Review Week 2 day 2 updated - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

74

Views

5.9k

Users

28

Likes

176

Frequent Posters

enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: nikita59

I am actually am more excited for KVB and Lauren's performance! I feel these 2 have that power to win this competition! I am a Drashti fan through and through! But, I would really like to see her individuality in the performances. It seems like Salman really isn't giving her that much to perform by herself. I really want that performance from her where she shines through! But, keeping in mind she gets on 3hrs daily, I think she is doing it brilliantly with that! I know that sympathy and all is biased. But, if the judges keep up with the scores they giving to the contestants, I feel that one's practice of how many hours per day should be kept in mind! Because any performance requires a lot of practice and hard work! And, for that one needs time! I am satisfied with her performances so far, putting that many number of hours and still getting an average of 26 or 27. I am happy for her!


Caught glimpse of lauren's only.. looks good.. And i think i shall be judging puneet rather than lauren 😛

Bang on!.. Salman till now hasn't let her perform indivdually ( what i mean is give a small dancing piece where she is dancing without salman's support)... I would really want to see that.. because today they were good and I do expect great things from her in coming time.. she looks like someone who can manage that..

agree on 3 hrs.. but it can't be taken as excuse for long!

Don't agree on hours of practice should be kept in mind.. why should a contestant get a concession for that? If they don't have time to practice they shouldn't have opted for this show.. but however.. if they don't play on this card then this very card will play to their advantage because then viewers would give them credit that by practicing 3 hrs they are performing well... but no extra benefit in marks or comments just because they practice for 3 hrs!!!





enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: El_Dorado

Below is my opinion as a non-dancer viewer-

1. Shaan: My Score: Prop: 4, dancing: 3, emotions: 4, choreography: 4 (Marischa is awesome 👏)= 15/16

2. Aarti: My score: Prop: 3, Dancing: 3, Emotions: 2, choreography: 2.5= 10.5/16

3. Drashti: My Score: Prop: 1, dancing: 3, emotions: 3, choreography: 1(all the dancing was done by Drashti, while Salman was standing idle for most of the time. Drashti did way better than last week; but Salman was disappointing)= 8/16

4. Meghna: My Score: Prop: 2, dancing: 2, emotions: 4, choreography: 2.5= 10.5/16

4.Sid: My Score: Prop: 2, dancing: 1, emotions: 1, choreography: 2= 6/16

Face off:
1. Suresh: My Score: Dancing: 1, emotions: 4, choreography: 1= 5/12
2. Ekta: My Score: Dancing: 3, emotions: 0 (sorry but I don't know how come she is an actress 😆), choreography: 3= 6/12

edit: fonts changed 😳




ha ha.. the reason I didn't add choreography to scores is because there are too many variables after that.. so judging the theme alone seemed more fair to minimize subjectivity..

On choreo.. I think Marischa had an oft repeated style.. but that is a problem with contemprory.. most used style on tv shows so more or less everyone has seen everything.. 😃.. but when I look at shaan's footwork and finesses.. although its more of acrobatics.. and his charming sweet calm look.. it adds a certain grace to the performance..

On Ekta, i agree.. wonder how she performs in her serials!.. has anyone see her???
sadumaneet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
lovely reviews dear completely agree specially about DD's off screen moments channel not realising by showing all this they r just ruining her hardwork means common yaar while signing for show she knows pros and cons why make issue out of it and more over she really don't need it her dancing talent is enough for that... ok now coming to her performance it was damn good i had goosebumps but agree with Remo there was less use of props. Shaan was just wow I love his smile he had so much positive auro around him which automatic brings smile on ur face he dance also really well but it was not best for me it is 26 or 27 woud have enough. Arati is really very good dancer but I find choreography quite boring and I was like ye dance to khatam hi nahi ho raha hai, i really like her mimicry of Juhi Chawala it was so much fun... P. S. KJO ur not comedian ur damn judge of the show what is that comment that U both r looking like vitamin C tablet common means isn't that shud be Manish's job. I watched only these performance so can't comment on others
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Veronica.

awesome analysis 👏

Shaan is a treat to watch. His smile makes up for whatever little mistakes he makes here and there. His choreographer very smartly took up that german wheel and choreographed some real wonderful moves to which Shaan did full justice.👏

Aarti is a good dancer but I didn't really like her performance.It was a so-so act for me.🥱

Drashti's performance was nice if u forget that they were supposed to use a prop. Nice concept, wonderful expressions.
And on one thing I completely agree with you. Too much of something is never good. And this Drashti Drashti has annoyed me to the point that I can't enjoy her performances. They need to start differentiating b/w madhubala and drashti.😕

I loved Meghna. She gave some really wonderful expressions and being a non-dancer, her moves were quite good👏

Sid..what the hell was he doing? His dance was NOT AT ALL good! Last time the 3D thing covered up for his poor dancing skills, but today it became clear that he has got two left feet. The choreography was also not good. Sonia needs to buck up. And yeah..the yoga did no good to Sid 😆

Ekta will be eliminated soon. She's not a bad dancer and with that choregrapher she can learn a lot and do wonders BUT she always carries that dead pan expression on her face. It looks like only her body is dancing and mind is somewhere else. Being an actor she should know better about expressions and all.😲

Suresh Menon..He deserved to get eliminated. He was the weakest of them all. He forgot half of his steps and his performance was just plain bad.


he he.. sid was real funny.. wonder wat was wrong with sonia to choreograph this!.. god!.. ekta .. and look at her performance.. ok.. like we are talking abt drashti.. ekta's perofrmance technically was flawless except for one lift where her legs are not straight.. its is perfect.. BUT hell she doesn't emote only.. who wants to watch a dance with that expression 😡
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: ..SalmanGirl..

The way salman used the prop was disappointing ... But hey even sachin gets out on zero ... so no worries im sure he will bounce back (i thought remo was biased with him acc to half of the world ) well if i leave the prop it was 30/ 30 performance for me ,, They shudnt have shown her schedule ... i agree ...its colors fault though ! Wont comment on rest much ...but i guess shaan' perf deserved 27 maximum !


ya ya.. concession given .. 😆.. agree.. if prop or theme was not in question the dance was extremely nice.. well choreographed and well executed..

But for me, the point is.. if there is a theme then there is a theme..

And if Shaan was to get 27.. others should have got lesser.. 😆.. because in terms of being true to the theme they were way better than others..

Ofcourse, after tomorrow's performance we would know how others used their props.. lauren's acts looks best till now..

Also, I havent judged anyone's choreography.. because that is pointless this week.. all I am looking for it.. did they use the prop well!!!.. difficult moves or easy moves.. plus there is a thing with contemprory and lifts... people are awed by lifts (that salman tends to use a lot)... but this dance style is so oft repeated that .. everything looks monotonous after some time.. you can relate them.. and nothing seems new..
MercurialMedusa thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#16
Loved ur analysis and agree with it too 😊

Remo was honest in his comments today and said almost whatever I felt while I watched the performances so he gets a 👍🏼 from me.

Madhuri though is a good dancer is not a good judge IMO coz she wants to be nice to everyone and ends up being repetitively sugary sweet which gets annoying after a while.

Karan just copies the scores Madhuri gives and comments of Remo.. other than that I feel his only job on JDJ as a judge is to make gay jokes with the hosts and drool over the male contestants.

Coming to performances..

I absolutely loved Shaan's performance.. he totally deserved the scores he got 😊 he is such a treat to watch.. with his everlasting smile which covers all the nervousness and efforts he puts into his dancing.. he is a lambi race ka ghoda fosho 😃

Aarti's performance was okay.. I felt she was trying too hard and it showed in her perfomance.. it wasn't smooth or that pleasing to eyes.. she was okay.. she may last for 3-4 more weeks.

Drashti danced well and so did Salman but as Remo rightly pointed out their act was out of place with regards to the theme of the episode. Salman's choreography was a let down for me.

Meghna surprised me last week with her performance and today she amazed me.. the lady is otherwise so sober and graceful but as soon as the music started she danced like an item bomb 😆 she was much better than the resident item queen shweta.

Siddharth no matter how much yoga he tries his stiffness would not go away. His act was clumsy.. concept was weird and for most part of the act I couldn't figure out what was the concept and why did a Doctor and nurse randomly started doing Pole dancing (sid being the pole and sonia being the dancer 😛)

Now with Suresh gone I feel Siddharth is the weakest dancer of the lot and also seems like Sonia has given up coz all I see her is disconnected and frowning always after the act where as Siddharth tries to be as sportive as he can (love the guy for that).
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: sadumaneet

lovely reviews dear completely agree specially about DD's off screen moments channel not realising by showing all this they r just ruining her hardwork means common yaar while signing for show she knows pros and cons why make issue out of it and more over she really don't need it her dancing talent is enough for that... ok now coming to her performance it was damn good i had goosebumps but agree with Remo there was less use of props. Shaan was just wow I love his smile he had so much positive auro around him which automatic brings smile on ur face he dance also really well but it was not best for me it is 26 or 27 woud have enough. Arati is really very good dancer but I find choreography quite boring and I was like ye dance to khatam hi nahi ho raha hai, i really like her mimicry of Juhi Chawala it was so much fun... P. S. KJO ur not comedian ur damn judge of the show what is that comment that U both r looking like vitamin C tablet common means isn't that shud be Manish's job. I watched only these performance so can't comment on others


Correct abt drashti.. she is good of only colors can leave it at that. 😆

Shaan for me.. today they are the only ones who did justice to their theme.. and compared to last week.. it was an outstanding performance for me..😆😃.. now next week onwards.. yes, since expectations are more they would have to work real hard.. 😃

Juhi's mimicry was awesome!

Kjo is useless...😛
Serenity_me thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#18
nice analysis.

shaan- i loved his performance,. song selection was really good n dance movements were as smooth n beautiful as d song was. prop selection was quite unique n it was not easy to maintain ur balance on wheels but they did it so gracefully. shaan got well deserving 30 marks .👏


Aarti- it was nice performance but not better than her last performance. prop was ok ok. i hv nothing to say more about her except stop crying . baby why u always starts crying😆 u r doing good job , so please take it easy😆

Drashti- very well choreographed. good synchronization , expressions n moves justified the theme. less use of prop , only that was their minus point. n me too agree whatever remo said.

Meghna- sorry, but i didn't get their song, my fault😆 but her energy level was her plus point.

sid- ummm need to put extra efforts. i didnt find his performance upto d mark.

suresh n ekta- i do agree wid remo, suresh was energetic but ekta danced mechanically without any expression. But she can dance, so she is in.

about judges, i think remo is d only judge who judge contestant from tip to toe.

@ TM- agree wid u, there is no need to put extra efforts to promote they own actors.


PD_forums thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#19
excellent thread 👏 superb analysis 👍🏼

I am not sure if you had opened a thread last week, if you opened share the link i would love to read it 😃
and please do continue your analysis 😊

i was switching between DID and JDL so i missed DD and Siddarth performances 🤔

i liked Shaan and megna performances and arti is ok... but i loved her juhi mimic 😆
Edited by -PD- - 12 years ago
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: GoldenDew

Loved ur analysis and agree with it too 😊

Remo was honest in his comments today and said almost whatever I felt while I watched the performances so he gets a 👍🏼 from me.

Madhuri though is a good dancer is not a good judge IMO coz she wants to be nice to everyone and ends up being repetitively sugary sweet which gets annoying after a while.

Karan just copies the scores Madhuri gives and comments of Remo.. other than that I feel his only job on JDJ as a judge is to make gay jokes with the hosts and drool over the male contestants.

Coming to performances..

I absolutely loved Shaan's performance.. he totally deserved the scores he got 😊 he is such a treat to watch.. with his everlasting smile which covers all the nervousness and efforts he puts into his dancing.. he is a lambi race ka ghoda fosho 😃

Aarti's performance was okay.. I felt she was trying too hard and it showed in her perfomance.. it wasn't smooth or that pleasing to eyes.. she was okay.. she may last for 3-4 more weeks.

Drashti danced well and so did Salman but as Remo rightly pointed out their act was out of place with regards to the theme of the episode. Salman's choreography was a let down for me.

Meghna surprised me last week with her performance and today she amazed me.. the lady is otherwise so sober and graceful but as soon as the music started she danced like an item bomb 😆 she was much better than the resident item queen shweta.

Siddharth no matter how much yoga he tries his stiffness would not go away. His act was clumsy.. concept was weird and for most part of the act I couldn't figure out what was the concept and why did a Doctor and nurse randomly started doing Pole dancing (sid being the pole and sonia being the dancer 😛)

Now with Suresh gone I feel Siddharth is the weakest dancer of the lot and also seems like Sonia has given up coz all I see her is disconnected and frowning always after the act where as Siddharth tries to be as sportive as he can (love the guy for that).


True abt sonia, she seems disconnected.. with baichung she was so serious of her performances... sid is a weak dancer. .. indeed..

Meghna.. I am loving her with each day.. i hope she gets votes.. that's the only issue with her.. and expressions man.. till now only her and lauren have I seen exceling in emoting..rest all of them are plain ok..

On shwets.. oh yes, last week even i was giving the concession to her on bad choreography.. but then u look at meghna today.. it was an ok choreo.. but song selection was good..and i would never want to see shweta in item numbers if meghna is my option.. bang on expressions.. rt energy.,. full on item song ka mazza

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".