Someone messaged this thread to me on facebook and so I'm commenting, simply because I feel obliged to lift some ignorance here.
First of all, LOL at the fact that such a topic was even started. If you seriously think that Isha is faking an injury, then I simply have no words for you. That woman is the best dancer in the show, and nobody denies that. Sure, she is trained but so what. There is no clause that forbids a trained dancer from participating in the show. Isha is a trained aerial dancer, yet she has given an astounding number of outstanding performances on the floor as well. Whether it be paso doble or the horror act, Solstorm or ballroom dancing--she has done each one to perfection, heck she even did the machata/pole dance to perfection. So what are we going to say now, she's a trained pole dancer LMAO.
It would be foolish to even consider that anybody else deserves the trophy more than her, and she had no benefit in pretending to break her arm. The woman could have danced every week and gotten a thirty, and not risked her position in the show, so why in blue hell would she pretend to have an injury.
As for putting on clothes with a cast, let me address that as well. Whether she has a dislocation or a hairline fracture is still up for grabs, since everybody has a different opinion. In either case, the purpose of a cast is simply to securely keep the arm in place so that no strain is caused. After a few weeks of keeping the cast on, often doctors will allow you to switch that cast for one which is in fact removable--to clean the skin and other purposes. It is possible that she have a cast that can be taken off for brief moments of time, however it is also possible to slip material underneath a cast. This is simply because the cast is not glued to your flesh, to allow plenty of breathing room.
If you have any further questions regarding this, pm me and I will refer you to the links of Encyclpedia Brittanica which detail this further--because I don't feel like giving an anatomy lecture at the moment.
As for Gurmeet, he's a great dancer, and he has proven that multiple times. However, Isha and in fact both Rithvik and Rashmi as well are performing better than him at the moment. Wish him a hearty comeback, but in the mean time--MAY THE BEST CONTESTANT WIN.
Cheers,
-Marvee