Shveta won't part with her money! - Page 8

Originally posted by: Buffie

Rati AGnihortri,Pooja Bedi are all talking about
"how good a human being mona is"...seriously,is this a "personality
competition".... Svetha was a born dancer,so penalize her for god's
gift.take away all credit that she performed well....So atrocious.... and it
would be nice if Pooja could tell us how she came to know that svetha's a
seasoned dancer..because,even Pooja has danced for
movies,awards,shows etc..in that way,wouldnt she too be called a
seasoned dancer.....

ajay's voting for mona only based on sympathy...just like
everyone else....None of them say that they vote for the better dancer[/
FONT]

if Pooja was season dancer wouldn't she be getting 10's and 9s which she
never got and she was voted off first... and Svetha always showed her
skills and dancing abilities... and took home major mileage... why are you
saying that ppl will give sympathy votes to mona... whole point of
competition is to show improvements, not to show off the dance skills a
person has.. what improvement did svetha showed from first to last
episode Zilt..
all in all India should stop copying the western concepts.. it never works,
for indian audience,

Originally posted by: dhru4u

if Pooja was season dancer wouldn't she be getting 10's and 9s which she
never got and she was voted off first... and Svetha always showed her
skills and dancing abilities... and took home major mileage... why are you
saying that ppl will give sympathy votes to mona... whole point of
competition is to show improvements, not to show off the dance skills a
person has.. what improvement did svetha showed from first to last
episode Zilt..
all in all India should stop copying the western concepts.. it never works,
for indian audience,

If someone gets a 30,it doesnt mean that person is a professional

Even Mona got 29,does that make her a professional,going by your logic

The whole point of competitions is all about dancing,and not about mere improvements along the show....Its firstly not a show for non dancers,its only a show for "celebrities from different walks of life".....because if it was strictly only for non dancers who have never danced earlier in their lives,then perhaps only sanjeev kapoor should have been there,as everyone else have danced before in moives/awards etc

Pooja bedi is a self proclaimed BAD dancer.....a BAD dancer who just isnt cut out for dance cannot dance like a diva......and besides,Pooja ranted and fretted and fumed about shveta being trained,only because shveta has danced for music videos/shows earlier...and thus I said,applying the logic,even Pooja who has danced in movies would be called a seasoned dancer..IT WAS A TONGUE IN CHEEK REMARK!

and why would shveta show improvement,when she's so near perfection...IF she has a natural flair for dancing,and if she scores a 30,should she underperform just to hsow that she has "improved"....Shveta's interviews say it all,she doesnt want to underperform....The show is not "IMPROVEMENT DIKHLA JA"....so that the one who improved the most would win....Its about dancing,and on judicious grounds,the best dancer should win

Originally posted by: Dancingdoll

You are right MithiBani, I do not like it!!! We know this is what public
does and we have seen the public opinion right here in IF!!! and that is
why we are asking people to change this attitude because this is
WRONG!!! The criteria should be DANCE and only DANCE!!!! This show is
not about being a Good Human Being!!! The concept here is changed by
people completely!!!

Plus I have heard the same rumours about shveta as you all have and I
am not denying the rumours and I am not affirming them!!!!! Because
frankly it does not matter to me what kinda human is she.....and who has
given us credentials to judge someone...Noone is perfect!!!! Why do you
think there are so many shveta's supporters???? They too have heard the
same stories as you have but not all have given hay to these stories as
what counts is that she can DANCE well!!! and this competition is all
about Dance!!!

You asked me, "suppose I come to know that Mona is a terrible person,
would I vote for her", Let me tell you, this is what I have heard about
shveta and I would still vote for her....Because Dancing skills do not go on
the basis of your character!!! When nature has seperated the Dancing skill
from the character of a human being, then why are we being illogical and
fools to club both of them!!!

There are many ppl who are posting messages to make ppl aware that
Hiten and Gauri should be voted out!!!! That means there are ppl who
understand that this is wrong!!! So, I would not say that the public in
general is like this but yes, most of us are fools to mix these feelings!!![/
P]

what did judges do then...??? they kept on giving Mahesh sympathy
votes.. lots of times he has sliped and made mistakes yet have taken
more points, farah even said it to mahesh in one epiode "minused points
will be added for a lift" what is this.... tell me....

and not only that farah even said to mahesh in the episode after akash
left... that "mahesh no matter what you do on top, your footwork is
always good" so she is trying to say... if Akash had done bhangra moves
on top and salsa in the bottom it is ok... what is the BS.. tell me
isn't this stupid... Mahesh always got sympathy votes cuz he was old...
noone objected to that... half the times he didn't even do what was told, i
saw lots of episodes where they did same thing over and over, yet got
more points....
but when Mona did same steps, farah and Sanjay both started pointing...
very idotic...

i have taken salsa and sabha classes and i still do... if i show my teacher
these moves from JDJ he will laugh at them... only ppl who actually did
right stuff, was Svetha, Ajay, Akash & Mona... but no judges always gave
Mahesh good points....

all in all as i said. india shouldn't copy western concepts it never works...

Originally posted by: Buffie

If someone gets a 30,it doesnt mean that person is a
professional

Even Mona got 29,does that make her a professional,going by
your logic

The whole point of competitions is all about dancing,and not
about mere improvements along the show....Its firstly not a show for non
dancers,its only a show for "celebrities from different walks of
life".....because if it was strictly only for non dancers who have never
danced earlier in their lives,then perhaps only sanjeev kapoor should have
been there,as everyone else have danced before in moives/awards etc[/
FONT]

and why would shveta show improvement,when she's so near
perfection...IF she has a natural flair for dancing,and if she scores a
30,should she underperform just to hsow that she has
"improved"....Shveta's interviews say it all,she doesnt want to
underperform....The show is not "IMPROVEMENT DIKHLA JA"....so that the
one who improved the most would win....Its about dancing,and on
judicious grounds,the best dancer should win

First of all learn how to read...
i never said Svetha is a proffesional dancer....
and second of all... Mona never performed as much as Svetha did on
stage... and forget mona... when did Rati, Mahesh and Sanjeev and Ajay
performed on stage.... out of everyone only 2 ppl have performed quite
many times, Svetha and pooja... no one is doubting that svetha is natural
born dancer... and if the show was for dancers,, then none of them
should be there, accept, pooja and svetha...
and plus watch the british version the original version of the same show..
you will get the concept...

and if the show was not for improvements.. then why were judges there
in first place..and why was farah khan telling contestants to improve this
and that .. she shouldn't be there RIGHT!...
cuz this is for dancers, and not improvements...

Originally posted by: dhru4u

First of all learn how to read...
i never said Svetha is a proffesional dancer....
and second of all... Mona never performed as much as Svetha did on
stage... and forget mona... when did Rati, Mahesh and Sanjeev and Ajay
performed on stage.... out of everyone only 2 ppl have performed quite
many times, Svetha and pooja... no one is doubting that svetha is natural
born dancer... and if the show was for dancers,, then none of them
should be there, accept, pooja and svetha...
and plus watch the british version the original version of the same show..
you will get the concept...

I dont care about the british version,but the rules of JDJ(indian version) say that "ITS FOR CELEBRITIES FROM DIFFERENT WALKS OF LIFE,WHO MAY HAVE NOT DANCED EARLIER"....the emphasis is on the word "MAY HAVE"......Its not strictly for non dancers to begin with.....

"Mona never performed as much as shveta did on stage"...

If you're talking about JDJ,then every contestant has been treated equally,and Mona has danced as much as shveta has

If you're talking about dancing experience apart from jhalak,then mona has danced in a mucis video,in ads,at garbas,at cruises,at award functions...Thus even she has danced quite alot in the last 3 years😃

Judges gave sympathy votes,does that mean
even we should do the wrong thing by giving Mona sympathy votes....

and this post isnt about judges....One is only saying that IF YOU TRULY
FEEL MONA IS THE BETTER DANCER,VOTE FOR HER.....One is only asking
people not to vote for other factors like "goodness of human being"
etc,because if the criterion for voting isnt dance,then its a mockery of the
entire show and the entire concept of "DANCING WITH STARS"...[/
QUOTE]

why shouldn't we do that... if judges could do it and put someone in hot
seat.. why not public? and plus... what dance.. when mahesh manjrekar
did whatever he felt like.. according to judges "humour"... he did lavni
with salsa steps... and he got 9 from everyone... public is not stupid... it's
a common sense right there... when a judge says "mahesh tum upar kuch
bhi karo, tumhara foot work kabhi nahi chhutt taa" what does that
mean.."it means upaar bhangra karo aur foot work salsa ka do"
does this make anysense.. is this the dance show or bash ex-bf and
rivalry show...

well.. all in all... ppl hates MONA.. and they luv svetha cuz she has danced
and have gotten 30's that is it... so ppl vote for whoever you ppl want to..
don't let others tell you about anyone...... you have rights, and it's given to
you... cuz arguing is not gonna make these ppl understand... so someone
has to step down...

Originally posted by: dhru4u

if Pooja was season dancer wouldn't she be getting 10's and 9s which she
never got and she was voted off first... and Svetha always showed her
skills and dancing abilities... and took home major mileage... why are you
saying that ppl will give sympathy votes to mona... whole point of
competition is to show improvements, not to show off the dance skills a
person has.. what improvement did svetha showed from first to last
episode Zilt..
all in all India should stop copying the western concepts.. it never works,
for indian audience,

Hey Dhruv,

Can you show us where exactly is it mentioned that the criteria for Jhalak Dikhla Ja is that you should show improvement and then you win and incase you show consistency in dancing and perform extremely well in all rounds then you dont deserve to win because "This show si all about improvement"..I dont see this quoted anywheer by Jhalak Dikhla Ja team.......

Why should they even take Shveta If thats the criteria, take ppl who have never danced before!!! Its not shveta's mistake that she has the knack for dancing and has consistently performed well!!! why penalise her just because she is a born dancer? Just because she dances well and there is no room for improvement that we dont vote for her....

Sorry, but you have got the whole concept wrong about the show!!!! The show is about the best dancer and not about improvement....

and lastly, I would like to quote Mermaid's line.....If it is about improvement, shouldnt this show be renamed to, "Improvement dikhla Ja"...

A huge round of applause to Mermaid!!!!! 😆