Judges r too biased

I feel that last week judges decision was biased... Though I am not from dance field n don't have much knowledge abt dance but as a viewer, in last week where concept is of childhood, I loved the rashmi's perf which was enjoyable n their steps, lifts n expressions were too good n most imp they stick to concept childhood they shld get 30 but judges gave them only 27,very sad... Where as at other hand sal-isha's performance was not that good n ... N most imp I feel that their perf was far frm concept... What I understand n think abt concept childhood is that one shld perf n dance with portraying the actions, emotions, feelings n expresstion of the child on particular situation... And with that in my opinion sal-isha's perf shld hv been disqualified by judges as their perf was on fairytail n their exp n emotions were that of mutured couple... If one who doesn't know abt that fairytail n watches their performance than I m sure that one cannt find any relation of their perf with childhood... Judges are too biased...

Originally posted by: PURVIVA

I feel that last week judges decision was biased... Though I am not from dance field n don't have much knowledge abt dance but as a viewer, in last week where concept is of childhood, I loved the rashmi's perf which was enjoyable n their steps, lifts n expressions were too good n most imp they stick to concept childhood they shld get 30 but judges gave them only 27,very sad... Where as at other hand sal-isha's performance was not that good n ... N most imp I feel that their perf was far frm concept... What I understand n think abt concept childhood is that one shld perf n dance with portraying the actions, emotions, feelings n expresstion of the child on particular situation... And with that in my opinion sal-isha's perf shld hv been disqualified by judges as their perf was on fairytail n their exp n emotions were that of mutured couple... If one who doesn't know abt that fairytail n watches their performance than I m sure that one cannt find any relation of their perf with childhood... Judges are too biased...

Rest is your opinion, so won't be commenting !!! As per the bold part, every child has different experiences which includes from books to school to activities to family to friends to everything. Every child goes through different experiences of life. There might have been some who know of the book and can relate to it, so for them Isha's performance was bang on, then there could have been some kids, which Rithvik displayed, having a dysfunctional family, not every child will relate to it, so that doesn't mean their performance deviated from the theme (I didn't relate to it cuz I haven't gone through that phase), and not every child goes through the fun element which Rashmi displayed, there are those kids who aren't even fortunate to go to school or even have the time or opportunity to have fun, not every child can have happy childhood, that doesn't mean Rashmi should have been disqualified. These are merely some examples. Basically if we were to follow your logic, I am sure every performance would have been disqualified for the one reason or other. So you want to criticize, do it fairly, and if not, then don't go around assuming that people can't relate to Isha's performance because that's individual perception.

My 2 cents. Simply my opinion based on what I deciphered from your statement.

oh please it has already been discussed that judges are biased ... . who in the world dnt knw about fairytales 😆😆 kamal ki baat kar rhe ho ...fairytale is all about childhood ...y dont u pin point rithvik's perfrmance ...they also played a matured couple ... DISQUALIFIED 😆

Don't bother criticising Isha on this forum, cause it'll be termed bashing, and the next minute your thread will be shut thanks to the amount of hate you'll invite.
As for your topic, I totally agree, there was no concept of childhood there except they wore those outfits, but obviously Isha's mahaaan dance obviously blinded the judges that they deviated from the theme AS USUAL. There's one jhalak for Isha-Salman and a different one for the other contestants.

Originally posted by: aa123.80

Don't bother criticising Isha on this forum, cause it'll be termed bashing, and the next minute your thread will be shut thanks to the amount of hate you'll invite.
As for your topic, I totally agree, there was no concept of childhood there except they wore those outfits, but obviously Isha's mahaaan dance obviously blinded the judges that they deviated from the theme AS USUAL. There's one jhalak for Isha-Salman and a different one for the other contestants.

Your thread was closed for many reasons, there were some who started getting personal and that also includes you as far as I have seen and I am not talking about you criticizing Isha. When people start getting personal and take dig at each other, that's when thread closes. Sometimes it's not even TM's fault.

And I completely disagree that they deviated from the theme. But then people will see what they want to see, rest is simply ignored including judges and their judgement.

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi-

Your thread was closed for many reasons, there were some who started getting personal and that also includes you as far as I have seen and I am not talking about you criticizing Isha. When people start getting personal and take dig at each other, that's when thread closes. Sometimes it's not even TM's fault.

And I completely disagree that they deviated from the theme. But then people will see what they want to see, rest is simply ignored including judges and their judgement.

Erm, so where have I argued about the reasons why it got closed? I was talking about the general reaction that a criticism post will invite here on this forum, and I saw it yesterday. And that's what led to that thread getting closed.
The rest is your opinion, so I can't comment on that.
And I better not discuss my thread here, cause it's obviously deviating from this thread.

Originally posted by: aa123.80

Erm, so where have I argued about the reasons why it got closed? I was talking about the general reaction that a criticism post will invite here on this forum, and I saw it yesterday. And that's what led to that thread getting closed.
The rest is your opinion, so I can't comment on that.
And I better not discuss my thread here, cause it's obviously deviating from this thread.

Any sorta criticism isn't going to be accepted by everyone, there will be others who don't agree with you but when people start acting immaturely from either end, it becomes a catastrophe and the thread gets closed, and it happens in every forum not only this one. So you just have to deal with it unfortunately. And yes, I leave it here.

Originally posted by: aa123.80

Don't bother criticising Isha on this forum, cause it'll be termed bashing, and the next minute your thread will be shut thanks to the amount of hate you'll invite.
As for your topic, I totally agree, there was no concept of childhood there except they wore those outfits, but obviously Isha's mahaaan dance obviously blinded the judges that they deviated from the theme AS USUAL. There's one jhalak for Isha-Salman and a different one for the other contestants.

+1

Originally posted by: PURVIVA

I feel that last week judges decision was biased... Though I am not from dance field n don't have much knowledge abt dance but as a viewer, in last week where concept is of childhood, I loved the rashmi's perf which was enjoyable n their steps, lifts n expressions were too good n most imp they stick to concept childhood they shld get 30 but judges gave them only 27,very sad... Where as at other hand sal-isha's performance was not that good n ... N most imp I feel that their perf was far frm concept... What I understand n think abt concept childhood is that one shld perf n dance with portraying the actions, emotions, feelings n expresstion of the child on particular situation... And with that in my opinion sal-isha's perf shld hv been disqualified by judges as their perf was on fairytail n their exp n emotions were that of mutured couple... If one who doesn't know abt that fairytail n watches their performance than I m sure that one cannt find any relation of their perf with childhood... Judges are too biased...

wen salman isha gets 30 ...all of a sudden..judges bcomes biased..wen their favrts gets 30 oh remo dsouza knws the mst..he can never be wrong...
Such hypocrisy runs here...they can say watever on the name of opinion...nd we cant even defend..grt