4 THOSE who don't know SAROJ ji's capability. - Page 3

Originally posted by: sinipillai

Thanks buddy for understanding.. the reason to open this topic...

She's probably the best in bollywood choreography.... For eg. If you've seen the song "Mehendi laga ke rakhna" from DDLJ.... The song includes steps but Kajol was just sitting and emoting...that also comes under choreography...How to move your hands and eyes and to give what expressions according to the lyrics of the song. And i believe Saroj ji is best for bollywood songs.

But being a great personality does'nt give you the right to be rude. You should be always humble and down to earth. Like SRK and BIG B. But im sorry to say Saroj ji is'nt. We've seen other reality shows also and her comments were rude manier times. Her comments are more of an insult sometimes. Im not talking about JDJ3 but other shows also in which i've seen her.

Originally posted by: BlueSoul

She's probably the best in bollywood choreography.... For eg. If you've seen the song "Mehendi laga ke rakhna" from DDLJ.... The song includes steps but Kajol was just sitting and emoting...that also comes under choreography...How to move your hands and eyes and to give what expressions according to the lyrics of the song. And i believe Saroj ji is best for bollywood songs.<br><br>But being a great personality does'nt give you the right to be rude. You should be always humble and down to earth. Like SRK and BIG B. But im sorry to say Saroj ji is'nt. We've seen other reality shows also and her comments were rude manier times. Her comments are more of an insult sometimes. Im not talking about JDJ3 but other shows also in which i've seen her.<br>

exactly my point...she has been a famous choreographer of her time...but wen it comes to judging...her parameters r not set... She is unpredictable n sometimes very insensible...for eg: during Nb2..dis particular dance act of shweta tiwari was not up to da mark n was a mediocre performance but jus cuz it was her birthday dat particular day she gave her a 9??..ahem wat is dis?... Second example is from jdj itself...(i had to bring out dis nt because m a kg fan but m a dancer myself n i seriously felt for it).. So in his khuda jaane act...let me tell u dis i myself watched it for lik 20 times...der was only one lift dat was a lil clumpsy..rest da dance was perfect..she gave dem 8 earlier n den changed it to 6 cuz she didnt find nothin new in da lifts!?? I mean 4 marks cut for dis reason..she even gave dem a 6 for der baaware performance which acc to me was kg's worst performance...so ders no difference between des two dances.. Dats y i think she should not judge any reality show's from now.. Cuz she is a confused personality...

We dint say she doesn't know how to dance obviously she does
Were just saying she doesn't need to be bias
and just because shes a choreographer she has no right to call karans dancing bekaar
I mean maybe shes very talented but that doesn't mean she has the right to say all that about someone else
How would u feel if in front of everyone i call u sucky dancer doesn't deserve to be in the show
How would u feel if i gave u less marks when it deserved more
Think about how u would feel
Im a karan fan but if someone called me bekaar in public i would surely be upset

I dont care about any performances and marks...Her comments does not matches her marks...That is what i feel. Once she told HK that this was the best performance of the episode and then gave her a 9 or 8 i guess😡 Why??? If it was THE BEST give her a 10.

Also there should b a difference in marks for those who performed worst, good and best. But sometimes the worst and the good scores equal and sometimes the good and the best score equal.

There should be a standard set for giving marks...sometimes they cut half of the marks for a stupid thing and sometimes they give full 10/10 even if there were flaws in the performance.

But still these things can be spared if you atleast speak properly. For eg. Juhi...she is the one who gave the most annoying marks throughout the show but coz she speaks politely... half of her problem is solved.

i do believe that Saroj ji is an extremely talented and experienced choreographer...i have no doubts about her capabilities in that sphere at all, we've seen enough of her work to let it do the talking as far as her skills as a choreographer are concerned...she's brilliant in what she does...but just like a bunch of degrees does not necessarily make you a good teacher, a heap of talent may still leave your objectivity as a judge lacking in some respects...i agree that she is a learned lady in her field, but even that does not make her word the be all and end all of dance...and that holds good for every judge in every reality show, not just Saroj ji in Jhalak...😊

Originally posted by: sakshiluvskaran

okkkk what AMV stands for?

It was on Star Plus -- Aaja Mahi Vay!! With my babies as Judges🤣 And SK used to dominate others😡😡Creating fights and all😡😡

All this is fine and the attitude she brings in with experience is highly unacceptable.....????That too ATTITUDE that hurts others....👎🏼

Thank you for posting it. But I am going to leave before I read any of those comments that I find ridiculous. Since she didn't favor Karan despite the fact that she is the queen of her field she is not a good judge.😆

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

Thank you for posting it. But I am going to leave before I read any of those comments that I find ridiculous. Since she didn't favor Karan despite the fact that she is the queen of her field she is not a good judge.😆

Someone should post Vaibhabi's list too. Both of them are amazing. I wish people would give them merit and realize they know what they are talking about.

it might be slightly more fair if you would give them a read before dismissing them all as ridiculous...would make it much easier to have a discussion...😊 i agree, some bit of what you might find will be quite irrelevant, but all of it may not be the same...

just a thought, since i've noticed how so many times relevant arguments are dismissed on both sides like this, and end up getting lost while the silliest of statements spark off a battlefield...makes any rational discussion impossible...and this just because a few irrelevant posts put people off...that's been a major hurdle on this forum for a very long time...😳