I can from this forum but since it's your POST so thought of giving my views...I am NOT a Vivian fan,in fact I don't even LIKE him but his elimination was NOT fair by any standards...If the face off dance was any criteria then his was far...far...superior to Raftar's...If votes were the criteria then I can bet Vivian would have an edge over Raftar any time...so I am really at my wits end to UNDERSTAND this elimination.

P.S . For once last night Vivian really danced and I thoroughly enjoyed it & this is coming from someone who is NOT his fan .

Hi Navya ! Feeling so nice to meet you,after a long time. After 1st epi of 'Jhalak',It's my 2nd day here.

VD elimination in this point,is big question mark for 'Jhalak' n Channel Policy. Viewers are not blind,we can judge a entertaining act because,Its totally visible. 'Immunity Ball' is also a mysterious thing here, to 'justify' Makers last decision.

Quote

SHABLA MUSTAFA

@shabla

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#37

Totally agree wth u...d frst thng whch cam to ma mind aftr watchng jaan ki dance ws VD is gng to b eliminated aftr such a grt perfrmnce...lik really...raftaar act ws just anthr hip hop wth a group...nthng new...bt VD ws really entrtaining...are d judges blind or wht...i hav persnally flt tht votes dnt play much role in jdj...bcz its al jst rigged drama...i will nvr believe tht VD gt less votes thn othrs in bottom...if tre is no value fr public opinion thn wht is d point f keepng ts voting drama in jdj...com on ppl r nt fool...neithr will thy b impressed by some one's sob story...earn respect wth ur hard wrk n b happy abt the lif god gav u instead f shedding tears in a reality shw...tis is d part wre VD kept hs dignity n i am proud f him...

Quote

anitarani

@anitarani

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 9 years ago

#38

Originally posted by: Joseph_A

Hi Faria !
Thanks for sharing your detail take on this Issue. n I truly respect your take on this elimination but,I have some points to clear here.

As I mentioned,I am also not a VD fan,I am just sharing my POV as honest viewers. I never seen Drashti or VD shows so,I am not aware wid their fanbase,Its totally different thing for this issue. Its really a not right place for discuss those things. Nice n Arrogant fanz are part of all Fandom, Its very natural thing that's why, we can't point out to any particular fan Group.

I am just questioning abt Channel policy for 'Elimination of Contestant' because,as per my POV, Its not looking fair in VD case. Its just my take. I am not pointing any other contestant because,they are definitely not responsible for VD elimination.I am pointing Channel doubtful procedure to eliminate a contestant.

Here,I refuse to accept any possibility of Radhika n VD comparison. As per my knowledge ,Radhika was/is a Dance instructor but,we all know that VD was totally new in Dancing. Radhika face off act wid Faisal was also a big reason for her elimination.

My question is still same,How can they compare a trend dancer performance wid untrained dancer performance? If,Makers want to judge all contestant equally,then they should be sign all trend dancers for 'Jhalak' why are they wasting our time??

In my 4th point,I am questioning abt this so called 'Equality'. As a neutral person I feel VD was far better then Raftaar in that 'Jaan ke Liye Dance' act so,Obviously I am not convinced wid Judges decision. He was decently performing a 'Rajnikant' act,how can any1 expect Michal Jackson moves in that performance??

You can take this,I am questioning abt Umpire decision. Because,As a viewer, Its my right.

I didn't say anything abt Mohit so,don't want to drag his name in this topic. If,Fanz are wasting their money n valuable time for save their fav then, they have full right to know abt exact voting position of their favorite.

If,Fan want a clear transparency in this elimination procedure then what is wrong in this wish??

@Joseph... +100

Quote

Anisha_anitan

@Anisha_anitan

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#39

The 3rd point is most imp its really unfair to compare people like si vd with faisal

This ellimanation is weird from start dipika had high score in 2nd and 3rd week shes out no face off no performance and again she dont have fandom like vd but she does have fans who vote. Then comes radz and vd

Anyway what can we expect from colors every year fans vote at awards show yet si hardly wins

Quote

Joseph

@Joseph_A

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: RIMO9013
am so so greatfull to u joseph for this post u said all my words what i wanted to express
all the valid points r summed up in one intellegent post i have nothing more to say
can only thanx u for understanding the unfair treatment has done with him

am a diehard vdian was watching this show for vd now its over for me but i will deffo support si from now on and will pray for her to win the tropyy

Thanks Buddy for your nice compliment. I just tried to share my unbiased take on this entire mess. Unfair would be unfair,no one can justify it. n I am so glad that,max peoples are agree wid my points.

I really wish a GR8 comeback for Viven because,he really deserves a better project on better channel. We'll really miss his Votes appeal for other contestant,It was really unique.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

Vivian elimination, just in 8th week?? - Page 4

Related Topics

Explore Topics