Why its 'Unfair' that Mahi is still in JDJ4? - Page 4

Thank you for agreeing that she does not dance as good as the others. IDEALLY, the winner should be the best dancer, not popular dancer.

The people that are saying it's unfair for Mahi to stay in the competition, is because they go by the contestant's dance and scores, rather than their popularity. So you must understand where they are coming from.

Therefore, if Mahi wins, she will not automatically become the best dancer, even though the goal of Jhalak is to reward the best dancer. At the end of the day, the people that deserved it based on their dance, will not win. This has been happening in all seasons, so there's nothing new about it. I wouldn't be surprised if Mahi wins. Congrats to her if she does. But the ultimate winners will still be the best dancers of the show, and nobody can change that! 😊

no use arguing theultimate, im certain mahi is out so im not going to debate, just see for yourself in the episode

Originally posted by: -Priyalicious-

no use arguing theultimate, im certain mahi is out so im not going to debate, just see for yourself in the episode

Lol....that's good to hear! 😊

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

Saaki, I agree with your post uptil the point where you brought the dancer- non-dancer thing. I personally feel that Mahi and other non-dancers KNEW from the beginning itself, when they took on the show that they would be competing against some dancers as well, yet they agreed to take the show, so that consideration doesn't hold anymore. 😃

Coming to your main point, no, Mahi staying in JDJ is not unfair. Even if she wins tomorrow, it will not be unfair- bcos everything is within the show format. The one who gets votes wins- plain and simple. 😊

Its just that the voting and eliminations are not going on according to the dance done by the contestants. Some who were better than Mahi got less votes from the public and got eliminated😭. Sad, but there is nothing one can do about it-- in such reality shows, fan base along with talent is equally important..

Nikita............Stop finding some "fairness" from these JDJ people.................

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

I think MV has really worked hard to get so far. Her hard work shouldnt be dismissed. Frankly speaking its unfair to have trained dancers like Sushant, Yana compete with untrained ones like MV and Chang. But the show is abt celebs and so in a way is fair as all 4 are celebs on their own right!

Plus MV has public support...people like to see her antics. Having the ability to entertain is also an important part of being a celeb. That MV has in loads.

Shreyaaaaaaaaa......................... ................

Originally posted by: njo921

totally agree with ur post!! 👍🏼

mahi is in the show fair and square... so y r ppl complaining?!?!

go mahi go!!! she rocks! 😃

Thx for agreeing yaar................

Originally posted by: Kanuk

I agree with you Saaki. There are lot more "Unfair" things going on in the show. Veto power was supposed to be used once, but it's used twice. Once to save Ankita and Yana, and second time to save Sushant and Yana.

Mahi is not a non-dancer that I can tell when she is let free to dance as she likes, she dances pretty well. But that doesn't make you accustomed to be in right posture always , which is the high point in Sushant's performance and others.

The trained dancers's performances are always highlighted by their strong points whereas more technical points are highlighted in untrained dancers' performance.

Thx for agreeying yaar................ ...........

Originally posted by: anupamas2

Agree with you totally. She has worked very hard and her improvement is noticeable too. Even I sometimes feel that the judges give her less scores than when she deserves, specially Remo.
All the reality shows are all about getting votes, so if she gets more votes then she has every right to be in JDJ4 till now.

Completely agree with you dear.........

Originally posted by: blyton

If a celebrity is staying on in the competition because they are getting more votes than others, it is part of the format of the show. No way can it be termed unfair. It is unfair when the format is changed to "help" some contestants. I felt it was unfair to Krushna when Ankita was brought back through a second wild card and he wasn't, when there wasn't much difference in their WC performance and many people even felt that he danced better than Ankita.

Thx for replying dear............

Originally posted by: lunza

ditto ..
and reg . the whole "fair/unfair" debate .. why are the other "imbalances" never spoken about ?..
Ok , sushant has an "advantage" of having learnt jazz .. but he has this "disadvantage" of having to rehearse for his performances after shooting for 13-14 hours a day for his daily soap... how tiring must that be?

so i never get this argument - chang should win bcuz he is not trained like sushant ..
what about the fact that chang has loads of time to rehearse for his performances unlike sushant
who is practically living on the sets and working almost 24 hours a day ?
In fact chang said the same thing in his interview - if sushant has good dancing skills then chang has lots of time on his hand .. similarly for yana .. and yana is a pretty good dancer too..

Jhalak has never been a level playing field ...
They have always taken an "uneven" bunch of celebs .. some trained/natural dancers , some hugely popular , some with two left feet , some who are much older than the other contestants , some who are not as physically fit as the others etc ...

The only "criteria" for their selection in the show is that you have to be a well known celebrity in your field ..( "celebrities from all walks of life" )

ok , now coming back to the topic .. 😆 ..
Well , I will be honest , i am a sushant fan and i want him to win , -
so yes , i would not like it if mahi wins ,and i find her performances to be really clumsy and i am disappointed with savio too ( didnt really watch last season , but i heard he did a better job last season ...)
When the show started , mahi was a much better dancer than chang who had two left feet
chang has improved a lot ( who would have thought that chang would be equaling yana in the last few weeks of the show?)

but if mahi wins , uh ...ok , i will try not to say anything to dismiss all her hard work ...
and no , mahi winning will not be unfair ( sigggggghhhhhhhhhh 😔 😆 )

@ Bold : Yes......I too agree Chang's improvement is highly commendable.......