Voting - Talent or popularity? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Disha60

Popularity might win but I feel talent is always the true winner....it finds its way!!

Originally posted by: pksanam

yeah, you might achieve fame and you might go far but most of the times, it never wins.. true winner is perspective, isn't it.. in my eyes or in your's eyes, true winner is someone who is talented.. but we're talking about actual results.. where rarely talent wins.. although, there are a few exceptions.. but when celebs are involved, it is always popularity..

yeah but the fact is fact...as u see tat how even after Mona winning the first season its still said tat Shweta shud win but Mona won only coz she has a gr8 fan following, same is said for Prachi too & I think this is enough to change the whole scenerio n ones prospect...it'll continue till the time the talent becomes the winner!

Originally posted by: raj5000

History speaks for itself, this time am hoping for a change!

IMHO - they all are at a scale one, based on my perception of talent/dancing background/accomplishment/training etc etc ... initial 2 - 3 eliminations would mean they don't even fit the scale 1, lols but from there based on what they learn/improve and progress/accomplish strictly focusing on show in terms of dancing skills , stage presentation, overall atitude, popularity would be key to bet ma money on. Good Luck to all of them, may the best win.

Originally posted by: realitybites

So u mean its like a learning school! 😆, ala graduation dance😉😆😆 ok Anshuman-just kidding😳! Sadly the history of JDJ is popularity beating talent hands down. The charac played by the popular contestant is embedded so deeply into the minds of the ardent fans that they refuse to acknowledge the real person with real skills and hence the unyielding support. To add to it I do think the channel also looks for increasing TRPs in return. So the popular contestant must guarantee regular viewership along with votes. Still I do hope that may the talented one win⭐️

Originally posted by: raj5000

😆😆 Oye Lavvy, u are here too 😆 j/ks. No yaa, I don't mean learning school literally but it does seems fair that way, specially considering the mix of celebs with different backgrounds and knowledge of dance etc. Atleast as a filtering criteria, later when last 4-5 are left by God's Grace 😆 calls can be made based of other factors😉😆

I know Mr. Ram ko dekh kar lagta hai, itna pareshan kiya Bani ko and here he is enjoying with other chicks so unfair 😆😆 its like Mr. Walia can you please stop acting kiddish and check on Bani back stage is she is doing okay.. 😉😆

hear yaa on what you said....hahahaha finally Mullah ki ran Masjid tak..i mean all about trp trp and trp. We should send millions of melodramatic petitions to the show makers, if anyone of the popular celeb is eliminated and not vote, thats how they will understand, playing emotions/sentiments is not a good thing😆

Originally posted by: realitybites

Yeah me😳 Yattra Tatra Sarvatra 😆😆. I agree its like getting trained with the choreographer. Coming to Mr Ram well havent ever watched the serial so dont know!😃 but see in real life women suffer so to for cathartic effect they make men suffer in serials😆😆. Yeah the guy was having fun😉 in wife's absence! TRP means revenue from advs so it rules the minds of channel heads. Yeap agree with you, no emotional atyachar please😆 not to play with member emotions😉..ooops viewer emotions.

Originally posted by: raj5000

@Bold, 😆😆😆 Sense of Humor 👏😆 Oh boy, tummy aches. Lets see what happens this tiem around... Kya talent ki Popularity par vijay hoggi... kyaa popular celeb bhi kabhi talented thaaa... dekhna nah bhuliya JDJ3 sir sony par😆

Originally posted by: hahaz

I dont think that you can blame the public for voting based on popularity since the format allows for public voting....if they wanted a winner solely based upon merit then they shouldn't have public voting at all.