Voting - Talent or popularity?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

kash4life

@kash4life

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

#11

obvioulsy popularity over talent but that is completely expected

you vote for some one you like and people like karan have sloid fan bases who ishallah will vote for him lol

but talent obbviously does creep in but i think there is no problem with voting on talent because you want a liked person to win becsue you know tht other people support them too

so im voting on both popularty and talent but my vote will ALWAYS go to KARA because i ama FAN of his

Quote

sawani3

@sawani3

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#12

It should be based on talent.But whenver there is public voting its based on popularity.Most of reality show are that way,popularity, regionalism play important

role.

Unfortunate but true.

All contestants are working hard not only particular ones & lot of prople have potential but only popular ones will get chance.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

@lilmoonprincess

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#13

Of course popularity WINS over! But i am wondering.. if wasn't for these celebrities will JDJ 3 work???

People like to watch reality shows because they have a reason to cheer their favorite stars!! they like to see them dance their hearts off and vote for them!! NOW from previous results i would say that yes the tellywood wins it all! But it has also been witnessed that some of these "unknown" stars have gotten to the height of their popularity because of this show!!

Plus.. are we forgetting that these stars work as hard as the next person to win this.. it doesn't come easy to them!! plus some of them have on going TV shows.. so they have to work TWICE as hard!!!

Season 2 when Prachi won. i was soo mad the way they treated her!!! she won the show FAIR! alot of ppl would say NO.. it wasn't fair cuz the Sandhiya was a better dancer! given that she was a better dancer and worked so hard to get to the finale! BUT did prachi work any less hard.. In fact she had to work harder because she had to prove herself!!! But no appreciate went her way! and she was wrapped in this whole controvesy!!! that was UNFAIR!!!

Now speaking of TALENT! if we are basing this one on Talent! then the scores in this season is already on a bad start!

Edited by lilmoonprincess - 16 years ago

Quote

MohitSanayaFan

@MohitSanayaFan

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#14

based on past results, being a well-known tv star and showing improvement over time are steps for success

Quote

unknown cute

@yogzz

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#15

i would say popularity with talent..............n karan is working very hard....

Quote

Wrackspurt

@Wrackspurt

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#16

It was and always be Popularity over talent.But along with popularity there should also be some talent cause otherwise Sandhya Mridul wouldnt have been one of the finalists of JDJ in the last season....cause there were others who were much more popular than her.

Quote

Ishaqzaadi

@Ishaqzaadi

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

#17

Popularity & showing hard work/improvement

Its baseless if some good dancer comes & wins...thats boring..theyre good/trained dancers already

its more fun to see someone come & improve thru the show and of course popularity helps

because who wants to waste money voting for someone theyre not a fan of

if ur not a fan you might vote once or twice coz you liked the persons performance...but if ur a fan ur gona want ur fav to stay happy and stay in the competition so ul go kangaal voting..thats jus the way it goes !

Quote

@pksanam

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: Preeti_285
Popularity & showing hard work/improvement

Its baseless if some good dancer comes & wins...thats boring..theyre good/trained dancers already

its more fun to see someone come & improve thru the show and of course popularity helps

because who wants to waste money voting for someone theyre not a fan of

if ur not a fan you might vote once or twice coz you liked the persons performance...but if ur a fan ur gona want ur fav to stay happy and stay in the competition so ul go kangaal voting..thats jus the way it goes !

exactly.. well put.. so it's always popularity who wins.. of course, everyone works hard.. not only one's fav..!! and not just the fav who show the improvement, many others do, but it is never appreciated the same.. so they have that unfair advantage always.. when it comes to talent wins or popularity wins - it is always popularity.. never the talent..!!

Quote

LadyMcbeth

@LadyMcbeth

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#19

Ideally talent alone should win ... but we all know that is NEVER the case. History is witness
- Mona Singh vs. Shweta Salve - better dancer Shweta Salve, winner: Mona Singh!
- Sandhya Mridul vs. Prachi Desai - better dancer Sandhya Mridul, winner: Prachi Desai!

Strictly my views, no offense to any fans!