The idiosyncracies of the show...!! - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

61

Views

3.4k

Users

28

Frequent Posters

hide thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Pebblez



So yea. The basic point is, stop being so biased against him. He's just another contestant. And yah, whether he deserves to be there or not, depends on the voters. All those anti-Karan, you can just vote for the ones you like, and get off the guy's back. Its all the time yak-yak-yak about either Karan or Shraddha or Nicole or the blog or the dance or the godforsaken kisses and how they are seriously proving to be a hazard to your sensitive little hearts.

P.s. No offence meant, i am not here for fighting. I just need to make a stance and stand by it for him.

Kiran



i agree to your post here..
hide thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: *Huma*


I don't think Karan is the only celeb that Sony have taken digs at, there have been digs on Bhaghyashree, Gauhar, Monica, Parul, HK etc etc.. So my point, its not only Karan who has been subjected to this. Its the channel's way of creating drama. And dude they are creating this drama so that his fans become over-zealous and vote double/ triple, which is what is happening. Hence the channel wins; its a win-win situation for them.

'Any publicity is good publicity..'

About your statement: "No. Its "dancing with the Stars" which means, definitely, the popular ones get through." You are contradicting yourself; its a dancing show, hence the celebrity with dancing talent should win, and personally right this moment coz of Karan a well deserving celeb who was also popular and COULD dance had to loose out.

in the end it benefits them; they gain more popularity and come in the public eye, and eventually people forget about what happened in the show.




i agree to the above points raised by you
hide thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: alias

Dude, this is an open forum and is meant to have arguments/ discussion. When JDJ started- everyone was pouncing on Gauhar- then HK and then Parul....where were u then? U didnt come to their rescue.
And now it's Karan's turn.

People have every right to voice their thoughts- just as you say people have every right to vote whoever they want.

Important thing is how you counter argue their thoughts vs ur own and provide RATIONAL reasoning to back your thoughts. If you are not capable to do so then please don't jump into conclusion that everyone is Karan haters or after Karan just cause.


People are after KARAN for a REASON and they have every right to make their case. Although, I am against bashing and I see some members bashing him but U cant generalize everyone being haters.
We are here to PUT FORTH a valid DISCUSSION. (some maybe unreasonable but reasonable ones- CAN YOU SAY ANYTHING AGAINST THOSE?? If yes, then please POST.

If no, then please dont open random topics claiming 'Oh why is everyone after Karan'........They are AFTER him because they can't understand the choice being made by the VOTERS despite a mediocre Performance....I read the crap you wrote about Dancing with the STARs.....lolzzz...Trust me u dont want to drag that discussion with moi. 😉

One more thing- If you do make a valid point then I would concur otherwise...bring on the discussion!! Also u'l have to hear sides as well.


valid points.. i do believe that this is an open forum and is meant to have arguments/ discussion

TK368 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: *Huma*






About your statement: "No. Its "dancing with the Stars" which means, definitely, the popular ones get through."
You are contradicting yourself; its a dancing show, hence the celebrity with dancing talent should win, and personally right this moment coz of Karan a well deserving celeb who was also popular and COULD dance had to loose out.




umm hello, karan is not the best dancer agreed?? yess

hard kaur was hte best agreed?? yess

umm where is the logic becoz of karan she had to leave??
everytime u do bad with the judges ALL THE CELEBS ask junta to vote for them, karan supporters vote for him since hes been doing badd!!! LIke gauher said int eh last eppy, "votes are asked for when scores arent on ur side, so vote for me"" thats the pt of them!! and if they are in karans favor so wat!!

and if hard kaur was doing good rather, but still didnt get votes, so u are saying karan should not ask for votes, and say vote for the others b/c im not good enuff!! no not really!!
dance or no dance, its a COMPETITION and everyone wants to win, they were good dancers b4 too that got out

its not like karan is asking for all ppl in india to vote jsut for him, only ppl that like him!! if u guys are so hung up on hard kaur(whom i wanted to win) vote for her next time, shes in a realtiy show and make her win!!! judges let her go, even she said in an interview that she was tensed during dance off, but judges should looked at her past record!!

and its not like she gonna come back if karan leaves!!
Edited by tara5989 - 16 years ago
cutie_ketu thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: Pebblez

Okay, seriously. This forum is one i visit the least, and since the very start of the show, i have seen people crib, complain and go on non-stop about Karan, Karan Karan....Karan this, Karan that...!!! So clearly, he is the most popular star of the show, whether you like him or not. But anyways, thats not why um here. All i wanted to say is, this show is seriously turning idiotic now.

First thing, I clearly remember the logo of the show; dancing with the STARS. Which means, celebrities, of course. And so it should be damn well clear that in celebrities, one or two would be more popular than the others. Then they dragged in Karan Singh Grover, who happens to be amongst the top rated television stars today. And thats when the drama started.

What i dont understand is why everyone is all the time taking digs at him? Karan is as much of a celebrity as the others; i dont see them being dragged into every statement the hosts make. I agree, he is far more popular with a huge fan following; so is that a crime on the show? Can you stop people from voting? I dont frikking get what the hell is everyone's problem with his fan following voting for him. Is it a 'Search India for Talent Dance Show'? No. Its "dancing with the Stars" which means, definitely, the popular ones get through.

They go on and on about how his voting is so much more than others, and its unfair. How come? Isnt it the pattern of the show? If the voting irks them so much, why not totally make a judge-based show, on 'pure dancing' talent. I bet they would have a big financial problem, not to mention low TRP s in it.

See, Sony's giving us a show that's about stars and dancing. Just learn to enjoy dance, rather than fret about it. If i get down to HOW unfair the show has been to Karan, and how he's been facing such a biased behavior from the judges, than it'd be definitely a very long post. All i want to say is, they are just too hypocritical to HAVE him in the show and then take digs at him. Come on, take Karan out tomorrow, their TRPs are gonna drop within ONE episode. I. Can. Frikking. Bet.

So yea. The basic point is, stop being so biased against him. He's just another contestant. And yah, whether he deserves to be there or not, depends on the voters. All those anti-Karan, you can just vote for the ones you like, and get off the guy's back. Its all the time yak-yak-yak about either Karan or Shraddha or Nicole or the blog or the dance or the godforsaken kisses and how they are seriously proving to be a hazard to your sensitive little hearts.

P.s. No offence meant, i am not here for fighting. I just need to make a stance and stand by it for him.

Kiran



m totally wid ur statement......everyword u wrote is damn truth
rittu_deep thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#36

Well, I do not agree with the topic starter at all...Many chances were given to Karan but still we are not able to see something very special in his performances.I wish, had Ugesh Sarcar or Bhagyashree that much fan following, they would also have been also in top 5.
Please don't judge a book with its cover.People here are not voting for Karan, sadly they are voting for 'Armaan Mallik' from Dill Mill Gaye...

sakshiluvskaran thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#37
agree with you amazing post.... see other participants are also celebrities but only karan has been blamed for his votes and fan-following... calling him bad boy and then superstar... i agree he is a notch higher in fan-following than other contestants but sony knew before getting him... and as far as trp thing i agree with you there was a topic in this forum that who will leave watching jdj once karan is out and 65%people said they will... so we all know that karan is popular even getting him on the show meant a lot of votes.... there is no ambiguity there... and girl i agree with dancing with the stars thing it never said its a talent hunt or something... the most popular person will take away the trophy thats it...
sakshiluvskaran thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: rittu_084

Well, I do not agree with the topic starter at all...Many chances were given to Karan but still we are not able to see something very special in his performances.I wish, had Ugesh Sarcar or Bhagyashree that much fan following, they would also have been also in top 5.
Please don't judge a book with its cover.People here are not voting for Karan, sadly they are voting for 'Armaan Mallik' from Dill Mill Gaye...


jst a sec gal how can you make this assumption... i am not voting for armaan i am voting for karan he is our karan... i always loved karan more than armaan... gal armaan is a fictional character and karan has lived that character perfectly but there is no point saying that his fans vote for his armaanness...
Riddikulus thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: sakshiluvskaran


jst a sec gal how can you make this assumption... i am not voting for armaan i am voting for karan he is our karan... i always loved karan more than armaan... gal armaan is a fictional character and karan has lived that character perfectly but there is no point saying that his fans vote for his armaanness...

Agree with you Sakshi...that is what i said in reply to another post...that just as every person who criticises Karan cannot be categorized as a Hater, every person who praises him cannot be categorized as a K-Babe who votes for Armaan rather than Karan...there are such people here, i will not deny that, but that does not in any way imply that all his supporters are the same...think about it...😊
and yes, you do have a valid point there...but the topic is meant for those who often cross the line of constructive criticism or expression of opinion, and become outrightly insulting...whether Karan deserves to be on the show or not, he certainly does not deserve to be insulted, as do any of us here...that's all...😊
Edited by nandinidev - 16 years ago
sakshiluvskaran thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#40


Agree with you Sakshi...that is what i said in reply to another post...that just as every person who criticises Karan cannot be categorized as a Hater, every person who praises him cannot be categorized as a K-Babe who votes for Armaan rather than Karan...there are such people here, i will not deny that, but that does not in any way imply that all his supporters are the same...think about it...😊
and yes, you do have a valid point there...but the topic is meant for those who often cross the line of constructive criticism or expression of opinion, and become outrightly insulting...whether Karan deserves to be on the show or not, he certainly does not deserve to be insulted, as do any of us here...that's all...😊


thanks nandini... i agree that he is not the best dancer of the lot but i also like the way he handles the situation when he is insulted... now when i wrote this i wanted to say that criticism and praise are two sides of a coin and when you do only one of the two you cant be regarded as a fan either you are a hater and hold some acrimony or a sychophant ... and with this i can say i am his fan thats all.... i never said he is the best dancer but when people go on to question his character or our ethics then i get enraged and defend him coz none of us know him in personal... i love the character of armaan and i also agree karan is playing it but then it doesnt means i am voting for him just coz he plays armaan or for any matter his physique... i watch TV for entertainment and in jdj i can say karan's performance entertained me... i am not a virtuoso in dancing so cant see the technicalities but i vote for him seeing the whole thing not just dance his expressions and modesty make me vote for him

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".