Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

4.1k

Users

25

Frequent Posters

fm05 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Kirs

divyta, I would like to request u to first read my post well, before you express your agreement or disagreements.

True, a person is judged in a show according to his/her dance and not actress. What I said is that inspite of being a non-dancer (actress), she is making a mark against shveta, so much as to make her feel insecure. You are forgetting that Shveta also is an actress.

I never said that "mona is popular in votes u think she can stay in this show". No way, I am very much against this voting thing. Since Shveta is supposed to be a good dancer, she should have confidence over her performance.

The judges are not at all biased towards Mona, as you may note that she got less marks when her performance was not good in the initial rounds, whereas Shveta has always got good marks in all the rounds.

I do agree that Shveta is a better dancer among the two, but I do hope that Mona wins in the final duel, not based on votes, but on performance. Although there is no way to judge how the winner actually won, through judges marks or through votes.

The judges in this show are horrible and Akash has rightly pointed out each and every judge's faults. A judge is meant to be impartial. Here, they have their own favourites and its as if they have pre-decided who the winner finally would be.


Shveta does have confidence in her dancing skills, she doesnt have faith in the audience to support that. Shveta is given marks on merit, she always performs to the highest level so she deserves the points, but she was marked low in one round so you cant say that the judges are impartial.

To call the judges bias it to just makes excuses for the other dancers not scoring so highly, which is exactly what Akash was doing in his speech. He was a sore loser and insulted the juges to make himself feel better. I suspose what he said about Shilpa was semi-true but still it was uncalled for, his choregrapher was weak. She always gave him slow moves when he just didnt suit them.

Anyway, these reality shows are never fair as the public vote element just calls for bias, as the most popular contestant wins. Such shows end up being a popularity contest.

Honestly speaking, i was not a fan of Shveta until JDJ, it was her dancing skills which were so impressive that she has made me a fan. The best dancer should win and Shveta is the best.

fm05 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: sumesh



Oh Sneha u said it....👏

Wow..extremely well said 👏 👏 👏
Think how frustrating it must be for Shveta to have her hardwrk go under-appreciated because the audience want 'Jassi' to win.

sumesh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#23
U guys really need a break....Even donno basics of relaity show....

In all reality shows they will give more importance to make gossips or heats like this...& even edits the question they were asked & just show the answer only...No one will think of wht made them tell a reply like this & all...

same happened in FG Rex & Arpita being made a Villain to get more sympathy over Qazi....In II-2 too antara's comments were edited & showed as she was rude to public & even judges too one time... In II-2 Anuj came so far due to frustration by judges towards him & in II-1 Rabinder Ravi also come so far becoz of the same....

This is dance show just watch the show in dance basis & dont look over hw they looks or wht they told in edited clips(Actually wht we were seeing)..Its seems like there still some foolish people in India there which believes in wht they were shown only & Ofcourse this way TRP raises too...

SONY u r doing good job with ur cut part like this to make one down & another to get sympathy or emotional votes seeing this...Keep it up....In Any shows most hyped one or deserving never wins...If they gets some chance u guys make them villain using their comment shown to public

So my request to all who watched JDJ just enjoy the show & discuss abt their faults in dancing or judges biased comments & all rather than discussing abt the editted comments liek this😃
Edited by sumesh - 18 years ago
tina59 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#24

first of all ,those who know me from the JJKN forum would know that I am a big Mona fan but at the same time when it comes to dancing ,I will def agree that shwetha is the best dancer and she deserves to win the JDL champpionship.Moreover she is an excellent dancer and she has got showering praises from all the judges so why would she be jealous ,infact Mona should be jealous seeing the judges praise her so much .

Def one can say that the contestants may feel a little insecure and thats what shwetha felt coz I think whatever said and done, Mona is much more popular and has mass appeal mainly bcoz of her "jassi" image.I think all the contestants would be insecure at this point ,if shwetha is/may be insecure bcoz of Mona getting more votes,I think Mona would be nsecure bcoz of shwetha's incredible dancing abilities .Thats human nature and there is nothing wrong in it .

jyoti jwala thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#25
i don't know why but to me shweta was not talking much yesterday and kept on looking down and looked upset but she should be like mona always laughing and thats what people want to see.
breathing_irony thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: jyoti jwala

i don't know why but to me shweta was not talking much yesterday and kept on looking down and looked upset but she should be like mona always laughing and thats what people want to see.

oh so ppl r going to judge upon how bubbly a person is?😕😕

I dont think any of us shd start pointing fingers at shveta's charcter, her insecurity, her confidence etc....coz at the end of the day the only thing tht matters is the dancing. So pls lets stop teh character assassination!

My heart goes out to shveta, who despite putting in more thn 2000% may not get the votes just coz she doesnt havea 'jassi' lik image. LRL is not as popular as Jassi is---n it is rajeev who si the highlight of LRL, not shveta.....

I really realyl aprreciate the fact tht mona is a good dancer n she has realyl improved.....i think she's extremely cute as well.....but all of tht doesnt make her more deserving thn shveta, who IS THE BEST!

Edited by breathing_irony - 18 years ago
ajain73 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#27
mona is lauging because she know she is getting all votes and shwta is right what ever she do dance is very good but she is not getting same votes as mona

and these days it dodn't matter how you dance just get the publec vote and you are in finals
(like NB2) but so far JDJ is going good( other than manjreker) now lets see what happens?
insouciance thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

oh so ppl r going to judge upon how bubbly a person is?😕😕

I dont think any of us shd start pointing fingers at shveta's charcter, her insecurity, her confidence etc....coz at the end of the day the only thing tht matters is the dancing. So pls lets stop teh character assassination!

My heart goes out to shveta, who despite putting in more thn 2000% may not get the votes just coz she doesnt havea 'jassi' lik image. LRL is not as popular as Jassi is---n it is rajeev who si the highlight of LRL, not shveta.....

I really realyl aprreciate the fact tht mona is a good dancer n she has realyl improved.....i think she's extremely cute as well.....but all of tht doesnt make her more deserving thn shveta, who IS THE BEST!

you know what,people HARDLY go by the talent...People mostly vote based on other factors like chirpiness,affability,spontaniety etc...Happens everywhere...Mona does laugh more,comes across as more funloving,thus people vote for her "image"....WHich is sad,as dance isnt being given predominance

and those who say that Mone needs to win because she has worked hard....YEs,she hAS worked hard..but Mona has ONLY JDJ,she can donate all her time for this show..whereas svetha has 3 other shows too..LRL(albeit she's not seen much offlate,but she had scenes till 2 weeks back),kittu and popkorn...Svetha's juggling with JDJ and3 shows,mona has ALLLLLLLLLLLL the time only to practice for JDJ...WHy dont people consider that

Jassi is not Mona,and even mona has agreed that she is NOT jassi,infact she was hell bent on getting out of the jassi image,but its just helping her now...Jassi has the mass appeal,people consider "mona singh" as their role model....SOme cant differentiate between reel and real,Jassi was an icon in certain ways,Mona isnt....Even in the intro,Mona was introduced as "model,role model"...In what way has mona been a role mode😕l,she isnt anything like Jassi in real life...SOme dense people cant differentiate,and stars bank in on the junta's idiocy

Poor svetha,I'd really be sad if she gets out😭

Edited by Buffie - 18 years ago
rangi1222 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#29
i agree with buffie.mona get so popular because of jassi and people like her because of her role.shewta is not that popular she didnot do any serial as main character i think
NKSUDHIR thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#30
Yess, Shveta is jealous of Mona getting votes because of Jassi fan base but Mahesh is getting judges points because he is a director. It happens in all the reality shows. Public has their own way of voting. I really want Mona to win because she is really an entertainer.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".