4 THOSE who don't know SAROJ ji's capability.

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

BWSweetu

@BWSweetu

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#31

she is amazing judges.... and daring tooo ... she has a guts to say a truth (bekaar dancer to pappu) on national tv👏

Quote

Kanchan Prashar

@kanchan.p

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: shooli
she is amazing judges.... and daring tooo ... she has a guts to say a truth (bekaar dancer to pappu) on national tv👏<br>

lets see you dance you b-babe hahaaa
your fast talking about karan
but bb can't dance any better
and saroj is NOT a good judge.. she is unprofessional .. maybe a good choreographer but NOT a good judge

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sinipillai

@sinipillai

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

#33

Originally posted by: kanchan.p

lets see you dance you b-babe hahaaa
your fast talking about karan
but bb can't dance any better
and saroj is NOT a good judge.. she is unprofessional .. maybe a good choreographer but NOT a good judge

i think you didn't read all the comments...i am just copying from the 3rd page earlier i wrote for someone else .. i think my these lines fits you more...coz you said she is not a good jugde and unprofessional.... Wake up...

you are expecting Saroj ji and all other judges to say to Karan the following...

👏👏 Vowwww aapne kithna achaaa nachaa... Bina koi steps ke....

👏👏 Vowwww From the starting to the end you didn't show any improvements... well done...

👏👏 Vowwww Sab log ithna alag alag concepts kar rahe hai.. lekin aapki act mein kuch bhi naya nahi haii..... very good....

👏👏 Inspite of poor dancing in a dance reality show.... YOu are getting the higher vots..... WELL DONE..

Lists continues....................😃

Quote

sakshiluvskaran

@sakshiluvskaran

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: sinipillai

ooohhh i didn't know that this is called HEALTHY DISCUSSIONS....i got 96% in my boards... one % extra than you..............😆😆😆.............. come on yaar.. why are you taking it so seriously..... Let me give you a JAADU KI CHAPPI with loooooots of love...

i am not taking anything to heart ... i just said she needs to learn communication skills she doesnt thinks about others emotions u can see any post of mine on her i have no question on her skills but as a judges she lacks somewhere maybe she is inconsistent as a judge thats my point... and most people in one way or the other are agreeing with me

Edited by sakshiluvskaran - 16 years ago

Quote

sakshiluvskaran

@sakshiluvskaran

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: nandinidev
i do believe that Saroj ji is an extremely talented and experienced choreographer...i have no doubts about her capabilities in that sphere at all, we've seen enough of her work to let it do the talking as far as her skills as a choreographer are concerned...she's brilliant in what she does...but just like a bunch of degrees does not necessarily make you a good teacher, a heap of talent may still leave your objectivity as a judge lacking in some respects...i agree that she is a learned lady in her field, but even that does not make her word the be all and end all of dance...and that holds good for every judge in every reality show, not just Saroj ji in Jhalak...😊

but that's besides the point...as for those who have abused her after her statement on Karan, i will definitely agree that they need not have done so...👎🏼 i think they just got carried away in outrage...which is just to explain why they said what they said, not to condone it as right in any way...she deserves respect for what she is today...but i just wish she would be willing to give a little more thought to how much respect other people also deserve, if not as dancers then as human beings...to rate Karan low as a dancer is absolutely fine, but to use a term as crass as "Bekaar" with a sardonic tone and smile for a finalist on national television is a little tactless, and quite rude...🤔 and this would still have been the case no matter which contestant she was referring to...i'm saying this from an entirely objective point of view...😳

yes, i do agree that she should not have been abused or insulted in any way...and i also feel that it would be much nicer on her part, if she could at least attempt to be a little less condescending at times...and yes, a little more polite...

cheers! 😊

agree with u nandini this is what i said she cud have used the term "not the best of the lot" instead of "bekaar"... many people got hurt including me but then also i did not say a word about her except she needs to be polite i never questioned her skills... i dont know why bash somebody when u asked the opinions...

Quote

sakshiluvskaran

@sakshiluvskaran

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: prerna4rishav

It was on Star Plus -- Aaja Mahi Vay!! With my babies as Judges🤣 And SK used to dominate others😡😡Creating fights and all😡😡

i usually dont watch reality shows thats why my first one was ZND and probably last one will be JDJ...so SK is basically dominating

Quote

Rikz

@BlueSoul

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: sinipillai

i think you didn't read all the comments...i am just copying from the 3rd page earlier i wrote for someone else .. i think my these lines fits you more...coz you said she is not a good jugde and unprofessional.... Wake up...

you are expecting Saroj ji and all other judges to say to Karan the following...

👏👏 Vowwww aapne kithna achaaa nachaa... Bina koi steps ke....

👏👏 Vowwww From the starting to the end you didn't show any improvements... well done...

👏👏 Vowwww Sab log ithna alag alag concepts kar rahe hai.. lekin aapki act mein kuch bhi naya nahi haii..... very good....

👏👏 Inspite of poor dancing in a dance reality show.... YOu are getting the higher vots..... WELL DONE..

Lists continues....................😃

Im not a Die Hard Karan fan.....In this forum every topic comes to Karan whether its relevant or not. Cut that crap about Karan....Its always Karan Karan Karan in this forum.

Even i feel Saroj ji is not a good Judge.... A good Judge should never let her emotions take charge.

I've seen many other shows where Saroj ji as a judge was unfair. Also her comments should match with the marks she's giving...which is not case manier times. And while commenting she often gives the impression like she knows much more than the other choreographers....which may be true...still ...she dont need to show that....Other choreographers cant give their POV or what???

Quote

Reema

@ReemAnshu

Navigator

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#38

With the risk of getting some volatile replies, I will dare to put my 2 cents on this. Those who have seen my previous posts, would know that I am not a Karan Fan and Nor am I a BB Fan. Both dance rediculously but at the same time I think BB won it honestly and there was no rigging.

Coming to Saroj Khan. I think she was a Good choreographer and has done some memorable numbers. I loved Madhuri and her combo. But at the same time all her numbers In Late 80's and Early 90's were all Pelvic thrusts and Bust jerks. She has a great command over Indian Style of dancing (as seen in Dola re) and also sensuous numbers (Dhak Dhak, Hai Rama) but I seriously feel that she is not cut out of JUDGING ANY REALITY SHOWS. She has limited knowledge of Western Dancing. For he Samba is 'Sambha' and Saalsa is 'Sulsa'. Plus is is very rude and prejudiced. I have seen her on other shows also and she mostly ruins it, when she was Judge on Nach Baliye, She was Anti Bakhtiyar (which she made evident), then when she came on Zara Nach Ke Dikha (FInals) she carried on her Rude Behaviour and personal animosity by giving Lower marks to Bakhtiyar when he was miles ahead in dancing as compared to Karsima or Ashita.

She was very rude to the boys and again gave comments like ghatiya dancer and stuff to Bakhtiyar, who himself started his career as a Choreo. It resulted in a Boys walkout.

For me, she is way past her prime and not in sync with the western dances of today. I also feel that she has a bad attitude and is extremely rude. Just coz you are the judge you cannot be insulting towards anyone.

When Baichung had given his 1st performance, she had given him a 9 ! While Juhi & VM gave 6 & 7. She just goes overboard. If you are in her good books then great or else you face her wrath. SHE SHOULD BE BANNED FROM JUDGING REALITY SHOWS !

Although she was good to HardKaur (my darling) but still fact is fact.

But this also doesnt mean that Karan did not deserve what marks he got, in the end I feel that this was a Fare result.

(Saroj Khan fans, please dont get upset coz these are just my personal views and I too have given 30+ years of my life to Dance & Music)

Edited by ReemAnshu - 16 years ago

Quote

Nish

@nish_k

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

#39

Originally posted by: prerna4rishav
Now they'd say --

ALL these awards are rigged..!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

🤣

lol..

Quote

Kanchan Prashar

@kanchan.p

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: sinipillai

i think you didn't read all the comments...i am just copying from the 3rd page earlier i wrote for someone else .. i think my these lines fits you more...coz you said she is not a good jugde and unprofessional.... Wake up...

you are expecting Saroj ji and all other judges to say to Karan the following...

👏👏 Vowwww aapne kithna achaaa nachaa... Bina koi steps ke....

👏👏 Vowwww From the starting to the end you didn't show any improvements... well done...

👏👏 Vowwww Sab log ithna alag alag concepts kar rahe hai.. lekin aapki act mein kuch bhi naya nahi haii..... very good....

👏👏 Inspite of poor dancing in a dance reality show.... YOu are getting the higher vots..... WELL DONE..

Lists continues....................😃

LOL well she does blindly say that about bhaichung
gauhar is the only amazing dancer that reached the top3 buddy
she is unprofessional and NOTHING you say can change that sorry...
im not saying that because i love karan
im saying it because she IS... go watch the zara nach ke dikha finale if you dont beleive me :)

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

4 THOSE who don't know SAROJ ji's capability. - Page 4

Related Topics

Explore Topics