Clearing some misconceptions about redemption - Page 20

Created

Last reply

Replies

314

Views

19.1k

Users

73

Likes

1.7k

Frequent Posters

RickyBahl thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
I wud like to tell

the writers are also humans, they can also make wrong decisions.
since they are working in entertainment industry and since we adore these creative people, it doesnt mean they are GOD or 100 % perfect.
Their way of interpreting scenes can go wrong.
They are not almighty , that whatever they have written is the final destiny.

Many hav illusion that they can nevr be wrong, since they are Cv's.
For me Cv's are same as us having two ears, two eyes, 1 nose, 2 legs and importantly a brain to think rationally.

So whats the big deal if they accept their mistakes and correct it.
Nobody can have monopoly over Creativity. If audience is giving some feedback it shud be accepted with humility. Which TV show has such a fanbase that is active in giving feedback?None. Only IPK fans.

Or else have they taken the egoistic characteristics of their lead hero??

FairyLiquidSoap thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: AyeReKhushi

I'll add one more note...it doesn't feel like a redemption track because Khushi is still being humiliated now.

If it was proper redemption/wooing, we would be enjoying it along with Khushi. Why was there a need to drag Dadi into the story out of the blue, just so Arnav can jump in and defend Khushi while she gets humiliated unnecessarily. Arnav is redeeming himself...but once again, it comes at Khushi's expense.

These writers will destroy Khushi's character depth and growth; put her through every humiliation and pain and forget it the next moment; make her act irrational one minute, mature the next; make her the most inconsistent and disrespected person on the show; they'll make her do whatever it takes to make the other characters look good. She's their favorite punching bag. These writers suck...that's the only way I can put it mildly, without saying what I really think about them.

you hit the nail Priyanka we would not be this pissed if they had shown her having some spirit and fight back walking with her head held high like she did before I am not talking about an egoistical stance but a spirited stand and when she looks like this helpless hapless victim which she never allowed herself to be be last it gets my goat
Her character has been eroded just to make another look great and that is not a fair
-DKS- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: RickyBahl

I wud like to tell


the writers are also humans, they can also make wrong decisions.
since they are working in entertainment industry and since we adore these creative people, it doesnt mean they are GOD or 100 % perfect.
Their way of interpreting scenes can go wrong.
They are not almighty , that whatever they have written is the final destiny.

Many hav illusion that they can nevr be wrong, since they are Cv's.
For me Cv's are same as us having two ears, two eyes, 1 nose, 2 legs and importantly a brain to think rationally.

So whats the big deal if they accept their mistakes and correct it.
Nobody can have monopoly over Creativity. If audience is giving some feedback it shud be accepted with humility. Which TV show has such a fanbase that is active in giving feedback?None. Only IPK fans.

Or else have they taken the egoistic characteristics of their lead hero??

How can you forget the dreadful "dekhna he toh dekho" dialogue from GH?
OnepoundChic thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: rima

thanks for trying buddy
nice of you
but i never tried because those morons will never listen
anyone in their right mind will not show a lovely haracter like khushi abused without any good treatment for one and half years
yet i watch it just for sarun now


i requested with hope ,but some where i have zero hopes!
same here watching 4 san barun nd cast!
Firebolt thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: RickyBahl

I wud like to tell


the writers are also humans, they can also make wrong decisions.
since they are working in entertainment industry and since we adore these creative people, it doesnt mean they are GOD or 100 % perfect.
Their way of interpreting scenes can go wrong.
They are not almighty , that whatever they have written is the final destiny.

Many hav illusion that they can nevr be wrong, since they are Cv's.
For me Cv's are same as us having two ears, two eyes, 1 nose, 2 legs and importantly a brain to think rationally.

So whats the big deal if they accept their mistakes and correct it.
Nobody can have monopoly over Creativity. If audience is giving some feedback it shud be accepted with humility. Which TV show has such a fanbase that is active in giving feedback?None. Only IPK fans.

Or else have they taken the egoistic characteristics of their lead hero??



Yes they can. Which why im still here, in fact thats the reason all of us are here, hoping that the writers do something whith our beloved story.
charlotte74 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: ..Kirann..


Answer to your bold: Because she is IN LOVE! She's HOPELESSLY in love with a man who has RUINED her life, her dreams, her respect, her EVERYTHING! Now that's her BIGGEST MISTAKE! Isn't it? She should pay for it and she's paying badly.



Khushi could have saved herself from being RUINED that night ... ... she could have told everyone about Shyam right then and there... should have put the truth out and there ... and waited for the outcome... she should have slapped that B!@#$%#, kicked or clawed at Shyam on that night in the terrace for grabbing her...
CDlove thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Firebolt

Hiru you know my thoughts on that/those damn writers who write disgusting and cringe worthy dialogue from the 19th century. Gul decides the story not the script. Which is just staggeringly bad on some days.

Its just a way to pacify my self love. If i have to continue watching it (god knows im not goin to stop) i have to start being less antagonistic about everything.

True that. I just watch it for the sake of watching it but really it pains me the way they handled the story after the kidnapping track
I did have a lot of respect for gul and still do but I wish she could stick to the characterisation and bring the brilliance she showed 13 months back. It's not always possible to be brilliant but at least come up with something logical and that goes with the storyline and characters? I feel her priorities have shifted and personally I feel we know about the story and has a better hang of it than she does because she has shifted from the initial line of the story.
but that's strictly my personal opinion 😆
Edited by CDlove - 13 years ago
Nmyra thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
Rima! Thank GOD!

I swear some of the posts were giving me a headache - I'm thinking in my head actions are all good and fine but the words need to be there too!!

See look at Darcy -- I personally LOVE what he did for Lydia --- BUT one has to ask if we didn't have the letter before that, and him bringing Bingley and Jane together later would we have gone all gaga over him?

or would we have been --- hmmph...fine...the guys not a total jerk...

ASR needing redemption is not about what KKG wants or needs --- It's about him redeeming himself in his own eyes, and the viewers of course, if what he's doing now is considered 'enough' in his own eyes than he is not HALF the man i thought he was.

And also -- on a side note -- just because people want to see the man repent does not make them ASR haters/bashers some forum-ites need to grow up and stop throwing around the 'B' word --- it's beginning to get very aggravating. Learn to accept that just because someone has a different opinion than you do does not make them wrong and you right or you a 'fan' and them a 'basher' .

Peace Out,

Nmyra
-DKS- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: charlotte74



Khushi could have saved herself from being RUINED that night ... ... she could have told everyone about Shyam right then and there... should have put the truth out and there ... and waited for the outcome... she should have slapped that B!@#$%#, kicked or clawed at Shyam on that night in the terrace for grabbing her...

Even Arnav could have saved her had he listened completely or would have confronted Khushi.
FairyLiquidSoap thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Firebolt

Rima yes that was one of the things that really struck a nerve with me.

But i guess i dont really look as deep as you do. I kind of stopped expecting things a long time ago.

Now i am just a mindless watcher. I ve put too much effort into this show to quit now.

BTW if you like Arnav and Khushi even one percent then the entire credit to Gul and her team. I alwaysremember Khushi in her chikni chameli avatar. Which was her brain child.

shriya the problem girl is Gul has behaved like the proverbial asian mother showing her preference more to the male than the female
She gave us a beautiful character called KKG which drew many intelligent viewers into watching this otherwise ordinary show and then she proceeded to strip her of every characteristic that made her unique her fiestiness her fighting spirit her charm her moral fiber
with ASR she has not tinkered too much with his intrinsic character and right now he is being built up at the cost of hers I would have admired her if she had made it a fair fight
If both had retained there core instead of weakening one to the point of emaciation and making the other strong by building custom made tracks dialogues situations and scenes then there would have been a huge round of applause for both her creations She gave us KKG but then she proceeded to treat her like a paraya dhan with limited rights
how you been have not seen you for some time girl😊
swathi

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".