Views on Challenges given to contestants this week - Page 5

Originally posted by: Khushi.

Hey,

I am amongst those who said that dancing in a three is easy. Yes! It is easy and that is why you see such good group performances on TV. Dunno about other comments but I personally added that dancing in a three is anytime easy compared to dancing with a ball using illusion or dancing with hands tied or dancing while one is up and one is down or dancing with a live singer WHEN you have a GOOD dancer who is the third one to dance with you. Because a good dancer will always dance good and will always have the knowlegde of beats and rhythm and co-ordination because they dance well.

Dancing in a trio IS NOT easy- i said that too but it is defiently easier when A.) You have a good 3rd dancer dancing with you . B.)When other contestants have challenges like dancing with a ball using illusion and etc.

I agree with Sweety here that - They should have given the same challenge to all.

Originally posted by: atria

But the scores you have given (two 30, two 26) were pretty good for last season when they were not handing out 30s like laddoos as in this season. So dancing with trio is not that hard also. The point is that Isha is a damn good dancer, so for HER, this is not a particularly difficult thing to do. Salman is a good enough choreographer, and for him it can't be that hard to compose a trio dance with three good dancers (Karnvir is a good dancer I believe, I may be wrong). Savio may have a tougher time with Tushar and Bharti, but I guess they will do some comedy. So of all the challenges I still believe that Isha got the easiest one for her. Yes, the darkness of my ignorance is blinding, you may continue to laugh at me.😃

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

How many times people judge the performance on group dancing? That group dance and challange is entirely difference madam.

Originally posted by: Khushi.

Why is it different? People are more then 3 in number and they all dance in co-ordination. And that is what has to be judged mainly while dancing with someone else now be then 2 4 or 10..you need to judge how well co-ordinated everyone is and setting this co-ordination is difficult too but when everyone in the group( be it a group of 2 or 3 or 10) everyone dances well then its not that difficult..right?

We need to come out of the illusion, dancing is not like your finger... ke 1 finger cant do anything aor jab paanchon mil jaate to mutthi ban jaati hai...

@HakkaBakka- Cool! 😊I respect your POV as well.

Originally posted by: Khushi.

@HakkaBakka- Cool! 😊I respect your POV as well.

@Hakkabakka, can't quote your reply, its getting too long, but wanted to continue the discussion. Okay to look at the marks last year for all the dancers for the previous week and week after--

Ragini:
Week before: 30
that week: 21
Week after: 26

Chang:
Week before: 28
that week: 26
Week after: 29

Daya:
Week before: 22
That week: 21
Week after: 23

Ankita:
Week Before: 26
That week: 26
Week after: 26

Shekhar
Week Before: 23
That week: 21
Week after: 23

Yana
Week Before: 30
That week: 30
Week after: 21

Krushna:
Week before: 29
That week: 20
Eliminated

Sushant
Week Before: 30
That week: 30
Week after: 27

Mahi
Week Before:21
that week: 25
Week after: 21

To me the thing that stands out is that for the weaker dancers it IS easier to dance without a third person, since co-ordination is less of a worry. But for the two strong dancers of that season, Yana and Sushant, it was as easy as the previous week (30s) and actually easier than the next week (21 & 27 resp). As I said in the previous post, Isha is a good dancer, for HER (not for any of the others), this is NOT a challenge at all, not even close. I stand by that POV and marks of last year seem to support that POV also. Be reasonable.😃

Originally posted by: atria

@Hakkabakka, can't quote your reply, its getting too long, but wanted to continue the discussion. Okay to look at the marks last year for all the dancers for the previous week and week after--

Ragini:
Week before: 30
that week: 21
Week after: 26

Chang:
Week before: 28
that week: 26
Week after: 29

Daya:
Week before: 22
That week: 21
Week after: 23

Ankita:
Week Before: 26
That week: 26
Week after: 26

Shekhar
Week Before: 23
That week: 21
Week after: 23

Yana
Week Before: 30
That week: 30
Week after: 21

Krushna:
Week before: 29
That week: 20
Eliminated

Sushant
Week Before: 30
That week: 30
Week after: 27

Mahi
Week Before:21
that week: 25
Week after: 21

To me the thing that stands out is that for the weaker dancers it IS easier to dance without a third person, since co-ordination is less of a worry. But for the two strong dancers of that season, Yana and Sushant, it was as easy as the previous week (30s) and actually easier than the next week (21 & 27 resp). As I said in the previous post, Isha is a good dancer, for HER (not for any of the others), this is NOT a challenge at all, not even close. I stand by that POV and marks of last year seem to support that POV also. Be reasonable.😃

Agree with you on Isha & Bharti's challenge. It's not a proper challenge at all compared to others. They should have been given tough tasks