Why its 'Unfair' that Mahi is still in JDJ4? - Page 2

If a celebrity is staying on in the competition because they are getting more votes than others, it is part of the format of the show. No way can it be termed unfair. It is unfair when the format is changed to "help" some contestants. I felt it was unfair to Krushna when Ankita was brought back through a second wild card and he wasn't, when there wasn't much difference in their WC performance and many people even felt that he danced better than Ankita.

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

Kanuk, they must be knowing that there will be a few good dancers in the show as well. In EVERY season of JDJ, there have been a few trained dancers--- for example::: Sweta Salve, Sudha Chandran.

" I guess they are too busy to watch tv " 😉

If I take Sushant's example (cos everyone gives his example only all the time 😆 ) -- he has told it many times that he has learnt from Shiamak Davar- in interviews, in ZNKD, even in JDJ. He seems to be very proud of the fact that he got to learn for some time from such an awesome choreographer. So others must be knowing it too.

Thats why I mentioned except the few ones 😃

The show is about celebs from different walks of life--- and if they agreed for the show knowing that the talent level will not be the same, some will be stronger than others--- then now the dancer-non-dancer issue hold little consideration.

All that aside-- bottom line is--- (trying to stick in the topic😆)--- as long as Mahi Vij is getting votes, all is okay, although I do wish that people would start considering the dancing of other contestants as well while casting their precious votes.😃

Originally posted by: Kanuk

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

Saaki, I agree with your post uptil the point where you brought the dancer- non-dancer thing. I personally feel that Mahi and other non-dancers KNEW from the beginning itself, when they took on the show that they would be competing against some dancers as well, yet they agreed to take the show, so that consideration doesn't hold anymore. 😃

ditto ..
and reg . the whole "fair/unfair" debate .. why are the other "imbalances" never spoken about ?..
Ok , sushant has an "advantage" of having learnt jazz .. but he has this "disadvantage" of having to rehearse for his performances after shooting for 13-14 hours a day for his daily soap... how tiring must that be?

so i never get this argument - chang should win bcuz he is not trained like sushant ..
what about the fact that chang has loads of time to rehearse for his performances unlike sushant
who is practically living on the sets and working almost 24 hours a day ?
In fact chang said the same thing in his interview - if sushant has good dancing skills then chang has lots of time on his hand .. similarly for yana .. and yana is a pretty good dancer too..

Jhalak has never been a level playing field ...
They have always taken an "uneven" bunch of celebs .. some trained/natural dancers , some hugely popular , some with two left feet , some who are much older than the other contestants , some who are not as physically fit as the others etc ...

The only "criteria" for their selection in the show is that you have to be a well known celebrity in your field ..( "celebrities from all walks of life" )

ok , now coming back to the topic .. 😆 ..
Well , I will be honest , i am a sushant fan and i want him to win , -
so yes , i would not like it if mahi wins ,and i find her performances to be really clumsy and i am disappointed with savio too ( didnt really watch last season , but i heard he did a better job last season ...)
When the show started , mahi was a much better dancer than chang who had two left feet
chang has improved a lot ( who would have thought that chang would be equaling yana in the last few weeks of the show?)

but if mahi wins , uh ...ok , i will try not to say anything to dismiss all her hard work ...
and no , mahi winning will not be unfair ( sigggggghhhhhhhhhh 😔 😆 )

some of your points are true and i agree with them.. she has never NOT performed, she has improved a lot and has public support.

Hah ??

Her dance performance speaks for it self. She should have been out of JDJ long before Ankita.

Originally posted by: bozo

Her dance performance speaks for it self. She should have been out of JDJ long before Ankita.

her votes speak for themselves... she deserves to be there. 😊

okey mahi is not very very good dancer

Originally posted by: Kanuk

@nikitiagmc: I don't think they have an exact idea of how well trained the others are except the few ones.

Its same as other know how popular other contestants are. But still make a point that "oh she is getting more votes" when its known fact that votes are important as well.

I guess it fair with everyone in a way or other.